Murders of John Brandenburg and Keith Bibbs

On October 18, 1983,[9] a middle-aged couple gathering wild mushrooms discovered two partially buried human skulls alongside an oak tree close to an abandoned farmhouse in Lake Village, Indiana.[10] The couple immediately reported their discovery to authorities.[4]

Indiana State Police investigators at the abandoned Lake Village farmhouse. October 19, 1983

Investigators discovered the partially decomposed bodies of four murder victims at this location.[11] Each victim had been deceased for several months,[12] and all four decedents had been partially buried, face upwards, with sections of the body of each victim remaining exposed above ground and loosely covered with leaves and soil, suggesting the murderer had made only rudimentary efforts to conceal each victim.[8]

Three of these victims were buried at one side of the tree, three feet apart, with their heads facing north. The fourth decedent was buried at the other side of this tree. All four victims had been bound and stabbed more than two dozen times,[1][3][13][14] and the trousers and underwear of each victim were discovered around their ankles. Furthermore, the body of one victim had been dismembered after death.[15]

All four murders were almost immediately linked to the collective manhunt for a serial killer known as the "Interstate Killer" and the "Highway Killer", who at the time of the discovery of these bodies was believed to have already murdered up to nineteen young males across several Midwestern States.[16][17] The level of decomposition of each victim and the clothing discovered upon each body suggested several weeks or months had elapsed between each murder. One victim had worn a parka, whereas the other three victims had worn clothing suggesting they had been murdered in the spring or summer.[18] In addition, evidence retrieved from the farmhouse would lead investigators to conclude the murderer had evidently used this location as a site to restrain and torture these victims before burying their bodies alongside the oak tree.[15]

By December 29, 1983,[19] two of these four murder victims had been identified via dental records as Michael Bauer and John Bartlett; both of whom had been murdered by the Highway Killer in early March 1983.[20][21] Contemporary investigators were unable to identify the third and fourth victims recovered at the site.[22][23]

Perpetrator's confession

Eyler confessed to these four murders in a statement posthumously released by his attorney, Kathleen Zellner, following his death due to AIDS-related complications in March 1994 while incarcerated on death row at the Pontiac Correctional Center.[n 1] His posthumous confession specifically states the two victims unidentified at the time of his death found at this abandoned farmhouse were the third and fourth victims he had murdered at this location.[25][26]

According to his posthumous confession, Adam was a hitchhiker who agreed to submit to a sexual act for $75; Brad was an individual whom Eyler claimed to have been introduced to by his alleged accomplice, Robert David Little, at his Terre Haute residence.[1] He was unaware of either of their actual identities.[19][n 2] In addition, he is known to have disposed of any forms of identification that he would find on his victims' possession.[1]

Keith Bibbs
Keith Bibbs c. 1983
Born	Approx. 1966 Chicago, Illinois
Disappeared	Indiana State Road 63, Terre Haute, Indiana
Status	Identified July 24, 2023
Died	c. July 11, 1983 (aged 16) Lake Village, Newton County, Indiana
Cause of death	Homicide by stabbing
Body discovered	October 18, 1983
Resting place	Riverside Cemetery, Brook, Indiana
Other names	"Adam", "Victim A," "Victim 3"
Known for	Formerly unidentified victim of homicide
Height	Between 5 ft 8 in (1.73 m) and 6 ft 2 in (1.88 m) (approximate)

Keith Lavell Bibbs[7] (formerly known as Adam) was the third of the four victims to be discovered at the burial site. This victim was believed to be around fifteen to eighteen years of age, although he may have been aged in his early twenties.[3][5] His hair was cut short and was black, and he was most likely between five feet eight inches and six feet two inches in height.[23][28][29][30] He had received several fillings in life.[31]

The clothing worn by this decedent included a distinctive red and black belt, inscribed with the word "devil" multiple times.[5] The buckle contained the word "jeans".[1] A pair of jeans and pajama bottoms were found on his remains, along with a pair of black size 12 suede boots. The boots were made in the Hush Puppies design and had metal buckles to fasten them on each side.[1][32]

As with the vast majority of Eyler's murder victims, this decedent was found with his trousers and underwear around his ankles.[22]

Eyler specifically stated this murder had been committed in July 1983,[22] and confirmed investigators' suspicions that the victim had been a hitchhiker whom he had lured into his vehicle near Indiana State Road 63 in Terre Haute, Indiana.[31]

Investigator Scott McCord correctly believed that Adam was likely native to the region, having initially speculated he may have been a Chicago or St. Louis native.[3]

In July 2020, the DNA Doe Project announced their intention to identify Adam using genetic genealogy.[33] In July 2023, Adam was formally identified via forensic genealogy as a 16-year-old Chicagoan named Keith Lavell Bibbs.[34][35]

Eyler's confession

In a formal confession released by Eyler's defense attorney, Kathleen Zellner, following her client's death, Eyler claimed that on a date he believed to be a Monday in early- or mid-July 1983, following several heated arguments with his boyfriend, John Dobrovolskis (whom Eyler had recently discovered to be engaging in a discreet sexual relationship with another man), Eyler had driven toward Terre Haute.[36] While traveling upon State Road 63, he had encountered a hitchhiker who he described as being aged in his late teens or early twenties. According to Eyler, he offered Bibbs seventy-five dollars to allow Eyler to bind and "perform a sexual act" upon him, to which Bibbs contemplated, then agreed to his proposition. After Eyler had plied Bibbs with vodka and ethchlorvynol, he drove him to the abandoned farmhouse in Lake Village where he had earlier murdered John Bartlett, Michael Bauer, and John Brandenburg. At this location, Bibbs was bound to a wooden post, blindfolded and gagged, then stabbed multiple times in his upper and lower midsection.[22]

According to Eyler, his last words to Bibbs were, "Okay, make your peace with God, nigger." He had then waited four or five minutes before stabbing him to death.[22] Eyler further claimed to have confessed to this murder to his alleged accomplice, Robert David Little, whom he claimed had asked him the question, "Did he grunt or did he groan?"[n 3]

Eyler's confession further revealed he had intentionally buried Bibbs separately from the three Caucasian victims he had previously murdered at this location as he did not believe it to be "proper" to bury an African-American alongside European Americans.[22]

John Brandenburg Jr.
John Brandenburg c. 1983
Born	February 14, 1964 Jefferson County, Kentucky
Disappeared	Chicago, Illinois
Status	Identified April 24, 2021
Died	c. May 29, 1983 (aged 19) Lake Village, Newton County, Indiana
Cause of death	Homicide by stabbing
Body discovered	October 19, 1983
Resting place	Rest Haven Cemetery, Corbin, Kentucky
Other names	"Brad," "Victim B," "Victim 4"
Known for	Formerly unidentified victim of homicide
Height	Between 5 ft 11 in (1.80 m) and 6 ft 1 in (1.85 m) (approximate)

John Ingram Brandenburg Jr.[38] (formerly known as Brad) was the fourth and final murder victim discovered at the abandoned farmhouse.[22] This victim was determined to be a white male most likely aged between seventeen and twenty-three years old.[5][n 4] He had medium length, reddish or auburn, wavy hair, weighed between 130 and 180 pounds[1] and was most likely between five feet eleven inches and six feet one inches in height.[n 5] This decedent had also received several fillings in life and, in the years prior to his murder, had severely fractured his nose and left ankle.[39][40] In addition, staining evident upon the teeth indicated he may have been a smoker.[31]

The clothing worn by this decedent included size 30x30 brown slacks, white jockey undershorts (which had been lowered to his ankles),[22] and size 10 brown leather hiking boots described as being ankle-high with a fleece interior.[41][42]

Reconstruction of the cross-like tattoo located on the underside of Brandenburg's right forearm

This decedent had two known tattoos on opposite sides of his right forearm—both of which were moderately preserved and recognizable.[43] One of these tattoos depicted either a crudely inscribed Chinese character or a cross with two circular marks. This tattoo was located on the underside of the decedent's arm close to the wrist; the other was a rectangular (or possibly U-shaped) marking containing one circular mark, which was located on the other side of his forearm.[41] The crude nature of these tattoos indicated a possibility this decedent may have served time in jail or a juvenile detention center in life.[36]

Eyler specifically stated this murder had been committed in either mid- or late-May 1983, on a date he believed his alleged accomplice, Robert Little, had been on a sabbatical from his employment as a library science professor at the Indiana State University.[28]

As with Adam, DNA was extracted from one of this decedent's bones in efforts to locate any individual who may be related to him whose DNA is contained within national public DNA databases. In April 2021, Brad was formally identified as a 19-year-old Kentucky native named John Brandenburg Jr., who had disappeared from Chicago in 1983.[22][44] He was last seen by his family leaving their home to visit a friend.[45]

In October 2016, a public funeral for Adam and Brad was held in Brook, Indiana. Both decedents—plus a further unidentified decedent known as Charlene Newton Doe whose death is unrelated to these cases[52]—were interred inside of a mausoleum in Riverside Cemetery in Brook, Indiana.[31]

One month after the April 2021 identification of John Brandenburg, his body was buried in Rest Haven Cemetery in Corbin, Kentucky.[53] Bibbs's body was returned to his family in September 2023.[54]

• Evans, Colin (1996). The Casebook of Forensic Detection: How Science Solved 100 of the World's Most Baffling Crimes. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. ISBN 978-0-471-07650-6.
• Finkelhor, David; Sedlak, Andrea; Hotaling, Gerald T. (1990). Missing, Abducted, Runaway, and Thrownaway Children in America. New York: Officers of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention. ISBN 0-788-12651-2.
• Halber, Deborah (2015). The Skeleton Crew: How Amateur Sleuths Are Solving America's Coldest Cases. New York: Simon & Schuster. ISBN 978-1-451-65758-6.
• Kolarik, Gera-Lind; Klatt, Wayne (1990). Freed to Kill: The True Story of Serial Murderer Larry Eyler. Garrett County Press. ISBN 978-1-939-43000-7.
• Newton, Michael (2004). The Encyclopedia of Unsolved Crimes. New York: Facts on File. ISBN 978-0-816-07818-9.
• Newton, Michael (2006). The Encyclopedia of Serial Killers. Infobase Publishing. ISBN 0-816-06195-5.
• Pettem, Silvia (2013). Cold Case Research: Resources for Unidentified, Missing, and Cold Homicide Cases. Boca Raton: CRC Press. ISBN 978-1-466-57053-5.
• Taylor, Karen T. (2000). Forensic Art and Illustration. New York: CRC Press. ISBN 978-0-849-38118-8.

Media related to Unidentified murder victims at Wikimedia Commons

• Eyler's formal confession to the murders of John Brandenburg and Keith Bibbs
• 2010 news article detailing ongoing efforts to identify Brandenburg and Bibbs
• The belt buckle worn by Bibbs
• DNA Doe Project article regarding the identification of Brandenburg
• DNA Doe Project article regarding the identification of Bibbs