Racial separate schools in Canada

In 1849, Malcolm Cameron, a member of the Legislative Assembly of the Province of Canada, proposed a School Bill allowing for segregated schools.[5] As a result of that bill, from 1850 in Upper Canada in the Province of Canada, provision was made for the establishment of separate schools for the Black community.[6][7] In 1886, Ontario clarified its law, so that such establishment could only occur after an application had been made by at least five Black families in the community.[8]

Instances of Black children in Canada West being excluded from public education occurred before the 1850 Act. A case in 1843 resulted in a petition signed by the "Coloured People of Hamilton" addressed to Governor-General, Charles T. Metcalfe, detailing their frustrations with the racial prejudice in their new home. The petition explains that the children of community members- many of whom arrived in Canada as freedom seekers, were continuously denied access to the same public schools attended by white children, and that community members sought redress from the Hamilton Board of Police to no avail. As taxpayers, the Black residents of Hamilton wanted confirmation of their rights to access, as their payments assisted in keeping the public schools operating.[9][10]  

After receiving the letter, Rev. Robert Murry from the Department of Education enlisted George S. Tiffany from the Hamilton Board of Police to assess the situation despite their previous involvement. Responding to Murry, Tiffany explained that “there is a strong prejudice existing amongst the lower orders of the whites against the coloured people,” and that people with such prejudice feared that parents of the white children would take them away if Black children were admitted into the schools. Tiffany ultimately advised against admitting Black children into public schools, stating, “it would not be advisable to yield to it, but that the law ought to be enforced without distinction of colour (...) if a firm stand be taken at first, the prejudice will soon give way.” [10][11]

Alongside the 1850 Act, Ontario’s court system was used to uphold the practice of racial segregation within education, as parents of Black students denied admission to white schools often sued common school trustees.[12] The case of Hill v. School of Trustees of Camden and Zone in the Court of Queen's Bench for Upper Canada is an example of this dynamic.

In this case, a Black man named Dennis Hill from the Camden Township wrote a letter to the Chief Superintendent for Education, Egerton Ryerson, detailing the racial discrimination his family faced by the trustees of School Section No. 3 in the Township of Camden County of Kent while attempting to admit their eleven-year-old son into a school with white children. According to Mr. Hill, school trustees denied his son entry into a school in his section on account of his race, while offering white children from outside the township and adjoining county attendance.[13] Ryerson replied, stating, “I cannot express any opinion upon the case which you submit,” suggesting that, if there was no separate school for his son to attend, Hill should prosecute for damages.[5]

The 1854 ruling on this case stated that Dennis Hill's children should attend a Black common school in the Dawn settlement near Dresden, called the British American Institute, which was a significant distance from their property.[14][5]

Further examples of the Court's support for racially separate schools include remarks made by Chief Justice Beverly Robinson in the same 1854 court ruling. Robinson stated that "separate schools for coloured people were authorized, as the defendants have suggested, out of deference to the prejudices of the white population." He continued to describe these prejudices, noting that the language used in legislation, which corresponded with the prejudices of the white population, arose from "an apprehension that the children of the coloured people, many of whom have but lately escaped from a state of slavery, may be, in respect to morals and habits, unfortunately worse trained than the white children are in general, and that their children might suffer from the effects of bad example."[14]

As Black students were frequently excluded from public education, Black community members often established their own schools or took on teaching positions.

As activists, Mary Bibb and her husband, Henry Bibb, initiated various projects to serve and uplift Canada West’s growing Black population, including establishing a school in Sandwich.[15] Mary Bibb established the school in the late winter of 1850, teaching twenty-five day and evening students in her home by January of the following year.[16] Her class, taught in her makeshift classroom, would soon grow while lacking funds and resources.[16] In an issue of The Voice of the Fugitive, Mary Bibb describes the conditions of the school as having started as an “ill ventilated room, uncomfortable seats, want of desks, books and all sorts of school apparatus.” [17] The school was not without community support, with Bibb going on to thank various supporters for their contributions, including enabling the school to get a blackboard and books.[17] Despite all efforts, the school ultimately closed down by 1852.[16]

In Ontario, separate schools for Black students continued until 1891 in Chatham, 1893 in Sandwich, 1907 in Harrow, 1917 in Amherstburg, and 1965 in North Colchester and Essex.[1] The laws in Ontario governing black separate schools were not repealed until the mid-1960s, and the last segregated schools to close were in Merlin, Ontario in 1965.[3][18]