Ritual (White Lies album)

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Album of the Year	54/100[7]
Metacritic	60/100[8]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[9]
BBC Music	(positive)[10]
Drowned In Sound	[11]
NME	[12]
Rolling Stone	[13]
Spin	[14]
Sputnikmusic	[15]
The Telegraph	[16]
Pitchfork	2.5/10[17]
Paste	8.4/10[18]

Ritual was met with mixed reviews from contemporary music critics. On review aggregator website, Metacritic, Ritual has an average score of 60 out of 100, indicating "mixed reviews" from 24 reviews.[19] Album of the Year gave Ritual an aggregate score of 54 out of 100 based on 23 critic reviews, indicating "mixed reviews".

Jeff Leven, writing for Paste praised Ritual, praising the instrumentation in particular. Leven said of Ritual that "the sonic touches, song structure and performances are often immaculate, adventurous and loaded with intent. There are rarely guitars for the sake of guitars, and the washes of sound conjure ebony skies in a way that obscures the identity of the players themselves in service of the tableau". Leven ultimately gave Ritual an 8.4 out of 10, which was the highest amongst contemporary professional critics. Brian Boyd of The Irish Times also praised Ritual, giving it the "Album of the Week" distinction. Boyd described the album as "prog goth", and gave extra praise the vocals of Harry McVeigh saying that McVeigh's voice is "big and bold, with an industrial undertow."[20] Boyd awarded the album a four out of five-star rating.[20]

In a more mixed review, Chris Mandle of the New Musical Express called Ritual felt the album was particularly derivative, comparing it to outtakes of Pornography by The Cure, or Turn on the Bright Lights by Interpol.[12] Mandle also felt that the songs were much longer than necessary saying that the tracks on Ritual are "a hole where the album’s heart should be. Ritual takes itself incredibly seriously, going so far as to stretch songs out to an average length of five minutes apiece lest their importance be lost.[12] It’s an album that speaks at you rather than to you, and whose only real method of connection is a well-crafted chorus or 10."[12] Mandle did disclaim that there "is nothing gravely wrong" with Ritual and offered praise to the album's production and hooks, saying "the grandiose production style of Alan Moulder is also put to good use, and in addition to the album’s crisp, gleaming sound." Mandle gave Ritual a three out of five-star rating.[12]

Gregory Heaney of Allmusic also offered a mixed review of the album. Heaney did offer praise for Ritual having a more distinct sound, allowing for White Lies to "step out of the shadow of the likes of (contemporary bands) Interpol and Editors".[9] Heaney did offer compliments to the breaks in the album's tense and ethereal content saying that the band's "ability to break up the gloom with the occasional soaring moment" is impressive.[9]

Writing for Pitchfork, Ian Cohen panned the album summarising Ritual as "wildly overwrought and painfully dull".[17] Cohen dismissed the album as poorly written, and with cringeworthy lyrics. Describing the sound of the album, he compared the album to bands like Glasvegas saying that "once you've lived through Glasvegas and such, so you should know the drill by now: guitars whoosh and whir to sound exactly like synthesizers while the actual synthesizer goo provides the empty calories required for nearly every track on Ritual to reach its completely arbitrary five-minute length."[17] Describing the instrumentation, Cohen said "The constant hi-hats and thrumming bass are meant to imply some sense of urgent momentum, and the inevitable half-time chorus lets McVeigh over-sing even more. Take all these ingredients, mix them together, and voila-- instant UK buzzband." Cohen ultimately gave Ritual a 2.5 out of 10.[17]

Stacy Anderson of Rolling Stone also was critical of Ritual critiquing the vocals on the album. Anderson said "when McVeigh beats you over the head with his bummed wail on "Bigger Than Us," you'll want to slip him some Wellbutrin." Anderson gave Ritual a two out of five-star rating.[13]

White Lies

• Harry McVeigh – lead vocals, guitar
• Charles Cave – bass guitar, backing vocals
• Jack Lawrence-Brown – drums

Additional personnel

• Alan Moulder – production
• Max Dingel – production