Rubber Soul

Recording for Rubber Soul began on 12 October 1965 at EMI Studios (now Abbey Road Studios) in London; final production and mix down took place on 15 November.[31] During the sessions, the Beatles typically focused on fine-tuning the musical arrangement for each song, an approach that reflected the growing division between the band as a live act and their ambitions as recording artists.[32] The album was one of the first projects that Martin undertook after leaving EMI's staff and co-founding Associated Independent Recording (AIR).[33] Martin later described Rubber Soul as "the first album to present a new, growing Beatles to the world",[34] adding: "For the first time we began to think of albums as art on their own, as complete entities."[35][36] It was the final Beatles album that recording engineer Norman Smith worked on before being promoted by EMI to record producer.[37] The sessions were held over thirteen days and totalled 113 hours, with a further seventeen hours (spread over six days) allowed for mixing.[33]

The Beatles interrupted the intensive recording for the album to receive their MBEs at Buckingham Palace.

The band were forced to work to a tight deadline to ensure the album was completed in time for a pre-Christmas release.[18] They were nevertheless in the unfamiliar position of being able to dedicate themselves solely to a recording project, free of touring, filming and radio engagements.[4] The Beatles ceded to two interruptions during this time.[38] They received their MBEs at Buckingham Palace on 26 October, from Queen Elizabeth II,[39] and on 1–2 November, the band filmed their segments for The Music of Lennon & McCartney, a Granada Television tribute to the Lennon–McCartney songwriting partnership.[40][41] According to author Christopher Bray, this intensive recording made Rubber Soul not just unusual in the Beatles' career but "emphatically unlike those LPs made by other bands".[42] From 4 November – by which point only around half the required number of songs were near completion – the Beatles' sessions were routinely booked to finish at 3 am each day.[43]

After A Hard Day's Night in 1964, Rubber Soul was the second Beatles album to contain only original material.[44] As the band's main writers, Lennon and McCartney struggled to complete enough songs for the project.[5][45] After a session on 27 October was cancelled due to a lack of new material, Martin told a reporter that he and the group "hope to resume next week" but would not consider recording songs by any other composers.[46] The Beatles completed "Wait" for the album, having taped its rhythm track during the sessions for Help! in June 1965.[47] They also recorded the instrumental "12-Bar Original", a twelve-bar blues in the style of Booker T. & the M.G.'s.[48] Credited to Lennon, McCartney, Harrison and Starr,[49] it remained unreleased until 1996.[50][nb 2]

The group recorded "Day Tripper" and "We Can Work It Out" during the Rubber Soul sessions for release as a single accompanying the album.[52] To avoid having to promote the single with numerous television appearances,[53][54] the Beatles chose to produce film clips for the two songs, the first time they had done so for a single.[55][56] Directed by Joe McGrath, the clips were filmed at Twickenham Film Studios in south-west London on 23 November.[57][58]

Lennon recalled that Rubber Soul was the first album over which the Beatles took control in the studio and made demands rather than accept standard recording practices.[60] According to Riley, the album reflects "a new affection for recording" over live performance.[61] Author Philip Norman similarly writes that, with the Beatles increasingly drawn towards EMI's large cache of "exotic" musical instruments, combined with their readiness to incorporate "every possible resource of the studio itself" and Martin's skills as a classical arranger, "Implicitly, from the very start, this [music] was not stuff intended to be played live on stage."[28]

According to Barry Miles, a leading figure in the UK underground whom Lennon and McCartney befriended at this time, Rubber Soul and its 1966 follow-up, Revolver, were "when [the Beatles] got away from George Martin, and became a creative entity unto themselves".[62] In 1995, Harrison said that Rubber Soul was his favourite Beatles album, adding: "we certainly knew we were making a good album. We did spend more time on it and tried new things. But the most important thing about it was that we were suddenly hearing sounds that we weren't able to hear before."[18][16]

During the sessions, McCartney played a solid-body Rickenbacker 4001 bass guitar, which produced a fuller sound than his hollow-body Hofner.[63][64] The Rickenbacker's design allowed for greater melodic precision, a characteristic that led McCartney to contribute more intricate bass lines.[63] For the rest of his Beatles career, the Rickenbacker would become McCartney's primary bass for studio work.[65] Harrison used a Fender Stratocaster for the first time, most notably in his lead guitar part on "Nowhere Man".[66] The variety in guitar tones throughout the album was also aided by Harrison and Lennon's use of capos, such as in the high-register parts on "If I Needed Someone" and "Girl".[63]

A sitar (top) and a Mannborg harmonium. Along with fuzz bass and varispeed-treated piano, these instruments were among the unusual sounds the band used for the first time during the Rubber Soul sessions.

On Rubber Soul, the Beatles departed from standard rock and roll instrumentation,[1] particularly in Harrison's use of the Indian sitar on "Norwegian Wood".[59] Having been introduced to the string instrument on the set of the 1965 film Help!, Harrison's interest was fuelled by fellow Indian music fans Roger McGuinn and David Crosby of the Byrds, partway through the Beatles' US tour.[67][nb 3] Music journalist Paul Du Noyer describes the sitar part as "simply a sign of the whole band's hunger for new musical colours", but also "the pivotal moment of Rubber Soul".[69] The Beatles also made use of harmonium during the sessions,[70][71] marking that instrument's introduction into rock music.[72]

The band's willingness to experiment with sound was further demonstrated in McCartney playing fuzz bass on "Think for Yourself"[73] over his standard bass part,[74] and their employing a piano made to sound like a baroque harpsichord on "In My Life".[75] The latter effect came about when, in response to Lennon suggesting he play something "like Bach",[76] Martin recorded the piano solo with the tape running at half-speed;[77] when played back at normal speed, the sped-up sound gave the illusion of a harpsichord.[78] In this way, the Beatles used the recording studio as a musical instrument, an approach that they and Martin developed further with Revolver.[79][80] In Prendergast's description, "bright ethnic percussion" was among the other "great sounds" that filled the album.[81]

Lennon, McCartney and Harrison's three-part harmony singing was another musical detail that came to typify the Rubber Soul sound.[70][82] According to musicologist Walter Everett, some of the vocal arrangements feature the same "pantonal planing of three-part root-position triads" adopted by the Byrds, who had initially based their harmonies on the style used by the Beatles and other British Invasion bands.[83] Riley says that the Beatles softened their music on Rubber Soul, yet by reverting to slower tempos they "draw attention to how much rhythm can do".[84] Wide separation in the stereo image ensured that subtleties in the musical arrangements were heard; in Riley's description, this quality emphasised the "richly textured" arrangements over "everything being stirred together into one high-velocity mass".[85][nb 4]

McCartney said that as part of their increased involvement in the album's production, the band members attended the mixing sessions rather than let Martin work in their absence.[20] Until late in their career, the "primary" version of the Beatles' albums was always the monophonic mix. According to Beatles historian Bruce Spizer, Martin and the EMI engineers devoted most of their time and attention to the mono mixdowns, and generally regarded stereo as a gimmick. The band were not usually present for the stereo mixing sessions.[87]

While Martin recalled the sessions as having been "a very joyful time",[88] Smith felt "something had happened between Help! and Rubber Soul", and the family atmosphere that had once characterised the relationship between the Beatles and their production team was absent.[89] He said the project revealed the first signs of artistic conflict between Lennon and McCartney,[90] and friction within the band as more effort was spent on perfecting each song.[89][nb 5] This also manifested in a struggle over which song should be the A-side of their next single, with Lennon insisting on "Day Tripper" (of which he was the primary writer)[93] and publicly contradicting EMI's announcement about the upcoming release.[94]

In addition, a rift was growing between McCartney and his bandmates as he continued to abstain from taking LSD.[95][96] The revelations provided by the drug had drawn Lennon and Harrison closer,[95][97] and were then shared by Starr when, during the band's stay in Los Angeles that August, he had agreed to try LSD for the first time.[98]

Pop historian Andrew Grant Jackson describes Rubber Soul as a "synthesis of folk, rock, soul, baroque, proto-psychedelia, and the sitar".[99] According to author Joe Harrington, the album contained the Beatles' first "psychedelic experiments", heralding the transformational effect of LSD on many of the original British Invasion acts.[100] Author Bernard Gendron dismisses the commonly held view that Rubber Soul is a folk rock album; he cites its incorporation of baroque and Eastern sounds as examples of the Beatles' "nascent experimentalism and eclectic power of appropriation", aspects that he says suggest an artistic approach that transcends the genre.[101][nb 6] According to The Encyclopedia of Country Music, building on the Beatles' 1964 track "I Don't Want to Spoil the Party", the album can be seen in retrospect as an early example of country rock, anticipating the Byrds' Sweetheart of the Rodeo album.[102]

Further to Lennon's more introspective outlook in 1964, particularly on Beatles for Sale, the lyrics on Rubber Soul represent a pronounced development in sophistication, thoughtfulness and ambiguity.[103] According to music critic Greil Marcus, "the Beatles were still writing about love, but this was a new kind of love: contingent, scary and vital", and so, while the music was "seduction, not assault", the "emotional touch" was tougher than before.[104] Author James Decker considers it significant that Rubber Soul "took its narrative cues more from folk crossovers such as Bob Dylan and the Byrds than from the Beatles' pop cohorts".[105] In particular, the relationships between the sexes moved from simpler boy-girl love songs to more nuanced and negative portrayals.[106] In this way, Lennon and McCartney offered candid insights into their respective personal lives.[107]

The album opens with a pair of lead guitar parts that are soon rendered off-metre by the arrival of McCartney's bass.[85] "Drive My Car" is a McCartney composition with substantial contribution from Lennon with the lyrics.[108][109] Harrison, as the Beatles' most knowledgeable soul-music enthusiast, contributed heavily to the recording by suggesting they arrange the song with a dual guitar–bass riff in the style of Otis Redding's contemporary single "Respect".[110] In their joint lead vocals, McCartney and Lennon sing dissonant harmonies,[111] a quality that is furthered by Harrison's entrance and signifies what Everett terms a "new jazzy sophistication … in the vocal arrangement".[112]

The lyrics convey an actress's desire to become a film star and her promise to the narrator that he can be her chauffeur.[113] According to Riley, the song satirises the "ethics of materialism" and serves as a "parody of the Beatles' celebrity status and the status-seekers they meet".[114] Author and critic Kenneth Womack describes the lyrics as being "loaded with sexual innuendo", and he says that the female protagonist challenged the gendered expectations of a mid-1960s pop audience, as an "everywoman" with ego and a clear agenda.[115]

Lennon said he wrote "Norwegian Wood" about an extramarital affair and that he worded the narrative to hide the truth from his wife, Cynthia.[116] The lyrics sketch a failed meeting between the singer and a mysterious girl, where she goes to bed and he sleeps in the bath;[117] in retaliation at the girl's aloofness, the singer decides to burn down her pine-panelled home.[118][nb 7] Arranged in 12/8 time,[120] and in the English folk style, the song has a Mixolydian melody that results in a drone effect in the acoustic guitars, complementing the sitar part, though switches to parallel scale of E Dorian during its middle eight.[121] The narrative draws heavily on Dylan's style through its use of ambiguity.[117][122] In author Jonathan Gould's description, the song is an "emotional black comedy",[111] while Decker recognises it as a continuation of the "interrogation of sexual ambiguities" and "muddled sense of power" displayed in "Drive My Car".[123]

Written by McCartney, "You Won't See Me" reflects the difficulties he was experiencing in his relationship with actress Jane Asher due to her refusal to put her acting career second to his needs.[124][125] Gould identifies the song as the third consecutive track in which the narrative conveys miscommunication.[126] McCartney described its music as "very Motown-flavored", with a "feel" inspired by Motown bassist James Jamerson.[127] The verses use the same chord sequence as the Four Tops' hit "It's the Same Old Song",[128] which was titled by its writers, the Holland–Dozier–Holland team, in acknowledgement that they had already used the same pattern in their composition "I Can't Help Myself".[124]

Lennon recalled that "Nowhere Man" came to him fully formed one night at his home in Surrey,[129] after he had struggled to write anything for several hours.[116][130] The song reflects the existential concerns raised by his experiences with LSD, and, like "I'm a Loser" and "Help!", his self-loathing[131] during a time he later called his "fat Elvis period".[132] It was the first Beatles song to completely avoid boy–girl relationships,[113][133] and through Lennon conveying his feelings of inadequacy in the third person,[134] the first example of a literary character in the Beatles' work.[135] Riley views the message as a precursor to the "I'd love to turn you on" theme of "A Day in the Life" and, aided by the band's performance, optimistic in tone as Lennon "sings for the unsung, the people who have shut themselves off from life".[136]

Heavy equalisation was applied to the electric guitar parts through a series of faders,[137] giving them a treble-rich texture that, as with the harmony vocals,[116] recalls the Byrds' sound.[138] In Prendergast's description, the track "burst[s] forth with all the gusto of newly discovered psychedelia", as Lennon's lead vocal "luxuriates in an opiated haze of production and Harrison's Fender Stratocaster solo fuzzes with all the right hallucinatory sparkle".[139]

Harrison's lyrics to "Think for Yourself" suggest the influence of Dylan's September 1965 single "Positively 4th Street", as Harrison appears to rebuke a friend or lover.[140] The song's accusatory message was unprecedented in the Beatles' work;[140] Jackson identifies it as the band's contribution to a "subgenre" of protest songs that emerged in 1965, in which artists railed against "oppressive conformity itself" rather than political issues.[141] Everett describes the composition as "a tour de force of altered scale degrees". He adds that, such is the ambiguity throughout, "its tonal quality forms the perfect conspirator with the text's and the rhythm's hesitations and unexpected turns."[142] Gould writes that, in its dialogue with Harrison's vocal, McCartney's fuzz bass suggests "the snarls of an enraged schnauzer, snapping and striking at its lead".[143]

In his book 1965: The Year Modern Britain Was Born, Bray recognises "The Word" as marking the start of the Beatles' "high psychedelic period".[145] Lennon's exhortation that "The word is love" anticipates the ethos behind the counterculture's 1967 Summer of Love.[146] The lyrics focus on the concept of universal love as a path to spiritual enlightenment, with what Decker terms "proselytizing zeal" on the narrator's part.[147] Author Ian MacDonald recognises the "distant influence" of Wilson Pickett's "In the Midnight Hour" and James Brown's "Papa's Got a Brand New Bag" on the song's rhythm, and highlights Starr's drumming (for its "feast of eccentric 'backwards fills'") and McCartney's dextrous bass playing.[124] The arrangement also includes seven vocal parts and Martin playing suspended chords on harmonium.[127]

"Michelle" was conceived by McCartney in the late 1950s. During a writing session for Rubber Soul, Lennon added a new middle eight, part of which was taken from Nina Simone's recent cover of "I Put a Spell on You".[148] MacDonald identifies the song as another example of the Beatles' "comedy song" approach, which, in a contemporary interview, McCartney had suggested was a possible new direction for the group.[149] In Womack's view, the French phrases in the lyrics accentuate the premise whereby a language barrier separates two lovers, and the narrative conveys an acceptance that their relationship is doomed to fail, such that the singer is already looking back nostalgically at what could have been.[150] Gould describes the performance as "sentimental … French cabaret" which, following McCartney's declaration of "I love you", leads into a guitar solo by Harrison that represents "one of Jean-Paul Sartre's existential café workers".[151]

The Beatles had attempted to record an early version of Lennon's "What Goes On" in 1963.[152][153] With little time to complete Rubber Soul, the song was reworked by Lennon and McCartney as a vocal spot for Starr,[154] who also received his first songwriting credit, as co-composer.[155] The song is in the country style favoured by Starr,[155] and in its lyrics the singer laments his lover's deceit.[64][156] In Everett's description, the arrangement includes Harrison's rockabilly-inflected lead guitar, played on his Gretsch Tennessean, contrasting with Lennon's "Steve Cropper-styled Memphis 'chick' rhythm part".[157]

Lennon said he wrote "Girl" about an archetypal woman he had been searching for and would finally find in Yoko Ono,[155][158] the Japanese artist he met in November 1966.[159] In the lyrics, he also expresses his disdain for Christian moral values.[155] The song was the final track recorded for the album.[158] The composition incorporates aspects of Greek folk music,[160] while the arrangement includes an instrumental passage set as a German two-step[161] and an acoustic guitar part played to sound like a Greek bouzouki.[162][nb 8] High equalisation was applied to Lennon's vocal over the choruses to capture the hissing sound as he drew breath[163] – an effect that also suggested he was inhaling on a marijuana joint.[164][165] McCartney recalled that he and Harrison sang "Tit-tit-tit" on the middle eights to capture the "innocence" of the Beach Boys singing "La-la-la" on one of their recent songs.[166] Riley likens the musical arrangement to a "scene from the old world" and he concludes of the song: "The old-fashioned atmosphere conveys desire and deception, and Lennon sings it as much to console himself as to make sense of its bewildering proportions ('And she promises the earth to me and I believe her/After all this time I don't know why'). It's the sympathetic side of the anger in 'Norwegian Wood.'"[167]

Like "You Won't See Me" and "We Can Work It Out", "I'm Looking Through You" focuses on McCartney's troubled relationship with Asher.[168] Gould describes it as the "disillusioned sequel" to McCartney's other 1965 songs centring on "a face-to-face (if not necessarily eye-to-eye) encounter between two lovers".[152] Decker likens the lyrics to a less philosophical version of "Think for Yourself" in which "the narrator has grown, yet the woman has failed to keep up."[169] The composition contrasts acoustic-based verses with harsher, R&B-style instrumental sections,[170] suggesting a combination of the folk rock and soul styles.[148] The Beatles had taped two versions of the song before achieving the final version,[171] which they recorded during the last, frantic day of the Rubber Soul sessions. In its final form, the song gained a middle eight where previously there had been a twelve-bar blues jam.[172][nb 9]

Lennon credited a remark made by BBC journalist Kenneth Allsop, who had asked why his songs appeared to lack the wordplay and childhood focus evident in his 1964 book In His Own Write, as the catalyst for "In My Life".[173] Lennon considered the song to be his "first real major piece of work".[70] The lyrics evoke his youth in Liverpool and reflect his nostalgia for a time before the onset of international fame.[155] McCartney recalled writing the melody on his own and said that the song's musical inspiration came from Smokey Robinson and the Miracles;[173][174] according to Lennon, McCartney merely assisted in writing what he called "the middle-eight melody".[175] In Gould's description, "In My Life" "owed a conscious debt" to the Miracles' contemporary hit "The Tracks of My Tears" and thereby served as "the most recent installment in the lively cultural exchange between Motown's Hitsville Studios and EMI's Abbey Road".[176][nb 10]

Martin's Bach-inspired piano solo was overdubbed in the Beatles' absence,[177] over a section that they had left empty.[178] Womack says that the baroque aspect of this contribution furthers the song's nostalgic qualities,[179] a point also made by Gould, who adds that, by revisiting the past and presenting emotional themes that are resolved in the narrative, "In My Life" serves as the album's only song that "sounds the Beatles' original ground theme of happiness-in-relationship".[180]

"Wait" was a Lennon composition to which McCartney contributed a middle eight.[163][181] Gould includes the song among a category of Beatles "'coming home' songs",[180] while Riley pairs it with "It Won't Be Long" but adds that, relative to that 1963 song, in "Wait" "the lovers' reunion has more anxiety than euphoria goading the beat."[181] The band completed the track on the final day of recording for the album, overdubbing tone-pedal lead guitar, percussion[182] and a new vocal by McCartney onto the June 1965 rhythm track.[183] MacDonald writes that, although Lennon and McCartney would most likely have viewed the subject matter as dated even in June, the group's performance gives the song the required "drive and character" for Rubber Soul, particularly Starr's approach to the rhythm changes between its contrasting sections.[184]

Harrison wrote "If I Needed Someone" as a love song to Pattie Boyd, the English model to whom he became engaged in December 1965 and married the following month.[185] In the song's Rickenbacker 12-string guitar riff, the Beatles returned the compliment paid to them earlier in 1965 by the Byrds,[186][187] whose jangly guitar-based sound McGuinn had sourced from Harrison's playing the previous year.[180][188] In MacDonald's view, the song is influenced "far more" by Indian classical music than by the Byrds, through Harrison's partly Mixolydian melody and the presence of drone.[189] The latter aspect is furthered by McCartney's arpeggiated bass line in A major continuing over the chord change to a ♭VII triad.[190]

The detached, dispassionate tone in the lyrics has invited alternative interpretations. Gould refers to it as "a rueful rain check of a love song" directed to the "right person at the wrong time";[191] according to Jackson, "the lyrics address all the women of the world, saying that had he met them earlier [before committing to Boyd], it might have worked out, but now he was too much in love (but give me your number just in case)."[192]

Lennon wrote "Run for Your Life" based on "Baby Let's Play House",[193] which was one of Presley's early singles on the Sun record label.[155] Lennon retained a line from the Presley track – "I'd rather see you dead, little girl, than to be with another man".[155][194] The lyrical theme is jealousy,[195] betraying an overtly misogynistic quality that Decker finds at odds with the Beatles' approach to making the album.[196][nb 11] Performed in the country style,[194] it was the first track recorded for the album and features a descending guitar riff played by Harrison and slide guitar parts.[198]

Adhering to the company's policy for the Beatles' albums in the United States, Capitol Records altered the content of Rubber Soul for its release there.[199][200] They removed "Drive My Car", "Nowhere Man", "What Goes On" and "If I Needed Someone", all of which were instead issued on the Beatles' next North American album, Yesterday and Today, in June 1966.[201] The four songs were replaced with "I've Just Seen a Face" and "It's Only Love",[202] which had been cut from Help! as part of Capitol's reconfiguring of that LP to serve as a true soundtrack album, consisting of Beatles songs and orchestral music from the film.[203]

Through the mix of predominantly acoustic-based songs, according to Womack, the North American release "takes on a decidedly folk-ish orientation".[204] Capitol sequenced "I've Just Seen a Face" as the opening track, reflecting the company's attempt to present Rubber Soul as a folk-rock album,[205][206] and "It's Only Love" opened side two.[207][nb 12] Gould writes that the omission of songs such as "Drive My Car" provided a "misleading idea" of the Beatles' musical direction and "turned the album title into an even more obscure joke", since the result was the band's least soul- or R&B-influenced album up to this point.[209] The stereo mixes used by Capitol contained two false starts at the beginning of "I'm Looking Through You",[204] while "The Word" also differed from the UK version due to the double-tracking of Lennon's lead vocal, the addition of an extra falsetto harmony, and the panning treatment given to one of the percussion parts.[210]

Critical response to Rubber Soul was highly favourable.[277] Allen Evans of the NME wrote that the band were "still finding different ways to make us enjoy listening to them" and described the LP as "a fine piece of recording artistry and adventure in group sound".[278][279] While outlining to American readers the differences in the UK-format release, KRLA Beat said Rubber Soul was an "unbelievably sensational" work on which the Beatles were "once again ... setting trends in this world of pop".[280] Newsweek lauded the Beatles as "the Bards of Pop",[281] saying that the album's combination of "gospel, country, baroque counterpoint and even French popular ballads" lent the band a unique style in which their songs were "as brilliantly original as any written today".[282] Like Newsweek, The New York Times had belittled the group when they first performed in America in February 1964, but following the release of Rubber Soul, entertainment critic Jack Gould wrote an effusive tribute in the newspaper's Sunday magazine.[283] In HiFi/Stereo Review, Morgan Ames wrote that, like other supportive professional musicians, he recognised the devices the band employed as "they tromp on the art of music", and while he viewed their formal musicality as limited, he expressed joy at its effectiveness. Having opened the review by saying, "The Beatles sound more and more like music", he concluded of the album: "Their blend is excellent, their performance smooth, and their charm, wit and excitement run high."[284]

The writers of Record Mirror's initial review found the LP lacking some of the variety of the group's previous releases but also said: "one marvels and wonders at the constant stream of melodic ingenuity stemming from the boys, both as performers and composers. Keeping up their pace of creativeness is quite fantastic."[285] By contrast, Richard Green wrote in the same magazine that most of the album "if recorded by anyone but the Beatles, would not be worthy of release", with many of the tracks devoid of "the old Beatles excitement and compulsiveness". Green acknowledged that his was an unpopular opinion, before stating: "Judging LPs strictly on their merits, recent albums from Manfred Mann, the Beach Boys and Jerry Lee Lewis rank high above Rubber Soul."[286]

In another review that Richard Williams later cited as an example of the British pop press not being "quite ready" for the album, Melody Maker found the Beatles' new sound "a little subdued" and said that tracks such as "You Won't See Me" and "Nowhere Man" "almost get monotonous – an un-Beatle-like feature if ever there was one".[287] Author Steve Turner also highlights the comments made by the Melody Maker and Record Mirror reviewers, who were typically aged over 30, as indicative of how UK pop journalists lacked "the critical vocabulary" and "the broad musical perspective" to recognise or engage with progressive music.[288] Turner adds that Rubber Soul "may have perplexed the old guard of entertainment correspondents, but it was a beacon for fledgling rock critics (as they would soon be called)".[252]

In a September 1966 review of Revolver, KRLA Beat said that the title of Rubber Soul had "become a standard phrase used to describe a creation of exceptional excellence in the field of music", such that several highly regarded releases had since earned the description "a 'Rubber Soul in its field'".[289][nb 19] Writing in Esquire in 1967, Robert Christgau called it "an album that for innovation, tightness, and lyrical intelligence was about twice as good as anything they or anyone else (except maybe the Stones) had done previously".[291]

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[1]
Blender	[292]
Consequence of Sound	A+[293]
The Daily Telegraph	[294]
Encyclopedia of Popular Music	[295]
MusicHound Rock	4/5[296]
Paste	97/100[297]
Pitchfork	10/10[298]
Q	[299]
The Rolling Stone Album Guide	[300]

According to Decker, notwithstanding the band's advances in 1964, music critics generally view Rubber Soul as the Beatles' "'transitional' album … from successful pop act to unparalleled masters of the studio".[105] It is frequently cited by commentators as the first of their "classic" albums.[301] Greil Marcus described it as the best of all the band's LPs.[302] In his 1979 essay on the Beatles in The Rolling Stone Illustrated History of Rock & Roll, Marcus wrote: "Rubber Soul was an album made as an album; with the exception of 'Michelle' (which, to be fair, paid the bills for years to come), every cut was an inspiration, something new and remarkable in and of itself."[303][nb 20]

Neil McCormick of The Daily Telegraph wrote in 2009: "this is where things start to get very interesting ... Rubber Soul is the result of their first extended period in the studio. The production is open and spacious, adorned but not yet overcrowded with new instruments and ideas. The songs themselves are like little Pop Art vignettes, where the lyrics are starting to match the quality of the melodies and arrangements."[305] Scott Plagenhoef of Pitchfork describes the album as "the most important artistic leap in the Beatles' career – the signpost that signaled a shift away from Beatlemania and the heavy demands of teen pop, toward more introspective, adult subject matter".[298] Paul Du Noyer wrote in his review for Blender in 2004: "Their talent was already a source of wonder, but now the songs themselves were turning mysterious. Under the influence of Bob Dylan – and, it might be said, marijuana – the Fab Four laced their tunefulness with new introspection, wordplay and social comment. University professors and newspaper columnists started taking note."[292]

Writing in Paste, Mark Kemp says that the influence of Dylan and the Byrds seems overt at times but the album marks the start of the Beatles' peak in creativity and, in the context of 1965, offered "an unprecedented synthesis of elements from folk-rock and beyond".[297] According to Richie Unterberger of AllMusic, the album's lyrics represented "a quantum leap in terms of thoughtfulness, maturity, and complex ambiguities", while the music was similarly progressive in its use of sounds beyond "the conventional instrumental parameters of the rock group". He adds that Rubber Soul is "full of great tunes" from Lennon and McCartney notwithstanding their divergence from a common style, and demonstrates that Harrison "was also developing into a fine songwriter".[1] Writing in the Encyclopedia of Popular Music, Colin Larkin describes it as "not a collection of would-be hits or favourite cover versions … but a startlingly diverse collection, ranging from the pointed satire of 'Nowhere Man' to the intensely reflective 'In My Life'."[306] In the 2004 edition of The Rolling Stone Album Guide, Rob Sheffield recognises Help! as "the first chapter in the [Beatles'] astounding creative takeoff", after which the band "grew up with an album of bittersweet romance, singing adult love ballads that feel worldly but not jaded".[307]

In an article coinciding with the 50th anniversary of its release, for The Guardian, Bob Stanley lamented that Rubber Soul was often overlooked in appraisals of the Beatles' recording career, whereas Revolver and The Beatles had each gained in stature to surpass Sgt. Pepper. Stanley highlighted Rubber Soul as having been "a good 18 months ahead of its time" and "the first album of the rock era that sounded like an album".[308] Also writing in December 2015, in Rolling Stone, Sheffield especially admired the singing and the modern qualities of the female characters depicted in the lyrics. He said that the album was "way ahead of what anyone had done before" and, given the short period in which they had to record, he called it the Beatles' "accidental masterpiece".[309]

Conversely, Jon Friedman of Esquire finds the work vastly overrated, with only the Lennon-dominated songs "Norwegian Wood", "Nowhere Man", "In My Life" and "Girl" worthy of praise, and he dismisses it as "dull" and "the Beatles' most inconsequential album".[310] Although he considers that McCartney "comes off third-string" to Lennon and Harrison, Plagenhoef defends the album's subtle mood; highlighting the influence of cannabis on the Beatles throughout 1965, he writes: "With its patient pace and languid tones, Rubber Soul is an altogether much more mellow record than anything the Beatles had done before, or would do again. It's a fitting product from a quartet just beginning to explore their inner selves on record."[298] In his review for Rough Guides, Chris Ingham highlights the musical arrangements, three-part harmonies and judicious use of new sounds, in addition to the band's improved musicianship and songwriting. He says that Rubber Soul usually trails the Beatles' next four albums in critics' assessments of their work, yet "it's undoubtedly their pre-acid, pre-antagonism masterpiece: beat music as high art".[107][nb 21]

Music historian Bill Martin says that the release of Rubber Soul was a "turning point" for pop music, in that for the first time "the album rather than the song became the basic unit of artistic production."[312] In author David Howard's description, "pop's stakes had been raised into the stratosphere" by Rubber Soul, resulting in a shift in focus from singles to creating albums without the usual filler tracks.[313] The release marked the start of a period when other artists, in an attempt to emulate the Beatles' achievement, sought to create albums as works of artistic merit[313][314] and with increasingly novel sounds.[315] According to Steve Turner, by galvanising the Beatles' most ambitious rivals in Britain and America, Rubber Soul launched "the pop equivalent of an arms race".[316]

Brian Wilson of the Beach Boys described Rubber Soul as "the first album I listened to where every song was a gas" and planned his band's next project, Pet Sounds, as an attempt to surpass it.[317] Rubber Soul similarly inspired Pete Townshend of the Who and the Kinks' Ray Davies,[318] as well as Jagger and Keith Richards of the Rolling Stones, who issued their first album of all-original material, Aftermath, in April 1966.[314] The album was also an influence on Bob Dylan, Stevie Wonder[238] and the Byrds.[9] John Cale recalled that Rubber Soul was an inspiration as he and Lou Reed developed their band the Velvet Underground. He said it was the first time "you were forced to deal with them as something other than a flash in the pan" and especially admired Harrison's introduction of Indian sounds.[319]

In his chapter on Rubber Soul in the Cambridge Companion to Music's volume on the Beatles, James Decker credits the album with effecting the "transformation" of 1960s pop.[15] In addition to citing it as the precedent for early experimental works by bands including Love and Jefferson Airplane, Decker writes that Rubber Soul presented "a variety of techniques hitherto unexplored in popular music" while encouraging listeners "to be cognizant of more flexible dimensions of pop music and to desire and expect them as well".[320] Music historian Simon Philo also sees it as heralding the experimentation that characterised late-1960s rock. He describes it as an album-length confirmation of the "transformation of pop's range and reach" that the Beatles had first achieved when "Yesterday", McCartney's introspective and classically orchestrated ballad, topped US singles charts in late 1965.[321] In a 1968 article on the Beach Boys, Gene Sculatti of Jazz & Pop recognised Rubber Soul as the model for Pet Sounds and Aftermath, as well as "the necessary prototype that no major rock group has been able to ignore".[322][nb 22]

Rubber Soul is widely viewed as the first pop album to make an artistic statement through the quality of its songs,[323] a point that was reinforced by its artsy cover photo.[253] The belated acceptance of the Beatles by the editors of Newsweek was indicative of the magazine's recognition of the band's popularity among American intellectuals and the cultural elite.[324] This in turn was reflected in The Village Voice's appointment of Richard Goldstein, a recent graduate and New Journalism writer, to the new position of rock critic, in June 1966,[325] and the Beatles' central role in achieving cultural legitimisation for pop music over 1966–67.[326][nb 23] Referring to the praise afforded the band, particularly the Lennon–McCartney parternship, by Newsweek in early 1966, Michael Frontani writes: "The Beatles had a foothold in the world of art; in the months that followed, their efforts would lead to the full acceptance and legitimization of rock and roll as an art form."[330]

Paul Williams launched Crawdaddy! in February 1966 with the aim of reflecting the sophistication brought to the genre by Rubber Soul and Dylan's Bringing It All Back Home – the two albums that, in music journalist Barney Hoskyns' description, "arguably gave birth to 'rock' as a more solid concept than 'pop'".[331] According to Sculatti, Rubber Soul was "the definitive 'rock as art' album, revolutionary in that it was a completely successful creative endeavor integrating with precision all aspects of the creative (rock) process – composition of individual tracks done with extreme care, each track arranged appropriately to fit beside each other track, the symmetrical rock 'n' roll album".[322] Christopher Bray describes it as "the album that proved that rock and roll could be suitable for adult audiences", "the first long-playing pop record to really merit the term 'album'" and the LP that "turned pop music into high art".[332] Historian Marc Myers similarly credits it with "mark[ing] rock's shift from formulaic pop to studio experimentation and high art".[238]

According to Du Noyer, through Rubber Soul's blurring of the traditionally distinct dividing line between pop and high culture, and the perceived inferiority of singles, "a rift occurred [in the UK] between pop and rock". He quotes writer Nik Cohn's complaints that the "danger signs" for pop music's loss of innocence were apparent on Rubber Soul, and poet Philip Larkin's comment that "[The Beatles'] fans stayed with them, and the nuttier intelligentsia, but they lost the typists in the Cavern." Du Noyer says the album started a process that grew to become a "gulf between albums and singles, between rock or pop" that "shape[d] British music for decades".[9]

Jefferson Airplane performing in June 1967. Rubber Soul especially resonated with musicians in the emerging San Francisco scene.

The album coincided with rock 'n' roll's development into a variety of new styles, a process in which the Beatles' influence ensured them a pre-eminent role.[100] Andrew Loog Oldham, the Rolling Stones' manager and producer at the time, has described Rubber Soul as "the album that changed the musical world we lived in then to the one we still live in today".[333][nb 24] "Norwegian Wood" launched what Indian classical musician Ravi Shankar called "the great sitar explosion",[334] as the Indian string instrument became a popular feature in raga rock[335][336] and for many pop artists seeking to add an exotic quality to their music.[337] The harpsichord-like solo on "In My Life" led to a wave of baroque rock recordings.[338][339] Rubber Soul was also the release that encouraged many folk-music aficionados to embrace pop.[209] Folk singer Roy Harper recalled: "They'd come onto my turf, got there before me, and they were kings of it, overnight. We'd all been outflanked ..."[319][nb 25]

Author George Case, writing in his book Out of Our Heads, identifies Rubber Soul as "the authentic beginning of the psychedelic era".[27] Music journalist Mark Ellen similarly credits the album with having "sow[ed] the seeds of psychedelia",[333] while Christgau says that "psychedelia starts here."[340][nb 26] Writing in The Sydney Morning Herald in July 1966, Lillian Roxon reported on the new trend for psychedelia-themed clubs and events in the US and said that Rubber Soul was "the classic psychedelic album now played at all the psychedelic discotheques". She attributed pop's recent embrace of psychedelia and "many of the strange new sounds now in records" to the LP's influence.[341]

In Myers' view, the Capitol release "changed the direction of American rock".[342] In the ongoing process of reciprocal influence between the band and US folk rock acts, the Beatles went on to inspire the San Francisco music scene.[340] Recalling the album's popularity in the Haight-Ashbury district of San Francisco, where Jefferson Airplane were based,[343] journalist Charles Perry said: "You could party hop all night and hear nothing but Rubber Soul."[344] Perry also wrote that "More than ever the Beatles were the soundtrack of the Haight-Ashbury, Berkeley and the whole circuit", where pre-hippie students suspected that the album was inspired by drugs.[345]

Citing a quantitative study of tempos in music from the 1960s, Walter Everett identifies Rubber Soul as a work that was "made more to be thought about than danced to", and an album that "began a far-reaching trend" in its slowing-down of the tempos typically used in pop and rock music.[346] While music historians typically credit Sgt. Pepper as the birth of progressive rock,[347] Everett and Bill Martin recognise Rubber Soul as the inspiration for many of the bands working in that genre from the early 1970s.[312][348][nb 27]

Rubber Soul was voted fifth in Paul Gambaccini's 1978 book Critic's Choice: Top 200 Albums,[350] based on submissions from a panel of 47 critics and broadcasters including Richard Williams,[351] Christgau and Marcus.[352] In the first edition of Colin Larkin's book All Time Top 1000 Albums, in 1994, it was ranked at number 10,[353] and in 1998 it was voted the 39th greatest album of all time in the first "Music of the Millennium" poll,[354] conducted by HMV and Channel 4.[355] It was listed at number 34 in the third edition of Larkin's All Time Top 1000 Albums, published in 2000.[356][357]

Since 2001, Rubber Soul has appeared in critics' best-albums-of-all-time lists compiled by VH1 (at number 6),[358] Mojo (number 27) and Rolling Stone (number 5).[204] It was among Time magazine's selection of the "All-Time 100 Albums" in 2006[359] and was favoured over Revolver in Chris Smith's book 101 Albums That Changed Popular Music three years later.[360][361] In 2012, Rolling Stone again placed it at number 5 on the magazine's revised list of the "500 Greatest Albums of All Time".[73] In September 2020, Rubber Soul was ranked at number 35 on the same publication's new list.[362]

Rubber Soul appeared in Rolling Stone's 2014 list of the "40 Most Groundbreaking Albums of All Time", where the editors concluded: "You can say this represents 'maturity,' call it 'art' or credit it for moving rock away from singles to album-length statements – but regardless Rubber Soul accelerated popular music's creative arms race, driving competitors like the Stones, the Beach Boys and Dylan to dismantle expectations and create new ones."[363] Three years later, Pitchfork ranked it at number 46 on the website's "200 Best Albums of the 1960s". In his commentary with the entry, Ian Cohen wrote: "Every Beatles album fundamentally shaped how pop music is understood, so Rubber Soul is one of the most important records ever made, by default ... Even in 2017, whenever a pop singer makes a serious turn, or an anointed serious band says they've learned to embrace pop, Rubber Soul can't help but enter the conversation."[364]

In 2000, Rubber Soul was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame,[250] an award bestowed by the American Recording Academy "to honor recordings of lasting qualitative or historical significance that are at least 25 years old".[365] The album has been the subject of multi-artist tribute albums such as This Bird Has Flown and Rubber Folk.[204] Writing in December 2015, Ilan Mochari of Inc. magazine commented on the unusual aspect of a pop album's 50th anniversary being celebrated, and added: "Over the next several years, you can bet you'll read about the 50th anniversary of many other albums – thematic volumes composed by bands or songwriters in the tradition Rubber Soul established. All of which is to say: Rubber Soul, the Beatles' sixth studio album, was the record that launched a thousand ships."[342]

Compared to the UK/worldwide release, the original North American release of Rubber Soul drops four tracks ("Drive My Car", "Nowhere Man", "What Goes On" and "If I Needed Someone") and adds two others ("I've Just Seen A Face" and "It's Only Love"). In addition, the mixes (supervised by Dave Dexter Jr.) are in some cases slightly different from the UK/worldwide versions. Notably, the North American stereo version of "I'm Looking Through You" contains two false guitar starts not heard elsewhere, while "The Word" also differs from the UK version with several different and additional vocal parts, and the panning treatment given to one of the percussion parts.[210]