Spike of Bensonhurst

Spike Fumo is a young Italian-American man who lives in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn and aspires to be a boxer. He hopes to impress the local mob boss, Baldo Cacetti, so that he will become his sponsor. However, Cacetti knows Spike only competes in fixed matches, so he turns down the offer. Spike reminds Cacetti that his father went to prison for working for him, so Cacetti gives Spike a job collecting money for his numbers racket.

Spike meets the young woman Angel when she shows up to one of his boxing matches with her boyfriend, Justin. Angel also happens to be Cacetti's daughter. Cacetti makes clear to Spike that he does not want his daughter with Spike as he thinks Justin, who attends college and is the son of a congresswoman, is upwardly mobile and thus a better fit for her. Cacetti orders Spike to leave Bensonhurst, even though Angel prefers to be with him.

Spike ends up in a predominantly Puerto Rican section of Red Hook, where Bandana, one of his boxing friends, lives. Bandana invites Spike to live at his apartment. Spike is appalled at the decaying state of the neighborhood and manages to scare off loiterers and drug addicts away from the apartment building. Bandana's mother thanks him for the gesture and introduces him to her teenage daughter, India.

While living in Red Hook, Spike continues to train with Bandana at the local gym and begins a relationship with India. One day, Spike calls his friend Frankie to deliver his old boxing equipment. Frankie arrives with a now pregnant Angel accompanying him. Angel informs Spike that her father is still against their union. Soon after, Spike learns that India is also pregnant.

Back in Bensonhurst, Angel tries to convince her father that Spike could make something out of his life if only he helped him. Cacetti relents and arranges for Spike to win a fixed match in Bensonhurst. Spike believes this match is his chance to return to Bensonhurst and marry Angel. He tells India although he loves her, he cannot stay and returns to his old neighborhood. Cacetti's plan for Spike goes awry when he catches his wife Sylvia asleep in bed with Spike, though it is a misunderstanding and the two merely fell asleep together after playing cards. Cacetti orders for Spike to lose the match instead.

When Spike discovers these plans, he angrily defies them and knocks out his opponent in the first round. Angel arrives at the banquet hall with Justin. Cacetti has his men take Spike to the kitchen, where Angel pleads with her father and tells him although she does not want to marry Spike, she doesn’t want to see him murdered, either. Cacetti agrees to spare Spike's life, but he allows his men to break his right hand. Angel goes on to marry Justin and gives birth to Spike’s son. Spike returns to Red Hook, marries India, and becomes a police officer. Cacetti, having forgiven Spike, takes his grandson to visit Spike, India, and their new family.

Roger Ebert gave the film 3 out of 4 stars and said the film is "not the best comedy ever made but has energy and local color and a charismatic lead performance by Sasha Mitchell as Spike."[3] He called Borgnine's performance the "funniest in a long time" and added, "The domestic arrangements of a middle-class Mafia household are examined here as hilariously as in Married to the Mob, and if we do not care much about the final fight by the time it comes, well, neither do the fighters."[3] In response to claims that the movie "is generated mostly out of broad stereotypes" of Italians and Puerto Ricans, Ebert wrote, "I do not think the filmmakers or the actors had any racist intents. I think they were inspired more by the ethnic humor of TV sitcoms and movies like Saturday Night Fever."[3]

Janet Maslin of The New York Times wrote while the film "doesn't have the sharpest satirical edge...it does have personality".[4] Kevin Thomas of the Los Angeles Times wrote the film "has to buck the truth that comedies about Italian-Americans and the Mafia are beginning to wear a bit thin. With his outrageous sense of humor Morrissey turns this seeming obstacle to great advantage only to be slowed down by too much plot. The film begins to lose steam after its first hour and becomes dragged-out. Luckily, there’s as compensation for this drawback--a roster of rousing performances. Newcomer Mitchell is a breezy charmer; Borgnine is fresh and canny in a jewel of a portrayal; Anne DeSalvo is a likeably smart cookie as Baldo’s wife, and Antonia Rey practically walks off with the movie as an exuberant Puerto Rican mother. Best of all, Spike of Bensonhurst...boasts a finish that takes your breath away in its utter lack of sentimentality."[5]

Independent Spirit Awards

• 1989: Nominated, "Best Supporting Male" - Ernest Borgnine[6]

• Spike of Bensonhurst at IMDb
• Spike of Bensonhurst at AllMovie
• Spike of Bensonhurst at Rotten Tomatoes