Starcatcher (album)

According to drummer Danny Wagner, "We had this idea that we wanted to tell these stories to build a universe. We wanted to introduce characters and motifs and these ideas that would come about here and there throughout our careers through this world."[5]

During an interview in 2022, bassist Sam Kiszka stated that the album would go back to a more raw sound, being conceptually almost going back to their days in the garage. He also went on to say how the album will be an expansion of the band's sound. Furthermore, he stated how the band is "bringing our heads back to that garage time" and "making [the album] exciting and raw and energetic".[5]

The album was first announced on social media following the final three shows of the Dreams in Gold Tour, in which the band played the new tracks "Meeting the Master", "The Falling Sky", "Indigo Streak", "Sacred the Thread", and "Farewell for Now".[6][7] The track "Meeting the Master" was released on April 7, 2023, as the lead single from the album.[8][9] The track "Sacred the Thread" was released on May 19, 2023 as the second single, and the track "Farewell for Now" was released June 9, 2023 as the third single.[10][11] The track "The Falling Sky" was released on June 27, 2023 as the fourth single.[12] The world tour in promotion of the album began in Nashville, Tennessee on July 24, 2023.[13][14]

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Metacritic	59/100[15]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[16]
Kerrang!	4/5[17]
Mojo	[18]
Sputnikmusic	1.0/5[19]
Uncut	5/10[20]

Starcatcher received a score of 59 out of 100 on review aggregator Metacritic based on seven critics' reviews, indicating "mixed or average" reception.[15] Both Mojo and Uncut compared select tracks on the album to Led Zeppelin's songs, with Mojo saying "Fate of the Faithful" sounds like "No Quarter" and "Meeting the Master" sounds like "Thank You", and Uncut pointing out the harmonica from "When the Levee Breaks" is imitated on "The Falling Sky", while its beat is used on "Sacred the Thread", but neither helps the songs "stick in the memory".[20][18]

Rolling Stone's David Browne stated that while there are a "few new" elements to the album, it is "simply impossible to listen to Starcatcher and, as with all their previous work, not think you've stumbled upon a vault of outtakes from Led Zeppelin and some of their peers".[21] A staff reviewer from Sputnikmusic dismissed the album as "a record so entrenched in referencing other music that it ceases to be artistic expression, and is entirely separated from expression as a concept, floating in its own sterility".[19]

Stephen Thomas Erlewine of AllMusic wrote that the band are "stripping away the studio gloss so they can stand on their merits as a rock & roll band" and "the lack of polish on Starcatcher does make Greta Van Fleet seem leaner, but not meaner".[16] Steve Beebee of Kerrang! described the album as "the work of a band not phased by success, but continuing to develop its art. With a nod to the classic rock that inspired them, Greta Van Fleet continue to contort those great influences in challenging and evocative new directions".[17] Classic Rock stated that it "feels like their most consistent and complete record yet".[15]

Greta Van Fleet

• Joshua Kiszka – vocals, background vocals
• Jacob Kiszka – guitar, backing vocals
• Samuel Kiszka – bass guitar, keyboards, background vocals
• Daniel Wagner – drums, background vocals

Technical

• Dave Cobb – production
• Greg Gordon – engineering
• Phillip Smith – additional engineering
• Greg Gordon – mixing
• Dave Cobb – mixing
• Pete Lyman – mastering