Thayer Melvin

Thayer Melvin was born on November 15, 1835, in Fairview, Virginia.[1][2][3][lower-alpha 1] The eldest of five children, he was the son of James Melvin and his wife Philenia Thayer Melvin.[1][3][6] Melvin's father James, of Irish descent, was from Pennsylvania.[1]

Melvin received his early education in the common primary and secondary schools in Hancock and other neighboring counties.[1][2] He commenced his studies in jurisprudence at the age of 17 in New Manchester, which was then the county seat of Hancock, and received his law books and instruction from the town's lawyers.[1][2] Melvin then relocated to New Lisbon, Ohio, for a year to further his law studies under the instruction of a friend.[2][3] In 1853, at the age of 18, he passed his bar examination and was admitted to the bar of Hancock County.[1][2][7] Melvin then practiced law in association with O. W. Langfitt in New Manchester.[8]

In 1855, Melvin was elected as the Commonwealth's attorney of Hancock County, despite the fact that he was under the required minimum age of 21 to hold public office.[1][2][7] He was twice reelected for full terms to the position in 1856 and 1860.[1][2][3] Melvin continued to serve as Hancock County's prosecuting attorney notwithstanding his relocation to Wheeling in 1857.[1][2] Following his move to Wheeling, he established a law practice known as Pendleton & Melvin with Joseph H. Pendleton, who was one of the city's preeminent lawyers.[1][2][7] During this period, Melvin was affiliated with the Whig Party.[9]

In May 1861, Melvin served as a delegate from Hancock County to the First Wheeling Convention.[10] Following the onset of the American Civil War, he volunteered as a private in Company F of the 1st West Virginia Volunteer Infantry Regiment of the Union Army.[1][2][7] Melvin served first as an orderly sergeant and then as a first lieutenant of his company.[1][3] In August 1861, he organized a company for state service with its headquarters in his hometown of Fairview.[11] By April 1862, while still a lieutenant, Melvin had received a commission as Adjutant general of Volunteers on the staff of Brigadier General Benjamin Franklin Kelley in the Department of West Virginia.[1][7][12][13]

On August 12, 1863, in his role as adjutant general, Melvin delivered orders to Major General William W. Averell for the procurement of the law books of the Library of the Supreme Court of Virginia in Lewisburg and to place officers in charge of them for their transport to safekeeping in Beverly.[14] Because the library had been purchased for the western part of Virginia, Kelley averred that the library "rightfully belongs to the new State of West Virginia. Our judges need it very much".[14] Melvin then served on the staff of General Philip Sheridan during the Shenandoah Valley Campaigns of 1864.[15]

As the adjutant general for the Department of West Virginia, Melvin served under the department's succeeding commanding officers: Brigadier General Kelley, Major General Franz Sigel, Major General David Hunter, Major General George Crook, and Major General William H. Emory.[15]

Melvin served as an adjutant and chief of staff to Kelley while he was in command of the garrison guarding the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad in Cumberland, Maryland, which was then the headquarters of the Department of West Virginia military district.[16][17] By this time, he was serving with the military rank of Captain.[18][19] In the early morning of February 21, 1865, the Confederate partisans known as McNeill's Rangers sent two detachments behind enemy lines to capture Kelley and his superior Major General Crook from their hotels in Cumberland.[16][17][20] One of the two detachments was sent to the Barnum House hotel, where Melvin and Kelley were staying.[16][20][21] Other sources claim the two were staying at the St. Nicholas Hotel, where William McKinley had been lodged.[18][19]

At their hotel, McNeill's Rangers private Sprigg Lynn was directed to Melvin's room first, and then to Kelley's.[16][21] The men were forced to dress at gunpoint and were taken captive along with Crook, who had been staying at the Revere House hotel.[16][21] Melvin, Kelley, and Crook were sent to Libby Prison in Richmond, and were exchanged for Confederate general Isaac R. Trimble and a guarantee from General Ulysses S. Grant that the treatment of captured McNeill's Rangers imprisoned at Fort McHenry would be improved.[16][20][22] An article published in Richmond's Enquirer newspaper claimed that Melvin had been caught in bed with "a blushing bride" by McNeill's men during his capture; however, Wheeling's Daily Intelligencer newspaper reminded its readers that the story was baseless, as Melvin was unmarried.[23][24]

Following his release, Melvin served as an adjutant until the end of the war in 1865.[1][2] That year, he was honorably discharged as a brevet colonel from the Union Army in recognition of his meritorious services in the line of duty.[1][2][3]

In the fall of 1865, Melvin was elected prosecuting attorney of Hardy County in the Potomac Highlands of West Virginia.[25] In 1866 he relocated to Wellsburg in Brooke County where he resumed the practice of law.[1][2][15] He became a Republican following the war and remained affiliated with the party until his death although he was never a strong partisan.[9] In 1866, he was again elected as the prosecuting attorney for Hancock County, despite residing in Brooke County.[1][2]

In 1866, Melvin was nominated as the Republican candidate for Attorney General of West Virginia, and he won his election to the position with 23,509 votes,[1][15][26] receiving the highest number of votes cast for an attorney in West Virginia's brief three-year history.[26] On January 1, 1867, Melvin began his one-year tenure as attorney general; he was renominated on June 4, 1868, at the West Virginia Republican Convention and reelected to the position in fall 1868.[1][2][27][28] He served in the office until his resignation on July 1, 1869.[1][2][27] Melvin resigned his post as attorney general to accept an appointment to a circuit judgeship of the First Judicial District of West Virginia which comprised Brooke, Hancock, Marshall, and Ohio counties.[1][2][29] He had been appointed to the judgeship by West Virginia Governor William E. Stevenson to fill the vacancy caused by the death of Elbert H. Caldwell.[2][30][31]

While serving as a circuit judge, Melvin was appointed by the governor to assist in completing the codification of West Virginia state laws.[32][33] Following a dispute between Charles Town and Shepherdstown over the location of Jefferson County's court, he was selected to serve as the circuit court judge in Charles Town for the fall term, which began on September 12, 1872.[34][35] On August 24, 1872, Melvin was elected for a full eight-year term as judge of the First Judicial District, which began on January 1, 1873.[32][36][37]

In 1873, Melvin refused to transfer the case of Taylor Strauder, a black man, to a federal court following his indictment by an all-white Ohio County grand jury for the murder of his wife.[38] Strauder and his lawyers argued that he would not receive equal treatment in the West Virginia courts due to its all-white jury law and cited the Civil Rights Act of 1866 for a transfer to a federal court.[38] Following Melvin's ruling, Strauder's murder trial proceeded in the Ohio County court in May 1873, and he was inevitably convicted by an all-white jury.[38] Strauder appealed his conviction to the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia and finally to the Supreme Court of the United States, where his case Strauder v. West Virginia 100 U.S. 303 (1879) was decided on March 1, 1880.[39][40] The Supreme Court held that categorical exclusion of blacks from juries for no other reason than their race violated the Equal Protection Clause, and Strauder's conviction was overturned due to the Ohio County court's violation of United States constitutional criminal procedure.[39][40]

On October 12, 1880, Melvin was reelected with 7,730 votes alongside a second judge to serve the First Judicial District, and he commenced his new term on January 1, 1881.[32][41] He resigned his circuit judgeship on November 19, 1881, after tiring of the "wool sack", which is what he called his judicial court dress.[2][32][36] Former West Virginia Governor John Jeremiah Jacob was appointed by Governor Jacob B. Jackson to fill the remainder of Melvin's unexpired term.[36][42]

Melvin resumed the practice of law in Wheeling.[32][43] In 1881, he joined the law practice of J. Dallas Ewing and Thomas S. Riley under the name of Ewing, Melvin & Riley.[15][32][44] The law firm became one of the strongest in the Northern Panhandle of West Virginia.[42] In 1898, Melvin and his law partner, Riley, argued on behalf of the West Virginia Board of Public Works before the U.S. Supreme Court in the case, Pittsburgh &c. Ry. v. Board of Public Works of West Virginia 172 U.S. 32 (1898), in which the Pittsburgh, Cincinnati, Chicago and St. Louis Railroad sought to avoid paying taxes on its usage of the West Virginia section of a railroad bridge crossing the Ohio River between Steubenville and Wheeling Junction.[45][46][47] The court's decision upheld the law in the Code of West Virginia of 1891, c. 29, § 67, that taxed railroad bridges. The court's decision stated: "A railroad bridge across a navigable river forming the boundary line between two states is not, by reason of being an instrument of interstate commerce, exempt from taxation by either state upon the part within it."[45][46]

Following the death of Judge Joseph R. Paull in 1899, Melvin was appointed by Governor George W. Atkinson to fill the unexpired term of Paull's judicial seat with the unanimous urging of members of the judicial district's bar.[9][32][48]

On June 3, 1900, Melvin granted an injunction that prevented the Wheeling Stogies baseball team from playing Sunday games in Wheeling.[49] The Stogies had begun holding Sunday games to increase attendance, but received warrants sworn by Wheeling Island residents and a fine on April 29, 1900, during their first Sunday game on the island.[49] The Stogies continued to play Sunday games, claiming them to be for charity's sake; however, the team's players were again fined by Judge J. R. LaRue.[49] A local federation of churches and other people opposed to Sunday baseball games applied to Melvin and the circuit court for an injunction to restrict the Stogies and other baseball clubs from playing on Sunday because it was a "public nuisance".[50] His injunction, the violation of which was a fine of $2,000, followed.[49] The team's lawyers argued that Sunday games met the recreational needs of working-class people, but Melvin and the court did not buy the argument, and Sunday baseball games did not become prevalent in West Virginia for another two decades.[49]

Melvin served the remainder of Paull's unexpired term, and was nominated by both Democratic and Republican parties and reelected for another eight-year term without opposition in November 1900.[9][51][52]

Melvin served out his term until October 31, 1906, when he suffered a stroke while holding a session of the circuit court in Wellsburg.[3][32] He was paralyzed and lost consciousness as a result of the stroke, and was assisted from the bench and taken to Wheeling City Hospital in Ward 5.[3][53][54] By the following day physicians had given up hope for his recovery.[54] Melvin died at 16:00 on November 9, 1906, at the hospital as a result of apoplexy.[6][9][32][55] His body was taken to the McLure Hotel on November 10, where it lay in state until November 12.[3] Melvin was interred next to his father and mother in his family's graveyard at United Methodist Cemetery in his hometown of Fairview (present-day New Manchester) in Hancock County.[3][6][32]

Melvin's estate was valued at $30,000.[56] His heirs included his sister, Mrs. S. T. Moore of Fairview, his nephews James and Paul Melvin of Fairview, his nephew John Melvin of New Cumberland, and his niece Mrs. John Bendene of Steubenville.[56] While not an heir, Melvin was also survived by his brother, J. A. B. Melvin, who was president of the Altoona Trust Company.[53]

Following his death, lawyer Frank W. Nesbitt was appointed by Governor William M. O. Dawson to fulfill his unexpired term on the circuit court bench.[57][58][59]

Following his death, Melvin was memorialized by the West Virginia Bar Association at its annual meeting in December 1906.[1] The association averred, "Judge Melvin's name and character, both as a Judge and as a man, was not only well known and recognized in the Circuit in which he so long occupied the Bench, but known and honored throughout the entire state of West Virginia."[1] In his Bench and Bar of West Virginia (1919), former Governor George W. Atkinson remarked of Melvin's judicial career: "He sought only to be just and fair, and rarely if ever, failed in deciding right. It was a rare occurrence for one of his decisions to be reversed by the Appellate Court. Furthermore he was one of the most courteous, urbane of men, and was at all times absolutely honest and sincere."[9]

Melvin never married.[6][9][55] He was a member of the Wheeling Shakespeare Club[60] and was active in several Union veterans' organizations and reunions. In October 1871, Melvin delivered an address to welcome the soldiers and attendees of the Army of West Virginia Soldiers' Reunion in Wheeling.[61][62] He was later a member of the Society of the Army of West Virginia, later known as the Army of West Virginia Association.[63] In 1883, and again on September 9, 1897, Melvin was elected a vice president of the organization.[63][64] Melvin was also a member of the 1st West Virginia Association, of which he was elected president on September 6, 1894.[65] In addition, Melvin belonged to the Holliday Post of the Grand Army of the Republic and participated in the decoration of local Union graves on Memorial Day in 1897, 1898, and 1899.[66][67][68][69]

• "Letter to Thayer Melvin from Governor Jacob B. Jackson, November 16, 1881". West Virginia Archives and History. West Virginia Division of Culture and History. Retrieved July 14, 2015.
• "Timeline of West Virginia: Civil War and Statehood: Capture of Generals Kelley and Crook and Captain Melvin". West Virginia Archives and History. West Virginia Division of Culture and History. Retrieved July 14, 2015.

• Media related to Thayer Melvin at Wikimedia Commons