Underdog Alma Mater

Many of the songs from Underdog Alma Mater had already been released in the band's previous EPs.[1]

The band's very first EP, Television Off, Party On, featured the tracks "Believe Me, I'm Lying", "She's a Lady", and "Breakdown".[2] However, these tracks have a significantly different sound to them in their respective recordings from the EP and Underdog Alma Mater. On the band's release, The Sickest Warped Tour EP, "Hey Brittany" and "Coffee Break" were featured on it,[3] but were also different from their respective recorded versions on the album. Unlike the other songs, on the band's EP, Hot Party Jamz, the track "That for Me" was featured, but its recording remained the same as it was on the album.

The band recorded the album in Annetenna Studio in Burbank, California and Red Bull Studios in Santa Monica.[4] During the writing of the songs for the album, guitarist Marc Stewart stated, "Our songs are about real stuff that's happened to us because that's what kids want to hear about. They want to listen to stories about things that could happen to them as well, or that already have happened to them."[5]

"Hey Brittney" was the first song the group ever wrote. The song combines elements of power pop, pop-punk, electro-pop and '80s radio rock.[6][1] The track "Believe Me, I'm Lying", written by Austin Bello and Caleb Turman, is based on how Turman once ran into trouble with his girlfriend after he lied to her and left her in tears. Turman stated, "I was hanging out with some other girls, but I told my girlfriend that I was going out by myself. So, the girls and I decided to get some coffee, and as we're walking to the car, my girlfriend pulled up and her headlights were right there in my face. I was totally busted."[5]

"Believe Me, I'm Lying" and the track "My Worst Nightmare" were both written by Bello and Turman and both tracks had originally descended from the duo's former acoustic/electronic project Been Bradley. The original recordings of these two songs are featured on the deluxe edition of Underdog Alma Mater.[7]

Between mid-March and early May 2008, the band participated in the Alternative Press Tour.[8] "Whoa Oh! (Me vs. Everyone)" was released on the band's MySpace page on March 18, 2008.[9] It was released as the lead single from the album on April 1, 2008.[10] On April 10, a music video was released for the song.[11] Underdog Alma Mater was released on April 29 through Universal Motown Records.[1] The album was made available for streaming on May 2 through Imeem.[12] A couple of days later, the band appeared at the 2008 edition of the Bamboozle festival.[13] Also in May, the group went on a US tour alongside Metro Station, the Maine, the Cab and Danger Radio.[14] Between June and August, the band performed on the 2008 edition of Warped Tour.[15] "She's a Lady" was released on July 11, 2008 as the second single from the album.[16] A music video was released for the song on September 23.[17] In October and November, the band supported Cobra Starship on their Sassy Back (Tour) in the US.[18]

On February 4, 2009, the band posted a cover of Taylor Swift's "Love Story" online.[19] Later in February, the band went on a tour of Europe, followed by appearances at Soundwave festival in Australia and a tour of Japan, ending in early March.[20] In April, the band performed on the Bamboozle Roadshow[21] and appeared at The Bamboozle festival in early May.[22] Between late June and late August, the band performed on the Warped Tour.[23] On July 7, the deluxe edition of the album was released. It featured the twelve original songs from the album and seventeen additional tracks from the band, mainly from the band's earlier days.[7] A DVD with live shows and other footage was also included, as well.[7]

In 2018, the group released Underdog Alma Mater on vinyl to the celebrate the 10 year anniversary of the album.[24]

Fans would receive special bonuses by pre-ordering the album from certain retailers.[25]

• Best Buy
  • Two bonus tracks: "Give & Take (remix)" and "Hurricane Haley"
  • A bonus live video of the band's full set at SXSW
• Interpunk
  • Button, sticker, and signed poster
• iTunes (digital download)
  • Two bonus tracks: "Becky Starz (remix)" and "Indiana"
• Newbury Comics
  • Signed CD booklet
• SmartPunk
  • Autographed poster

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AbsolutePunk.net	(78%)[26]
AllMusic	[27]
Punknews.org	[28]

Underdog Alma Mater was met with generally positive reviews from music critics. Joe DeAndrea of AbsolutePunk.net praised the album for its catchy melodies, infectious chorus' and high production work. He stated, "it becomes obvious that not only does Forever the Sickest Kids have the ability to break through the mainstream, but completely burst through it." He called tracks such as "Hey Brittany" and "She's a Lady" a "harder punch that makes them irresistible." He also praised the song "Whoa Oh! (Me vs. Everyone)" for its simple lyrics and catchy chorus. However, he was critical on the tracks "Believe Me, I'm Lying" and "Coffee Break" calling them "watered down" and "out of place." Overall, he stated that the album would be "people's guiltiest pleasure of the year."[26]

Jordan Rogowski of Punksnew.org also gave the album a positive review. He complimented the band's songwriting ability and lyrical themes on the album that make them stand out among their peers within the genre.[28] However, Katherine Fulton of AllMusic stated the opposite of that, remarking; "The ultimate goal of a debut album should be to set a band apart from its peers, but it appears that Forever the Sickest Kids have missed that point with Underdog Alma Mater." Despite giving a negative review, she did praise the track "Uh Huh" calling it "light and bouncy." She ended off stating, "they're not enough to make up for what amounts to a shallow debut that shows Forever the Sickest Kids' talent for appropriation, not originality."[27]

Credits for Underdog Alma Mater adapted from AllMusic.[4]