Whisper a Prayer

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[26]
Entertainment Weekly	A−[27]

Whisper a Prayer has received general acclaim from critics. In a contemporary review by Entertainment Weekly, James Earl Hardy expressed, 'Mica Paris finally lives up to the sensation her debut single' and that 'Her breathy alto is equally as classy and confident with pop ("I Never Felt Like This Before") as it is with hip-hop soul ("You Got a Special Way") and sexy R&B ballads ("You Put a Move on My Heart")'.[27] AllMusic editor, Andrew Hamilton listed "Positivity" and "Can't Seem to Make Up My Mind", both co-written by Paris, as "favorites", adding that "her original version of "You Put a Move on My Heart" sounds better than Tamia's version" featured on Quincy Jones' Jook Joint album. Hamilton also praised Paris' vocal performances, writing "she delivers these songs in her smooth, jazz- and blues-influenced, intense but relaxed style". In addition to this, Hamilton expressed that Paris "is the most exciting female vocalist to come along in some time" but noted that "unlike her first LP, which scored a minor R&B hit with "My One Temptation", none of these excellent songs made much of an impact".[26]

In a retrospective review, BBC Music editor Daryl Easlea described Paris as "one of the UK’s greatest soul divas" and wrote that "working with what only could be deemed a stellar cast [...] Island looked at Whisper a Prayer as being Paris’ true breakthrough album". Easlea described the album as "a remarkable pedigree" thanks in part to "backing singers like Siedah Garrett, producers including Narada Michael Walden and Rod Temperton, and writers such as Graham Lyle on board". Easlea described "I Bless the Day" as "sweet and light, floating along with Paris’ emotive voice at once commanding and sensitive" and the "Drizabone-mixed swingbeat of Two in a Million" as "spry and sugary". However, Easlea wrote that "the only thing that lets the Whisper a Prayer down is its instrumentation". Using "You Put a Move on My Heart" as one such an example he wrote, "a song as beautiful and passionately delivered [...] you long for it being recorded at a different time, not with Paris in front of a keyboard with an orchestra setting button and a drum machine". He also noted the "90s contraptions [...] present and correct on the album’s opener, I Never Felt This Way Before", writing that "it may be ultra-smooth but the overall effect is like a cut-price version of a cut from Anita Baker's Rapture". In closing however, Easlea expressed 'Whisper a Prayer is one of the shining beacons of 90s UK soul'.[28]

Andrew Hamilton also reviewed "You Put a Move on My Heart" favorably, writing "Mica Paris' original rendition of Rod Temperton's ballad supreme[...]shames Tamia's more successful rendition". Though he noted that the sales of Whisper a Prayer "pale in comparison" to Q's Jook Joint – on which Tamia's cover is featured – he wrote that "Paris' glorious tone, however, never pales; it glows like a warm fire as the devastating British woman squeezes the last drop of soul from the lyrics."[7]

Whisper a Prayer debuted and peaked at number twenty on the UK Albums Chart making it her second top twenty appearance on the chart. In its second week the album dropped one place to twenty-one and thirty in its third before making its last appearance on the chart at number sixty-one in its fourth week.[29] In the US, Whisper a Prayer peaked at ninety-nine on the Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums chart, where it spent a single week. It is Paris' last album to appear on any Billboard chart.[30]