Miller Huggins

Huggins began his playing career in minor league baseball with the Mansfield Haymakers of the Class B Interstate League in 1899. He continued his minor league apprenticeship with the St. Paul Saints of the American Association from 1901 through 1903.[6] After starting his career as an exclusively right-handed hitter, he began to bat from the left side in 1902 in response to his offensive struggles in the 1901 season while also moving to second base during his time at St. Paul.[4]

Miller Huggins' 1909 baseball card

Huggins handled 19 fielding chances, 11 putouts and nine assists, without committing an error in a game with the Saints in 1902; the previous Major League Baseball (MLB) record being 18, set by Fred Dunlap in 1882.[9] In 1903, he pulled off the first delayed steal in recorded baseball history.[5]

Fleischmann, part-owner of the Cincinnati Reds of the National League (NL), kept an eye on Huggins while he played for St. Paul. The Reds duly purchased his contract from the Saints before the 1904 season.[4] He made his MLB debut on April 15, 1904,[9] and proved very adept at getting on base. He batted .264 with the Reds that season and improved in the 1906 season, finishing with a .292 batting average and 41 stolen bases,[6] while spending considerable time developing his upper-body strength.[4]

Although Huggins hoped to be selected as Ned Hanlon's successor as Cincinnati's manager after the 1907 season, the Reds instead went with John Ganzel.[10] In 1908, he played with the Reds in the Cuban-American Major League Clubs Series. Hampered by a broken ankle and torn ligaments in his shoulder, he slumped to .209 in 1909.[4]

Before the 1910 season, the Reds traded Huggins, along with Frank Corridon and Rebel Oakes, to the St. Louis Cardinals in return for Fred Beebe and Alan Storke. He set an MLB record on June 1, 1910, with six plate appearances but no at bats, with four walks and two sacrifice flies.[6][9] In the same year, he batted .265 for the Cardinals and led the NL in walks.[11]

Huggins with the St. Louis Cardinals in 1912

On July 13, 1911, he tied the NL record for successful fielding chances in a game with 16.[6] At the end of the season, he finished sixth in the voting for the Chalmers Award for Most Valuable Player. In 1912, he hit over .300 for the first time in his career.[4] Huggins became player-manager for the Cardinals after the 1912 season, succeeding Roger Bresnahan.[12][13][14] Team owner Helene Hathaway Britton preferred Huggins' "gentlemanly" manner over Bresnahan's rougher personality.[15]

With the acquisition of speed in a trade with the Pittsburgh Pirates, including Dots Miller, Art Butler, Cozy Dolan and Chief Wilson, the Cardinals contended for the NL pennant in 1914.[16] Finishing in third place, it was the Cardinals' best finish since 1876,[15] but they fell back to sixth in 1915 and last in 1916.[15] When Britton sold the team after that season, she offered Huggins a chance to buy a part of the team. While he was attempting to raise money from the Fleischmann family, Britton sold the team to a group headed by Samuel Breadon, who hired Branch Rickey to run the team's day-to-day operations in the front office.[15]

Huggins had coached the young Rogers Hornsby, helping him to correct his batting stance,[12] and Hornsby duly succeeded him as the team's starting second baseman in 1917 as Huggins ended his playing career.[15] He managed the team during 1917, the last year of his contract, but was not retained.[15]

With the New York Yankees of the American League (AL) not performing well, Yankees owners Jacob Ruppert and Tillinghast L'Hommedieu Huston sought to replace "Wild" Bill Donovan as manager.[17] Ban Johnson, AL president, suggested Huggins to Ruppert as a replacement for Donovan. Huston, who had been in Europe at the time that Ruppert had made the appointment, disliked Huggins and wanted to hire Wilbert Robinson, his drinking buddy.[17] Ruppert himself had been put off by Huggins' wool cap and practice of smoking pipes in public, which he felt was the mark of the working class.[17] However, Ruppert interviewed Huggins upon Johnson's recommendation, and agreed that Huggins knew much about baseball.[17] Ruppert offered the job to Huggins, who initially did not want to take the position, as the Yankees were in no better a position than the Cardinals. J. G. Taylor Spink of The Sporting News eventually convinced Huggins to accept the offer,[17] and he signed a two-year contract.[18] The hiring of Huggins drove a wedge between the two co-owners that culminated in Huston selling his shares of the team to Ruppert in 1922.[5][19]

Having taken charge Huggins did not shy away from making personnel changes.[20][21][22] Upon taking over the Yankees, he stressed fundamental baseball, drilling the Yankees in the art of the bunt.[23] Huggins also made his first player transaction, acquiring Del Pratt and Eddie Plank from the St. Louis Browns trading Nick Cullop, Joe Gedeon, Fritz Maisel, Les Nunamaker, Urban Shocker and $15,000 ($292,000 in current dollar terms),[24] a move that led to criticism in the press.[23]

In Huggins' first season with the Yankees, the team finished fourth in the AL.[25] After that season, he obtained Ernie Shore, Dutch Leonard and Duffy Lewis from the Boston Red Sox, for Ray Caldwell, Frank Gilhooley, Slim Love, and Roxy Walters.[24] The following year he traded Pratt, Muddy Ruel, Hank Thormahlen and Sammy Vick to the Red Sox for Waite Hoyt, Harry Harper, Mike McNally and Wally Schang.[24] Huggins signed a one-year contract to remain with the Yankees for a reported $12,000.[26]

Huston continually took the side of his players in any argument they had against Huggins,[17] criticizing Huggins in the press when the Yankees lost the pennant in 1920.[17] Meanwhile, Ruppert was at best a lukewarm advocate of Huggins.[27] Babe Ruth resisted Huggins' discipline; he did not respect Huggins due to his small stature, soft-spoken nature, and inability to fight,[28] and Huggins was unable to enforce punishments on Ruth, despite being well educated.[27] The Yankees finished third in the AL in 1919 and 1920.[25] Huggins signed a one-year contract to remain with the team in 1921.[26]

Huggins with the Yankees in 1922

Coming into the 1921 season, Huggins was still experiencing criticism in the press. Hugh Fullerton wrote that "in the past Huggins has not shone as a leader of men".[29] By that season, Huggins developed Aaron Ward, Wally Pipp, and Bob Shawkey.[30] The Yankees won their first AL pennant in 1921,[25] reaching the World Series for the first time in franchise history, silencing his critics in the press. However, they lost the 1921 World Series to the New York Giants. In response, Huggins sought to add more pitching talent.[31]

Before the 1922 season, Huggins acquired Johnny Mitchell from the Vernon Tigers of the Pacific Coast League and traded fan favorite Roger Peckinpaugh along with Rip Collins, Bill Piercy, and Jack Quinn to the Red Sox for Everett Scott, Bullet Joe Bush, and Sad Sam Jones.[24] By this time, Ruppert hired Ed Barrow as the team's business manager, and he aided Huggins in player transactions.[32] The Yankees repeated as AL champions that season,[25] but lost the 1922 World Series, again to the Giants. With the newly gained confidence of his owners, Huggins was retained as manager.[33][34]

The Yankees won their first World Series in 1923, preventing the Giants from repeating as champions for the third consecutive season.[35] They were unable to retain their title the following season however, finishing second in the AL to the Washington Senators.[25]

Huggins had come to regret his trade of Urban Shocker to the Browns. In St. Louis, the spitballer Shocker had come into his own as a starter, racking up four straight 20-win seasons (1920–23) and leading the American League with 27 wins in 1921 and strikeouts the following year, when he won 24 games. Shocker was reacquired for Bullet Joe Bush, Milt Gaston and Joe Giard in December 1924.

However, through 42 games of the 1925 season, the Yankees struggled, falling to seventh place in the eight-team AL, 13+1⁄2 games out of first place.[36] Huggins made wholesale changes to the Yankees' lineup, as he replaced Ward at second base with Howard Shanks, catchers Steve O'Neill and Wally Schang with Benny Bengough, and, most notably, Pipp with Lou Gehrig at first base, beginning Gehrig's record consecutive games played streak. Among the team's regulars, only Babe Ruth, Joe Dugan, and Bob Meusel remained in the lineup.[36] However, the team continued to struggle; amid rumors that he might replace Huggins, Ruppert stated that "Miller Huggins will be manager as long as he cares to be".[37] The Yankees fell to seventh place in the AL that season.[25]

With Ruppert's full support, Huggins' duties with the Yankees included keeping Ruth in line.[5][27] Unafraid of his star player, Huggins and Ruth often clashed.[38] Huggins suspended Ruth indefinitely on August 29, 1925, for "misconduct off the playing field", while also fining him $5,000 ($83,400 in current dollar terms), and as it was an away game in St. Louis, Ruth was ordered to pay his own way back to New York.[39][40][41] The actual reason was because he arrived late for batting practice after yet another night out the night before, though it was a culmination of his pranks and insistence of recruiting less able teammates to go clubbing with him, causing them to nurse hangovers.[41] Ruth responded by claiming Ruppert would rescind the fine and suspension, and that he would never play for Huggins again, believing that Ruppert would side with him over Huggins. However, Ruppert insisted that the fine would stand and that Ruth would be suspended for as long as Huggins desired.[27] After apologizing to Huggins and Ruppert,[42] Ruth was reinstated on September 5.[43] Ruth did not challenge Huggins' authority again.[27]

Huggins restructured the team for the 1926 season, giving starting jobs to Mark Koenig and Tony Lazzeri.[44] That season, Huggins won his fourth pennant with the Yankees in 1926,[12] marking the first time that a team won a pennant after finishing seventh the year prior.[25][45] However, the Yankees lost the 1926 World Series to the Cardinals in seven games.

Winning the pennant once again in the 1927 season, Huggins matched Cap Anson's mark of five pennants in seven seasons.[46] That year, the Yankees benefited from the development of George Pipgras and Wilcy Moore,[25] and set an American League record with 110 regular season victories,[47] winning the AL by 19 games.[48] The Yankees swept the Pittsburgh Pirates in the 1927 World Series. This team became known as Murderers' Row, and is considered one of the greatest teams in baseball history.[48]

Huggins remained confident in his team's ability to repeat as AL champions in 1928 season.[49][50] Huggins supplemented his team by acquiring Bill Dickey from the minor leagues.[51] He acquired Stan Coveleski, who was attempting to return to his peak years, but released him in August when the former star continued to struggle.[52] The Yankees reached the 1928 World Series, winning their sixth pennant in eight years,[22] and defeated the Cardinals 4 games to 0. This was the first time a team swept their opponents in consecutive World Series'.[53]

Huggins continued to tinker with his roster during the offseason. He traded Dugan, Mike Gazella, Rosy Ryan and Pat Collins,[22] and acquired Lyn Lary from the Pacific Coast League.[54] He tried Lary at third base and Leo Durocher at shortstop,[55] while he attempted to acquire George Uhle and Ed Morris, but was unsuccessful in both cases.[22] The Yankees fell behind the Philadelphia Athletics in the standings during the 1929 season and as it became clear that the Yankees would not win the AL pennant in 1929, Huggins began consulting with coaches Art Fletcher and Bob Shawkey about the future of the team, including how to replace Bob Meusel in left field.[55] However, by August 1929, Huggins began losing weight and complained of feeling ill.[53]