Rachael vs. Guy: Celebrity Cook-Off

In the premiere episode, Guy & Rachael played "roshambo" to determine who would pick first for their teams. Guy won (paper beating rock) and chose first. Here are how the teams were chosen, and what charity each celebrity was supporting:[2]

  (WIN) The celebrity won the series.

  (RUNNER-UP) The celebrity was the runner-up of the series.

  (WIN) The celebrity won the task.

  (IN) The celebrity lost the task but was not in the bottom two.

  (LOW) The celebrity competed in and won the cook-off to advance to the next round.

  (OUT) The celebrity lost that week's cook-off and was eliminated from the competition.

As described above, the teams are chosen and given their first task: supply food for the first ever Celebrity Cook-Off Food Festival, to be attended by 150 people. Each person is given a token to give to the celebrity who, in their opinion, made the best dish. The team with the most tokens wins the task and is safe from elimination. The two members of the losing team with the least tokens will have a 10-minute "secret ingredient" cook-off to determine who advances and who is eliminated (similar to the "Secret Ingredient Showdown" in the 2011 The Next Iron Chef: Super Chefs competition).

Each team had a 90-minute brainstorming session with their coach to determine the overall theme for their dishes, then was given two hours to cook their dishes before serving them to the Festival-goers.

• Team Rachael's food theme: "Hot in the City" (Spicy Foods)
• Team Guy's food theme: Mexican Foods
• Winning team: Team Guy
• Bottom 2 Cook-Off Participants: Aaron Carter and Taylor Dayne
• Elimination Cook-Off Secret Ingredient: Shrimp
• Advanced: Taylor Dayne
• Eliminated: Aaron Carter

The contestants make desserts judged by 13 pastry students and instructors. Each of the 13-student panel would grade the contestants' dishes on four different scores.

• Winning team: Tie (Each team received 26 points out of a maximum of 52)
• Bottom 2 Cook-Off Participants: Alyssa Campanella and Summer Sanders (Due to the tie, the team captains were chosen for the cook-off.)
• Elimination Cook-Off Assignment: Salad
• Advanced: Summer Sanders
• Eliminated: Alyssa Campanella

The remaining six have one-on-one battles, to prepare favorite dishes of three judges from Chopped. (Note: winners' names appear in bold)

• Marcus Samuelsson (Fried chicken): Coolio vs. Lou Diamond Phillips
• Scott Conant (Tomato & basil pasta sauce): Taylor Dayne vs. Joey Fatone
• Alex Guarnaschelli (Porterhouse steak): Summer Sanders vs. Cheech Marin
• Winning team: Team Rachael (2 out of 3 rounds)
• Bottom 3 Cook-Off Participants: Lou Diamond Phillips, Cheech Marin, and Joey Fatone
• Elimination Cook-Off Assignment: Grilled cheese sandwich
• Advanced: Joey Fatone and Lou Diamond Phillips
• Eliminated: Cheech Marin

The remaining five are asked to run food trucks

• Winning team: Team Guy
• Bottom 2 Cook-Off Participants: Taylor Dayne and Summer Sanders
• Elimination Cook Off Assignment: Amuse-bouche
• Advanced: Taylor Dayne
• Eliminated: Summer Sanders

The remaining four are asked to cater a three-course dinner for ten.

• Advanced: Coolio, Lou Diamond Phillips
• Bottom 2 Cook-Off Participants: Joey Fatone, Taylor Dayne
• Elimination Cook Off Assignment: Use anything in the pantry
• Third Place: Joey Fatone (Fried rice)
• Fourth place: Taylor Dayne (Matzah ball soup)

The final two are asked to run their own restaurants, to be judged by Tim and Nina Zagat, based on comments of 40 diners.

• Winning team: Team Rachael
• Winner: Lou Diamond Phillips (28/30)
• Runner-up: Coolio (23/30)

  (WINNER) The celebrity won the series.

  (RUNNER-UP) The celebrity was the runner-up of the series.

  (WIN) The celebrity won the task.

  (IN) The celebrity lost the task but was not in the bottom two.

  (LOW) The celebrity competed in and won the cook-off to advance to the next round.

  (OUT) The celebrity lost that week's cook-off and was eliminated from the competition.

Teams are chosen, and the teams' first challenge is to prepare a tasting menu. Each team must produce four individual dishes plus one team dessert, and put on a skit.

• Team Rachael Captain: Kathy Najimy
• Team Guy Captain: Dean McDermott
• Winning team: Team Guy
• Bottom 2 Cook-Off Participants: Kathy Najimy and Gilbert Gottfried
• Elimination Cook-Off Assignment: Ideal midnight snack
• Advanced: Kathy Najimy
• Eliminated: Gilbert Gottfried

The two teams visit a farm to learn about fresh cooking. For their challenge, each team member must create a dish with a specific meat product, such as salmon or lamb chops, along with a side dish that includes vegetables that they must pick on their own as a team.

• Team Rachael Captain: Carnie Wilson
• Team Guy Captain: Cornelia Guest
• Winning team: Team Rachael
• Bottom 2 Cook-Off Participants: Cornelia Guest and Dean McDermott
• Elimination Cook-Off Assignment: Corn
• Advanced: Dean McDermott
• Eliminated: Cornelia Guest

The teams run their own diners with the help of wait staff. Each team member is responsible for one of three diner classics: the tuna melt, the cheeseburger, or the club sandwich. One member must also entertain the crowd.

• Team Rachael Captain: Hines Ward
• Team Guy Captain: Johnny Weir
• Winning team: Team Rachael
• Bottom 2 Cook-Off Participants: Chilli and Dean McDermott
• Elimination Cook-Off Assignment: Milkshake
• Advanced: Dean McDermott
• Eliminated: Chilli

The remaining five have to create a child's birthday party menu

• Winning team: Tie
• Bottom 2 Cook-Off Participants: Johnny Weir and Carnie Wilson
• Elimination Cook-Off Assignment: Hot dogs
• Advanced: Carnie Wilson
• Eliminated: Johnny Weir

The remaining four are asked to run food trucks and are judged individually.

• Winning cook: Dean McDermott
• Bottom 3 Cook-Off Participants: Carnie Wilson, Hines Ward, and Kathy Najimy
• Elimination Cook-Off Assignment: Anything on a stick
• Advanced: Carnie Wilson
• Eliminated: Hines Ward and Kathy Najimy

• Winning team: Team Guy
• Winner: Dean McDermott
• Runner-Up: Carnie Wilson

  (WIN) The celebrity won the series.

  (RUNNER-UP) The celebrity was the runner-up of the series.

  (WIN) The celebrity won the task.

  (IN) The celebrity lost the task but was not eliminated.

  (MVP) The celebrity was their team's MVP.

  (OUT) The celebrity was eliminated.

Teams are chosen, and the teams' first challenge is to prepare a medieval themed meal.

Guest Judge: Lee Anne Wong

Winning Team: Team Guy

MVP: Tiffany

Eliminated: No One

The teams must prepare a meal for a luau.

Guest Judge: Marc Murphy

Winning Team: Team Rachael

MVP: Florence Henderson

Eliminated: Chris Kattan

Guest Judge: Madison Cowan

Winning Team:Team Guy

MVP: Penn Jillette and Herschel Walker

Eliminated: Jake Pavelka

The episode is set in a sports center. In the first challenge, the celebrities must make chicken wings (vegetarian Vanilla Ice was allowed to instead make a similar game day food out of tofu). Based on that, each team's MVP gets chosen who also gains immunity from elimination. In the next challenge, they have to cook elevated stadium food.

Guest Judge: Alex Guarnaschelli and Josh Elliott

Winning Team: Team Guy

MVP: Penn Jillette and Herschel Walker

Eliminated: Judy Gold

First, in a mini-challenge to win a 10-minute advantage in the main challenge, the celebrities must make French fries. In the main challenge they must make hot dogs.

Guest Judge: Amanda Freitag

Winning Team: Team Rachael

MVP: Florence Henderson

Eliminated: Vanilla Ice

The finalists therefore are Herschel Walker, Tiffany, Penn Jillette and Florence Henderson.

Aboard a ship, the finalists have to cook three-course dinners with Vanilla Ice and Judy Gold assisting them. They have to give five-minute presentations.

Judges: Aaron Sanchez, Scott Conant, Sunny Anderson, and some restaurateurs.

Winning Celebrity: Herschel Walker

Penn was the runner-up and was given $5,000 for his charity from Rachael and Guy's own money.