All Souls (TV series)

Described as a "paranormal hospital drama" by UPN,[1] All Souls follows the medical staff working in the Boston teaching hospital of the same name.[2] The area has a history dating back to the American Civil War. A photograph taken during the war is prominently featured in the series, as it shows individuals who still work as part of the staff.[2] The hauntings at All Souls started during the Civil War, when a Dr. Abramson conducted experiments on his patients following the death of his three sons in combat. The ghosts of Abramson's victims remain in the hospital to the present day.[3] The facility is composed of "dungeons, trick elevators, deserted floors, passageways filled with smoke and dripping water" and "dark, dank, cavelike areas".[4] It had previously functioned as a psychiatric hospital,[5] which was housed on the upper levels of the structure's tower.[4][6]

The main narrative includes "hints of deeper, good-versus-evil contests". Taking inspiration from the horror film genre, the series includes "extreme closeups [and] bizarre sexual transformations".[2] In the pilot episode, a seduction scene with a doctor and a young woman ends when she is revealed to be a corpse,[5] and several women die after being admitted for treatment.[7] Although the series follows a specific mythology and continuity, each episode has its own self-contained story.[8]

Grayson McCouch (pictured in 2009) played the show's lead character Dr. Mitchell Grace.[8]

UPN executives had pitched the series as following "young doctors in peril at a haunted old Boston Hospital" who must contend with "a healthy dose of terrifying paranormal occurrences and gripping medical emergencies".[4] In the pilot episode, Dr. Mitchell Grace (Grayson McCouch) begins working at the hospital immediately after graduating from medical school. He had specifically chosen the All Souls medical program, refusing offers from the Mayo Clinic and the Yale–New Haven Hospital, due to his personal connection with the hospital. Grace's father died in 1978 while working as a janitor in the hospital, after contracting a mysterious illness.[2][9] Grace serves as the show's lead character, and functions as a detective as well as a doctor while trying to understand the inner workings of All Souls.[8] As he works, Grace encounters both good and evil ghosts,[2] and discovers medical experiments are being conducted under the guidance of the board of directors.[5] Spirits include "a mad scientist and his Igor-like errand boy",[2] and a woman dressed in 19th century fashion pushing a baby carriage through the halls.[7] Grace is haunted by visions of his father,[7] and is somehow connected with the ghost Lazarus and Civil War doctors.[9] Dr. Dante Ambrosious (Jean LeClerc), the chair of the facility's board, is shown to have made deals with the evil spirits.[6]

Grace works closely with several allies during his time at All Souls,[2][4][5] but is the one of few people who is fully aware of the hospital's supernatural occurrences.[8] He collaborates with registered nurse Glory St. Claire (Irma P. Hall), who has a long history with the facility and "knows more than she can say or, at least, explain".[2] She is characterized by her telepathic powers.[2][4] According to St. Claire, "the dead have power" in the hospital and the "forces of good" residing inside All Souls had foretold of Grace's arrival for several decades.[5] She connects with Grace by holding his hands to allow him to see the "tortured soul" in the hospital.[10] Grace finds further support from Dr. Nicole De Brae (Serena Scott Thomas), Dr. Bradley Sterling (Daniel Cosgrove), and Patrick Fortado (Adam Rodriguez). De Brae acts as the hospital's chief of staff and Sterling works alongside Grace as a medical intern.[5][7] Fortado is Grace's close friend, a paraplegic who has great skill at hacking.[5] The exact nature of De Brae's loyalty is called into question, and Tim Goodman of the San Francisco Chronicle wondered if she will serve as a love interest or be revealed as one of the hospital's spirits.[4] Other members of the medical staff include the psychologist Dr. Philomena Cullen (Reiko Aylesworth) and the orderly Joey (Christian Tessier).[3][6]

All Souls was initially broadcast on Tuesday nights at 9 pm EST,[5] and aired directly after the reality television show Chains of Love.[9][10] The series carried a TV-PG parental rating, meaning it was judged "unsuitable for young children".[7] It premiered on April 17, 2001,[6] and was viewed by 2.1 million people; Nielsen Media Research ranked it 105th for the week.[16]

UPN placed the series on hiatus on April 30, 2001, due to concerns about its low ratings; only two episodes had aired. After announcing the show's hiatus, UPN executives said it was not canceled at that point. Despite the network's claims, media commentators believed it would be removed from air following its poor performance.[16][24] The series returned in August and the pilot and remaining episodes aired on Friday nights at 9 pm EST,[6] and were burned off throughout August.[25] Overall, All Souls was broadcast for a total of 360 minutes.[26]

While discussing the cancellation, McCouch felt it was "doomed to fail" from the beginning and referred to UPN as "a loser network at that time" due its treatment of the series. Cosgrove disagreed with McCouch's sentiment and believed the show's lack of success was not tied to the network specifically.[27] Rodriquez believed All Souls was unsuccessful as it was "just a little ahead of its time"; he felt that the program was better suited for television one to two years following its initial broadcast.[1] The series has never been released on DVD or Blu-ray, or licensed to an online-streaming service.[28]

All Souls has received positive critical feedback.[2][7][10][25] Eric Mink of the New York Daily News praised the show's use of horror, and wrote that it would "set the dragging knuckles of UPN's core audience all a-tingle".[2] The Los Angeles Times' Howard Rosenberg called the series "paranormal fun",[7] and television critic Kevin McDonough referenced All Souls as "a classic Aaron Spelling production" primarily due to its editing and special effects.[10] McDonough further described All Souls as "the best show you never watched", responding positively to the show's premise and actors.[25] Mink responded positively to the series' storylines and characters, believing they had potential for further development.[2]

Reception of the series' pilot was mixed, with television critics divided over its structure.[5][9][29] Rob Owen of The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette gave the first episode a positive review, believing it set up enough story elements to show promise.[9] Steven Oxman felt that the pilot made effective use of horror tropes, citing a scene in which a preserved fetus moves as a highlight.[5] LA Weekly's Robert Lloyd had a more mixed response to the series; while he felt that the Grace's initial interactions with St. Clair gave away too much of the plot, he found it "well-made within the limits of its ambitions".[29]

Critics had mixed reviews for All Souls, when compared to other horror and science-fiction narratives.[4][5] Tim Goodman noted that All Souls had aspects of The X-Files as well as from The Twilight Zone, Stephen King's 1977 novel The Shining, and the medical drama genre. Even though Goodman felt the series had a "scattershot approach", he felt that all the elements worked with one another.[4] Oxman was critical of the show's originality and its setting in a former asylum, saying it was similar to King's work and the 1996 film Extreme Measures, and felt it had "a superficial gloss" when compared to Twin Peaks. Despite this criticism, he called All Souls "potentially the scariest network show since The X-Files".[5]

• All Souls at IMDb