Andrew Jackson

Painting of Rachel Jackson by Ralph E. W. Earl (1823, the Hermitage, Tennessee)

After the Revolutionary War, Jackson worked as a saddle-maker,[22] briefly returned to school, and taught reading and writing to children.[23] In 1784, he left the Waxhaws region for Salisbury, North Carolina, where he studied law under attorney Spruce Macay.[24] He completed his training under John Stokes,[25] and was admitted to the North Carolina bar in September 1787.[26] Shortly thereafter, his friend John McNairy helped him get appointed as a prosecuting attorney in the Western District of North Carolina,[27] which would later become the state of Tennessee. While traveling to assume his new position, Jackson stopped in Jonesborough. While there, he bought his first slave, a woman who was around his age.[28] He also fought his first duel, accusing another lawyer, Waightstill Avery, of impugning his character. The duel ended with both men firing in the air.[29]

Jackson began his new career in the frontier town of Nashville in 1788 and quickly moved up in social status.[30] He became a protégé of William Blount, one of the most powerful men in the territory.[31] Jackson was appointed attorney general in 1791 and judge advocate for the militia the following year.[32] He also got involved in land speculation,[33] eventually forming a partnership with fellow lawyer John Overton.[34] Their partnership mainly dealt with claims made under a 'land grab' act of 1783 that opened Cherokee and Chickasaw territory to North Carolina's white residents.[35]

While boarding at the home of Rachel Stockly Donelson, the widow of John Donelson, Jackson became acquainted with their daughter, Rachel Donelson Robards. The younger Rachel was in an unhappy marriage with Captain Lewis Robards, and the two were separated by 1789.[36] After the separation, Jackson and Rachel became romantically involved,[37] living together as husband and wife.[38] Robards petitioned for divorce, which was granted on the basis of Rachel's infidelity.[39] The couple legally married in January 1794.[40] In 1796 they acquired their first plantation, Hunter's Hill,[41] on 640 acres (260 ha) of land near Nashville.[42]

Jackson became a member of the Democratic-Republican Party, the dominant party in Tennessee.[31] He was elected as a delegate to the Tennessee constitutional convention in 1796.[43] When Tennessee achieved statehood that year, he was elected to be its U.S. Representative. In Congress, Jackson argued against the Jay Treaty, criticized George Washington for allegedly removing Democratic-Republicans from public office, and joined several other Democratic-Republican congressmen in voting against a resolution of thanks for Washington.[44] He advocated for the right of Tennesseans to militarily oppose Native American interests.[45] The state legislature elected him to be a U.S. senator in 1797, but he resigned after serving only six months.[46]

Upon returning to Tennessee, Jackson was elected as a judge of the Tennessee superior court.[47][48] In 1802, Jackson also became major general, or commander, of the Tennessee militia, a position that was determined by a vote of the militia's officers. The vote was tied between Jackson and John Sevier, a popular Revolutionary War veteran and former governor, but the current state governor, Archibald Roane, broke the tie in Jackson's favor. Jackson later accused Sevier of fraud and bribery.[49] Sevier responded by impugning Rachel's honor, resulting in a shootout on a public street.[50] Soon afterwards, they met to duel, but parted without having fired at each other.[51]

Photograph of Aaron and Hannah Jackson by Theodore Schleier, (1865, the Hermitage, Tennessee). Aaron and Hannah were African-American slaves owned by Andrew Jackson.

Jackson resigned his judgeship in 1804.[52] He had almost gone bankrupt when the credit he used for land speculation collapsed in the wake of an earlier financial panic.[53] He had to sell Hunters Hill, as well as 25,000 acres (10,000 ha) of land he bought for speculation, and bought a smaller 420-acre (170 ha) plantation near Nashville that he would call the Hermitage.[54] He focused on recovering from his losses by becoming a successful planter and merchant.[54] The Hermitage would grow to 1,000 acres (400 ha),[55] making it one of the largest cotton-growing plantations in the state.[52]

Like most planters in the Southern United States, Jackson used slave labor. In 1804, Jackson had nine African American slaves; by 1820, he had over 100; and by his death in 1845, he had over 150.[56] Over his lifetime, he owned a total of 300 slaves.[57] Jackson subscribed to the paternalistic idea of slavery, which claimed that slave ownership was morally acceptable as long as slaves were treated with humanity and their basic needs were cared for.[58] In practice, slaves were treated as a form of wealth whose productivity needed to be protected.[59] Slaves who disobeyed or ran away could be harshly punished.[60] For example, in an 1804 advertisement to recover a runaway slave, Jackson offered "ten dollars extra, for every hundred lashes any person will give him, to the amount of three hundred".[61] Jackson also participated in the local slave trade.[62] Over time, his accumulation of wealth in both slaves and land placed him among the elite families of Tennessee.[63]

In May 1806, Jackson fought a duel with Charles Dickinson. They had gotten into an argument over a horse race, and Dickinson allegedly uttered a slur against Rachel.[50] During the duel, Dickinson fired first, and the bullet hit Jackson in the chest. The wound was not life-threatening because the bullet had shattered against his breastbone.[64] Jackson returned fire and killed Dickinson. The killing tarnished Jackson's reputation.[65]

Later in the year, Jackson became involved in former vice president Aaron Burr's plan to conquer Spanish Florida and drive the Spanish from Texas. Jackson had first gotten to know Burr in 1805 when he stayed with the Jacksons at the Hermitage during a tour of what was then the Western United States that he had embarked on after killing Alexander Hamilton in a duel[66] Burr eventually persuaded Jackson to join his adventure. In October 1806, Jackson wrote James Winchester that the United States "can conquer not only the Floridas [at that time there was an East Florida and a West Florida], but all Spanish North America".[67] He informed the Tennessee militia that it should be ready to march at a moment's notice "when the government and constituted authority of our country require it",[68] and agreed to provide boats and provisions for the expedition.[66] Jackson sent a letter to president Thomas Jefferson telling him that Tennessee was ready to defend the nation's honor.[69]

Jackson also expressed uncertainty about the enterprise. He warned the Governor of Louisiana William Claiborne and Tennessee Senator Daniel Smith that some of the people involved in the adventure might be intending to break away from the United States.[70] In December, Jefferson ordered Burr to be arrested for treason.[66] Jackson, safe from arrest because of his extensive paper trail, organized the militia to capture the conspirators.[71] Jackson testified before a grand jury at Burr's trial in 1807, implying that it was Burr's associate James Wilkinson who was guilty of treason, not Burr. Burr was acquitted of the charges.[72]

On 18 June 1812, the United States Congress declared war on the United Kingdom.[73] The causes of The War of 1812 were primarily about maritime issues,[74] but for the white settlers on the southern frontier, the war provided an opportunity to crush Native American resistance to encroachment on their lands, to undermine British support of the Native American tribes,[75] and to pry Florida from the Spanish.[76]

Jackson immediately offered to raise volunteers for the war, but he was not called to duty until after the United States military was repeatedly defeated in the American Northwest. After these defeats, in January 1813 Jackson enlisted over 2000 volunteers,[77] who were ordered to head to New Orleans to defend against a British attack.[78][79][80][81] When his forces arrived at Natchez, they were ordered to halt by General Wilkinson, the commander at New Orleans and the man Jackson accused of treason after the Burr adventure. A little later, Jackson received a letter from the Secretary of War, John Armstrong, stating that his volunteers were not needed,[15] and that they were to be disbanded and any supplies were to be handed over to Wilkinson.[82] Jackson refused to disband his troops; instead, he led them on the difficult march back to Nashville, earning the nickname "Hickory" (later "Old Hickory") for his toughness.[83]

After returning to Nashville, Jackson and one of his colonels, John Coffee, got into a street brawl over honor with the brothers Jesse and Thomas Hart Benton. Nobody was killed, but Jackson received a gunshot in the shoulder that nearly killed him.[84]

Jackson had not fully recovered from his wounds when Governor Blount called out the militia in September 1813.[85] A faction of Muscogee (Creek) known as the "Red Sticks" had broken away from the Muscogee Creek Confederacy, which wanted to maintain peace with the United States. The Red Sticks, led by William Weatherford (also called Red Eagle) and Peter McQueen, had allied with Tecumseh, a Shawnee chief who was fighting with the British against the United States.[80][86][87] Earlier in the summer, a party of Red Sticks had gone to Pensacola to pick up supplies from the Spanish.[88] During their return, they defeated an ambush at Burnt Corn Creek by American militia.[89][90] On 30 August, the Red Sticks avenged the ambush by attacking Fort Mims, a stockade inhabited by both white Americans and their Creek allies. They killed about 250 militia men and civilians.[91][92] The attack became known as the Fort Mims massacre and started the Red Stick War.[93][94]

Jackson's objective was to destroy the Red Sticks.[95] He headed south from Fayetteville, Tennessee in October with 2500 militia, establishing Fort Strother as his supply base.[96] He sent his cavalry under General Coffee ahead of the main force, destroying Red Stick villages and capturing supplies.[97][98] On 3 November, Coffee defeated a band of Red Sticks at the Battle of Tallushatchee. Later in the month, Jackson defeated another band of Red Sticks who were besieging Creek allies at the Battle of Talladega.[99]

By January 1814, the expiration of enlistments and desertion had reduced Jackson's force by about 1000 volunteers and Creek allies.[100] Even with this reduced force, Jackson continued the offensive.[101] The Red Sticks counterattacked at the Battles of Emuckfaw and Enotachopo Creek. Though outnumbered, Jackson repelled the attacks, but he was forced to withdraw to Fort Strother.[102] After Jackson's army was reinforced by further recruitments, including a regular army unit, the 39th U. S. Infantry Regiment under the command of Colonel John Williams,[101] their combined forces confronted the Red Sticks at a fort they had constructed at a bend in the Tallapoosa River. The Battle of Horseshoe Bend was fought on 27 March. Jackson's forces—including Cherokee, Choctaw and Creek allies–numbered over 3000 men; the Redsticks had about 1000.[103][104] The Red Sticks were overwhelmed and massacred. Over 800 Red Sticks were killed,[93] and nearly 300 Red Stick women and children were taken prisoner and distributed to Jackson's Native American allies.[105]

After the Battle of Horseshoe Bend, the power of the Red Sticks was broken.[106] Jackson continued his scorched-earth campaign of burning villages, destroying supplies,[106] and starving Red Stick women and children.[107] The campaign ended when Weatherford surrendered,[108] although some Red Sticks, including McQueen, fled to East Florida.[109] On June 8, Jackson was appointed a brigadier general in the United States Army, and 10 days later was made a brevet major general with command of the Seventh Military District, which included Tennessee, Louisiana, the Mississippi territory, and the Muscogee Creek Confederacy.[110] With President James Madison's approval, Jackson imposed the Treaty of Fort Jackson. The treaty required all Creek, including those who had remained allies, to surrender 23,000,000 acres (9,300,000 ha) of land to the United States.[111]

Jackson then turned his attention to the British and Spanish. He moved his forces to Mobile, Alabama in August. He accused the Spanish governor of West Florida, Mateo González Manrique, of arming the Red Sticks and threatened to attack. The governor responded by inviting the British to land at Pensacola to defend it, which violated Spanish neutrality.[112] The British attempted to capture Mobile, but their invasion fleet was repulsed at Fort Bowyer, located at the mouth of Mobile Bay.[113] Jackson then invaded Florida, defeating the Spanish and British forces at the Battle of Pensacola on November 7.[114] Afterwards, the Spanish surrendered and the British withdrew. Weeks later, Jackson learned that the British were planning an attack on New Orleans, which was the gateway to the lower Missippi river and control of the American West.[115] He evacuated Pensacola, strengthened the garrison at Mobile,[116] and led his troops to New Orleans.[117]

Jackson arrived in New Orleans on December 1, 1814.[118] There he instituted martial law because he worried about the loyalty of the city's Creole and Spanish inhabitants. He augmented his force by forming an alliance with Jean Lafitte's smugglers and raising units of free African-Americans and Creek,[119] paying non-white volunteers the same salary as whites.[120] This gave Jackson a force of about 5,000 men when the British arrived.[121]

The Battle of New Orleans by Edward Percy Moran (1910).

The British arrived in New Orleans in mid-December.[122] Admiral Cochrane was the overall commander of the operation;[123] General Edward Pakenham commanded the army of 10,000 soldiers, many of whom had served in the Napoleonic Wars.[124] As the British advanced up the east bank of the Mississippi River, Jackson constructed a fortified position to block them.[125] The climactic battle took place on January 8 when the British launched a frontal assault. Their troops made easy targets for the Americans protected by their parapets, and the attack ended in disaster.[126] General Packenham was killed and the British suffered over 2000 casualties; the Americans had suffered about 60 casualties.[127]

The British decamped from New Orleans at the end of January, but they still remained a threat.[128] Jackson refused to lift martial law and kept the militia under arms. He approved the execution of six militiamen for desertion.[129] Some Creoles registered as French citizens with the French consul and demanded to be discharged from the militia due to their foreign nationality. Jackson then ordered all French citizens to leave the city within three days,[130] and had a member of the Louisiana legislature, Louis Louaillier, arrested when he wrote a newspaper article criticizing Jackson's continuation of martial law. U.S. District Court Judge Dominic A. Hall signed a writ of habeas corpus for Louailler's release. Jackson had Hall arrested too. A military court ordered Louiallier's release, but Jackson kept him in prison and evicted Hall from the city.[131] Although Jackson lifted martial law when he received official word that the Treaty of Ghent, which ended the war with the British, had been signed,[132] his previous behavior tainted his reputation in New Orleans.[133]

Jackson's victory made him a national hero,[134] and on February 27, 1815, he was given the Thanks of Congress and awarded a Congressional Gold Medal.[47] Though the Treaty of Ghent had been signed in December 1814 before the Battle of New Orleans was fought,[135] Jackson's victory assured that the United States control of the region between Mobile and New Orleans would not be effectively contested by European powers. This control allowed the American government to ignore one of the articles in the treaty, which would have returned the Creek lands taken in the Treaty of Fort Jackson.[136]

Engraving of the trial of Robert Ambrister by William Croome in John Frost's Pictorial Life of Andrew Jackson. (c. 1846)

Following the war, Jackson remained in command of troops in the southern half of the United States and was permitted to make his headquarters at the Hermitage.[137] Jackson continued to displace the Native Americans in areas under his command. Despite resistance from the Secretary of the Treasury William Crawford who tried to help the Native Americans retain their land, Jackson signed five treaties with the Cherokee and Chickasaw between 1816 and 1820 that ceded tens of millions of acres of land to the United States.[138]

Jackson would soon find himself embroiled in another conflict in the Floridas. One source of conflict was the presence of a group of Native American people, known collectively as the Seminole, who straddled the border between the U.S. and Florida and were in constant conflict with white settlers.[139] Another source was the presence of runaway slaves in Florida. When the War of 1812 ended, the British turned a fort in Northern Florida over to runaway slaves, who they armed, trained and drilled to defend themselves.[140] Negro Fort, as it came to be called, had a garrison of about 300 African-Americans and protected about 1000 others living in its vicinity. The fort became a magnet for runaway slaves from both the United States and Spanish Florida,[140] representing a threat to the property rights of slave owners,[141] and heightened fears of slave insurrection.[142] Jackson ordered the fort captured. This was done in July 1816 by Colonel Duncan Clinch, who destroyed the fort and killed most of the garrison. The survivors were returned to slavery.[143]

These skirmishes, the problem of runaway slaves, and Spanish weakness became the focus of President James Monroe's administration, leading to what became known as the First Seminole War. In December 1817, Secretary of War John C. Calhoun ordered Jackson to lead a campaign "with full power to conduct the war as he may think best".[144] Jackson believed the best way to do this was to seize Florida from Spain once and for all. Before departing, Jackson wrote to Monroe, "Let it be signified to me through any channel ... that the possession of the Floridas would be desirable to the United States, and in sixty days it will be accomplished."[145]

Jackson invaded Florida, captured the Spanish fort of St. Marks, and occupied Pensacola. Seminole and Spanish resistance was effectively ended by May 1818. He also captured two British agents, Robert Ambrister and Alexander Arbuthnot, who had been working with the Seminole. After a brief trial, Jackson executed both of them, causing a diplomatic incident with the British. Jackson's actions polarized Monroe's cabinet. The occupied territories were returned to Spain.[146] Calhoun wanted him censured for violating the Constitution, since the United States had not declared war on Spain. Secretary of State John Quincy Adams defended him as he thought Jackson's occupation of Pensacola would lead Spain to sell Florida, which Spain did in the Adams–Onís Treaty of 1819.[147] In February 1819, a congressional investigation exonerated Jackson.[148]

Painting of Jackson by Thomas Sully (1824)

In 1819, mismanagement by the Second Bank of the United States created a financial panic that sent the US into its first prolonged financial depression. The United States reduced its military and Jackson was forced to retire from his major general position.[149] In compensation, Monroe made him the first territorial governor of Florida in 1821.[150] Jackson served as the governor for two months, returning to the Hermitage in ill health.[151] During his convalescence, Jackson, who had been a Freemason since at least 1798, became the Grand Master of the Grand Lodge of Tennessee for 1822–1823.[152] Around this time, he also completed negotiations for Tennessee to purchase Chickasaw lands. This became known as the Jackson Purchase. Jackson, Overton, and another colleague had speculated in some of the land and used their portion to found the town of Memphis.[153]

In 1822, Jackson accepted a plan by Overton to nominate him as a candidate for the 1824 presidential election, and he was nominated by the Tennessee legislature in July.[154] At the time, the Federalist Party had collapsed, and there were four major contenders for the Democratic-Republican Party nomination: William Crawford, John Quincy Adams, Henry Clay and John C. Calhoun. Jackson was intended to be a stalking horse candidate to prevent Tennessee's electoral votes from going to Crawford, who was seen as a Washington insider. Unexpectedly, Jackson garnered popular support outside of Tennessee and became a serious candidate.[149] He benefited from the expansion of suffrage among white males that followed the conclusion of the War of 1812.[155][156] He was a popular war hero whose reputation suggested he had the decisiveness and independence to bring change to how the government was run.[157] He also was promoted as a Washington outsider who stood for all the people, blaming banks for the country's depression.[158]

During his presidential candidacy, Jackson relunctantly ran for one of Tennessee's U.S. Senate seats. William Berkeley Lewis and the other U.S. senator John Eaton, who were Jackson's political managers, convinced him that he needed to defeat incumbent John Williams, who openly opposed Jackson. The legislature elected him in October 1823.[159][160] Jackson was attentive to his senatorial duties. He was appointed chairman of the Committee on Military Affairs, but avoided debate or initiating legislation.[161] He used his time in the Senate to form alliances and make peace with old adversaries.[162] Eaton continued to campaign for Jackson's presidency, updating his biography, and writing letters under a pseudonym that were quoted in newspapers around the country and so popular that they were reprinted in pamphlet form—Jackson himself clearly had a part in their composition.[163]

1824 election results

Democratic-Republican presidential nominees had historically been chosen by informal Congressional nominating caucuses. In 1824, most of the Democratic-Republicans in Congress boycotted the caucus,[164] and the power to choose nominees was shifting to state nominating committees and legislatures.[165] Jackson was nominated by a Pennsylvania convention, making him not merely a regional candidate from the west but the leading national contender.[166] When Jackson won the Pennsylvania nomination, Calhoun dropped out of the presidential race.[167] Afterwards, Jackson won the nomination in six other states and had a strong second-place finish in three others.[168]

In the presidential election, Jackson won a plurality of the popular vote, receiving 42 percent. More importantly, he won a plurality of electoral votes, receiving 99 votes from states in the South, West, and Mid-Atlantic. He was the only candidate to win states outside of his regional base: Adams dominated New England, Crawford won Virginia and Georgia, and Clay took three western states. Because no candidate had a majority of 131 of electoral votes, the House of Representatives held a contingent election under the terms of the Twelfth Amendment. The amendment specifies that only the top three electoral vote-winners are eligible to be elected by the House, so Clay was eliminated from contention.[169] Clay, who was also Speaker of the House and presided over the election's resolution, saw a Jackson presidency as a disaster for the country.[170] Clay threw his support behind Adams, who won the contingent election on the first ballot. Adams appointed Clay as his Secretary of State, leading supporters of Jackson to accuse Clay and Adams of having struck a "corrupt bargain".[171] After the Congressional session concluded, Jackson resigned his Senate seat and returned to Tennessee.[172]

After the election, Jackson's supporters formed a new party to undermine Adams and ensure he served only one term. Adams' presidency went poorly, and Adam's behavior undermined it. He was perceived as an intellectual elite who ignored the needs of the populace. He was unable to accomplish anything because Congress blocked his proposals.[173] In his First Annual Message to Congress, Adams stated that "we are palsied by the will of our constituents", which was interpreted as his being against representative democracy.[174] Jackson responded by championing the needs of ordinary citizens and declaring that "the voice of the people ... must be heard".[175]

1828 election results

Jackson was nominated for president by the Tennessee legislature in October 1825, more than three years before the 1828 election.[176] He gained powerful supporters in both the south and north, including Calhoun, who became Jackson's vice presidential running mate, and New York Senator Martin Van Buren.[177] Meanwhile, Adam's support from the southern states was eroded when he signed a tax on European imports, the Tariff of 1828, which was called the "Tariff of Abominations" by opponents, into law.[175] Jackson's victory in the presidential race was overwhelming. He won 56 percent of the popular vote and 68 percent of the electoral vote. The election ended the one-party system that had formed during the Era of Good Feelings as Jackson's supporters coalesced into the Democratic Party and the various groups who did not support him eventually formed the Whig Party.[178]

The political campaign was dominated by the personal abuse that partisans flung at both candidates.[179] Jackson was accused of being the son of an English prostitute and a mulatto,[180][181] and he was labelled a slave trader who trafficked in human flesh.[182] A series of pamphlets known as the Coffin Handbills.[183] accused him of having murdered 18 white men, including the soldiers he had executed for desertion and alleging that he stabbed a man in the back with his cane.[184][185] They stated that he had intentionally massacred Native American women and children at the Battle of Horseshoe Bend, ate the bodies of Native Americans he killed in battle,[186][187] and threatened to cut off the ears of Congressman who questioned his behavior during the Seminole war.[188]

Jackson and Rachel were accused of adultery for living together before her divorce was finalized,[189] and Rachel heard about the accusation.[190] She had been under stress throughout the election, and just as Jackson was preparing to head to Washington for his inauguration, she fell ill.[191] She did not live to see her husband become president, dying of a stroke or heart attack a few days later, and was buried on Christmas Eve.[190] Jackson believed that the abuse from Adams' supporters had hastened her death, stating at her funeral: "May God Almighty forgive her murderers, as I know she forgave them. I never can."[192]

Jackson arrived in Washington on February 11. His first concern was forming his cabinet.[193] He chose Van Buren as Secretary of State, his friend John Eaton as Secretary of War, Samuel D. Ingham as Secretary of Treasury, John Branch as Secretary of Navy, John M. Berrien as Attorney General, and William T. Barry as Postmaster General.[194] Jackson was inaugurated on March 4, 1829, becoming the first president-elect to take the oath of office on the East Portico of the U.S. Capitol.[195] Embittered by his defeat, Adams refused to attend.[196] In his inaugural address, Jackson promised to protect the sovereignty of the states, respect the limits of the presidency, reform the government by removing disloyal or incompentent appointees, and observe a fair policy toward Native Americans.[197] Jackson invited the public to the White House, which was promptly overun by well-wishers who caused minor damage to its furnishings. The spectacle earned him the nickname "King Mob."[198]

Jackson's believed that Adam's administration was corrupt and one of first acts as president was to initiate investigations into all executive departments.[199] The investigations revealed that $280,000 (equivalent to $7,100,000 today) was stolen from the Treasury, and the reduction in costs to the Department of the Navy saved it $1 million (equivalent to $25,000,000 today).[200] One of the people caught in his investigation was the Treasury Auditor Tobias Watkins, a personal friend of Adams' who was found guilty of embezzlement.[201][200] In the first year of his term Jackson asked Congress to tighten laws on embezzlement, revise laws to reduce tax evasion, and pushed for an improved government accounting system.[202]

Jackson implemented a principle he called "rotation in office" by enforcing the Tenure of Office Act, signed by President Monroe in 1820, that limited appointed office tenure and authorized the president to remove and appoint political party associates. The previous custom had been for the president to leave the existing appointees in office, replacing them through attrition.[203] During his first year in office, Jackson removed hundreds of federal officials, which was about 10% of all Federal employees,[203] and replaced them with loyal Democrats.[204] He argued that rotation in office was a democratic reform that reduced bureaucracy and corruption[205] by preventing hereditary officeholding and made officeholders responsible to the popular will,[206] but it functioned as political patronage, which came to be known as the spoils system.[207][205]

Lithograph cartoon The Celeste-al Cabinet by Albert A. Hoffay, published by H. R. Robinson (1836). Illustrates Jackson's cabinet during the Petticoat Affair. "Celeste" is Margaret Eaton.

Jackson spent much of his time during his first two and a half years in office dealing with what came to be known as the "Petticoat Affair" or "Eaton Affair".[208][209] The affair focused on Secretary of War Eaton's wife, Margaret. She had a reputation for being promiscuous, and like Rachel Jackson, she was accused of adultery. She and Eaton had been close before her first husband John Timberlake died, and they married nine months after his death.[210] With the exception of Barry's wife Catherine,[211] the cabinet members' wives followed the lead of Vice-president Calhoun's wife Floride and refused to socialize with the Eatons.[212] Though Jackson defended Margaret, her presence split the cabinet, which had been so ineffective that he rarely called it into session,[194] and the ongoing disagreement led to its dissolution.[213]

In the spring of 1831, Jackson demanded the resignations of all the cabinet members except Barry,[214] who would resign in 1835 when a Congressional investigation revealed his mismanagement of the Post Office.[215] Jackson tried to compensate Van Buren by appointing him the Minister to Great Britain, but Calhoun blocked the nomination with a tie-breaking vote against it.[214] Van Buren—along with Amos Kendall, who helped organize what would become the Democratic Party,[216] and Francis Preston Blair, the editor of The Globe newspaper that served as Jackson's house organ,[217]—would become regular participants in Jackson's Kitchen Cabinet, an unofficial, varying group of advisors that Jackson turned to for decision making even after he had formed a new official cabinet.[218]

Jackson's Indian Removal Act and subsequent treaties resulted in the forced removal of the major tribes of the Southeast from their traditional territories, many along the Trail of Tears.

Jackson's presidency marked the beginning of a national policy of Native American removal.[214] Before Jackson took office, the relationship between the southern states and the Native American tribes who lived within their boundaries was strained. The states felt that they had full jurisdiction over their territories; the native tribes saw themselves as autonomous nations that had a right to the land they lived on.[219] Significant portions of the five major tribes in the south—the Cherokee, Choctaw, Chickasaw, Creek, and Seminole— began to adopt white culture, including education, agricultural techniques, a road system, and rudimentary manufacturing.[220] In the case of the tensions between the state of Georgia and the Cherokee, Adams had tried to address the issue encouraging Cherokee emigration west of the Mississippi through financial incentives, but most refused.[221]

In the first days of Jackson's presidency, some of the southern states had passed legislation extending state jurisdiction to Native American lands.[222] Jackson supported the states' right to do so.[223][224] His position was later made clear in the 1832 Supreme Court test case of this legislation, Worcester v. Georgia. Georgia had arrested a group of missionaries for entering Cherokee territory without a permit; the Cherokee declared these arrests illegal. The court under Chief Justice John Marshall decided in favor of the Cherokee: imposition of Georgia law on the Cherokee was unconstitutional.[225] Horace Greeley alleges that when Jackson heard the ruling, he said, "Well, John Marshall has made his decision, but now let him enforce it."[226] Although the quote may be apocryphal, Jackson made it clear he would not use the federal government to enforce the ruling.[227][228][229]

Jackson used the power of the federal government to enforce the separation of the Native American tribes and whites.[230] In May 1830, Jackson passed the Indian Removal Act through Congress.[231] It gave the president the right to negotiate treaties to buy tribal lands in the eastern part of the United States in exchange for lands set aside for Native Americans west of the Mississippi,[232] as well as broad discretion on how to use the federal funds allocated to the negotiations.[233] The law was supposed to be a voluntary relocation program, but it was not implemented as one. Jackson's administration often achieved agreement to relocate through bribes, fraud and intimidation,[234] and the leaders who signed the treaties often did not represent the entire tribe.[235] The relocations could be a source of misery too: the Choctaw relocation was rife with corruption, theft and mismanagement that brought great suffering to that people.[236]

Portrait of Jackson by Ralph E.W. Earle (c. 1830, North Carolina Museum of Art)

In 1830, Jackson personally negotiated with the Chickasaw, who quickly agreed to move.[237] In the same year, Choctaw leaders signed the Treaty of Dancing Rabbit Creek; the majority did not want the treaty but complied with its terms.[238] In 1832, Seminole leaders signed the Treaty of Payne's Landing, which stipulated that the Seminole would move west and become part of the Muscogee Creek Confederacy if they found the new land suitable.[239] Most Seminole refused to move, leading to a second Seminole War in 1835 that lasted six years.[235] Members of the Muscogee Creek Confederacy ceded their land to the state of Alabama in the Third Treaty of Washington of 1832. Their private ownership of the land was to be protected, but the federal government did not enforce this. The government did encourage voluntary removal until the Creek War of 1836, after which almost all Creek were removed to Oklahoma territory.[240] In 1836, Cherokee leaders ceded their land to the government by the Treaty of New Echota.[241] Their removal, known as the Trail of Tears, was enforced by Jackson's successor, Van Buren.[242]

Jackson also applied the removal policy in the Northwest. He was not successful in removing the Iroquois Confederation in New York, but when some members of the Meskwaki (Fox) and the Sauk triggered the Black Hawk War by trying to cross back to the east side of the Mississippi, the peace treaties ratified after their defeat reduced their lands further.[243]

During his administration, he made about 70 treaties with American Indian tribes. He had removed almost all the Native Americans east of the Mississippi and south of Lake Michigan, about 70,000 people, from the United States;[244] though it was done at the cost of thousands of Native American lives lost because of the unsanitary conditions and epidemics arising from their dislocation, as well as their resistance to expulsion.[245] Jackson's implementation of the Indian Removal Act contributed to his popularity with his constituency. He added over 170,000 square miles of land to the public domain, which primarily benefited the United States' agricultural interests. The act also benefited small farmers, as Jackson allowed them to purchase moderate plots at low prices and offered squatters on land formerly belonging to Native Americans the option to purchase it before it was offered for sale to others.[246]

Civil War-era lithograph cartoon of Calhoun bowing before Jackson during the Nullification Crisis by Pendleton's Lithography and published by L. Prang & Co. (1864)

Jackson had to confront another challenge that had been building up since the beginning of his first term. The Tariff of 1828, which had been passed in the last year of Adams' administration, set a protective tariff at a very high rate to prevent the manufactoring industries in the Northern states from having to compete with lower-priced imports from Britain.[247] The tariff reduced the income of southern cotton planters: it propped up consumer prices, but not the price of cotton which had severely declined in the previous decade.[248] Immediately after the tariff's passage, the South Carolina Exposition and Protest was sent to the US Senate.[249] This document, which had been anonymously written by John C. Calhoun, asserted that the constitution was a compact of individual states[250] and when the federal government went beyond its delegated duties, such as enacting a protective tariff, a state had a right to declare this action unconstitutional and make the act null and void with the borders of that state.[251]

Jackson suspected Calhoun of writing the Exposition and Protest, and opposed his interpretation. Jackson argued that Congress as a whole had full authority to enact tariffs and that a dissenting state was denying the will of the majority.[252] He also needed the tariff, which generated 90% of the federal revenue,[253] to achieve another of his presidential goals, eliminating the national debt.[254] The issue developed into a personal rivalry between the two men. For example, during a celebration of Thomas Jefferson's birthday on April 13, 1830, the attendees gave after-dinner toasts. Jackson toasted: "Our federal Union: It must be preserved!" – a clear challenge to nullification. Calhoun whose toast immediately followed, rebutted: "The Union: Next to our Liberty, the most dear!"[255]

As a compromise, Jackson supported the Tariff of 1832, which reduced the duties from the Tariff of 1828 by almost half. The bill was signed on July 9, but failed to satisfy extremists on either side.[256] On November 24, South Carolina had passed the Ordinance of Nullification,[257] declaring both tariffs null and void and threatening to secede from the United States if the federal government tried to use force to collect the duties.[258][259] In response, Jackson sent warships to Charleston harbor, and threatened to hang any man who worked to support nullification or secession.[260]

On December 10, Jackson issued a proclamation against the "nullifiers",[261] stating that he considered "the power to annul a law of the United States, assumed by one State, incompatible with the existence of the Union, contradicted expressly by the letter of the Constitution, unauthorized by its spirit, inconsistent with every principle on which it was founded, and destructive of the great object for which it was formed". South Carolina, the president declared, stood on "the brink of insurrection and treason", and he appealed to the people of the state to reassert their allegiance to that Union. Jackson also denied the right of secession: "The Constitution ... forms a government not a league ... To say that any State may at pleasure secede from the Union is to say that the United States are not a nation."[262] On December 28, Calhoun, who had been elected to the U. S. Senate, resigned as vice president.[263]

Jackson asked Congress to pass a "Force Bill" authorizing the military to enforce the tariff. It was attacked by Calhoun as despotism.[264] Meanwhile, Calhoun and Clay began to work on a new compromise tariff. Jackson saw it as an effective way to end the confrontation, but insisted on the passage of the Force Bill before he signed.[265] On March 2, he signed into law the Force Bill and the Tariff of 1833, both of which passed on March 1, 1833. The South Carolina Convention then met and rescinded its nullification ordinance, but nullified the Force Bill in a final act of defiance.[266] Two months later, Jackson reflected on South Carolina's nullification: "the tariff was only the pretext, and disunion and southern confederacy the real object. The next pretext will be the negro, or slavery question".[267]

Lithograph cartoon of Jackson destroying the Second Bank of the United States with his "Removal Notice" by Zachariah Downing, published by H. R. Robinson (c. 1833). Nicholas Biddle is portrayed as the devil.

A few weeks after his inauguration, Jackson started looking into how he could replace the Second Bank of the United States.[268] The Bank had been chartered by President Madison in 1816 to restore the United States economy after the War of 1812. Monroe had appointed Nicholas Biddle as the Bank's executive.[269] The Bank was a repository for the country's public monies which also serviced the national debt; it was formed as a for-profit entity that looked after the concerns of its share-holders.[270] Under the Bank's stewardship, the country was economically healthy[271] and the currency was stable,[272] but Jackson saw the Bank as a fourth branch of government run by an elite,[268] what he called the "money power" that sought to control the labor and earnings of the "real people", who depend on their own efforts to succeed: the planters, farmers, mechanics and laborers.[273] Additionally, Jackson's own near bankruptcy in 1804 due to credit-fuelled land speculation had biased him against paper money and toward a policy favorable to hard-money.[274]

In his First Annual Address in December 1829, Jackson openly challenged the Bank by questioning its constitutionality and the soundness of its money.[275] Jackson's supporters further alleged that it gave preferential loans to speculators and merchants over artisans and farmers, that it used its money to bribe Congressmen and the press, and that it had ties with foreign creditors. Biddle responded to Jackson's challenge in early 1830 by using the Bank's vast financial holding to ensure the Bank's reputation, and his supporters argued that the Bank was the key to prosperity and stable commerce. By the time of the 1832 election, Biddle spent had over $250,000 (equivalent to $6,400,000 today) in printing pamphlets, lobbying for pro-Bank legislation, hiring agents and giving loans to editors and Congressmen.[276]

On the surface, Jackson's and Biddle's positions did not appear irreconcilable. Jackson seemed open to keeping the Bank if it could include some degree of Federal oversight, limit its real estate holdings, and have its property subject to taxation by the states.[277] Many of Jackson's cabinet members thought a compromise was possible. In 1831, Treasury Secretary Louis McLane told Biddle that Jackson was open to chartering a modified version of the Bank, but Biddle did not consult Jackson directly. Privately, Jackson expressed opposition to the Bank;[278] publicly, he announced that he would leave the decision concerning the Bank in the hands of the people.[279] Biddle was finally convinced to take open action by Henry Clay, who had decided to run for president against Jackson in the 1832 election. Biddle would agree to seek renewal of the charter two years earlier than scheduled. Clay argued that Jackson was in a bind. If he vetoed the charter, he would loose the votes of his pro-Bank constituents in Pennsylvania; but if he signed the charter, he would lose his anti-Bank constituents. After the recharter bill was passed, Jackson vetoed it on 10 July 1832, arguing that the country should not surrender the will of the majority to the desires of the wealthy.[280]

1832 election results

The 1832 presidential election demonstrated the rapid development of political parties during Jackson's presidency. The Democratic Party's first national convention, held in Baltimore, nominated Jackson's choice for vice president, Martin Van Buren. The National Republican Party, which had held its first convention in Baltimore earlier in December 1831, nominated Clay, now a senator from Kentucky, and John Sergeant of Pennsylvania.[281] An Anti-Masonic Party with a platform built around opposition to Freemasonry,[282] it supported neither Jackson nor Clay, who both were Masons. The party nominated William Wirt of Maryland and Amos Ellmaker of Pennsylvania.[283]

In addition to the votes Jackson would lose because of the Bank veto, Clay hoped that Jackson's Indian Removal Act would alienate voters in the East; but Jackson's losses were offset by the Act's popularity in the West and Southwest. Clay had also expected that Jackson would lose votes because of his stand on internal improvements.[284] Jackson had vetoed the Maysville Road bill, which funded an upgrade of a section of the National Road in Clay's state of Kentucky; as part of his justification, Jackson claimed it was unconstitutional to fund internal improvements using national funds for local projects.[285]

Clay's strategy failed. Jackson was able to mobilize the Democratic Party's strong political networks.[286] The Northeast supported Jackson because he was in favor of maintaining a stiff tariff; the West supported him because the Indian Removal Act reduced the number of Native Americans in the region and made available more public land.[287] Except for South Carolina, which passed the Ordinance of Nullification during the election month and refused to support any party by giving its votes to the future Governor of Virginia John B. Floyd,[288] the South supported Jackson for implementing the Indian Removal Act, as well as for his willingness to compromise by signing the Tariff of 1832.[289] Jackson won the election by a landslide, receiving 55 percent of the popular vote and 219 electoral votes.[286]

Lithograph cartoon of "King Andrew the First" by an anonymous artist (c. 1832)

Jackson saw his victory as a mandate to continue his war on the Bank's control over the national economy.[290] In 1833, Jackson signed an executive order ending the deposit of Treasury receipts in the bank.[291] When Secretary of the Treasury McLane refused to execute the order, Jackson replaced him with William J. Duane, who also refused. Jackson then appointed Roger B. Taney as acting secretary, who implemented Jackson's policy.[292] With the loss of federal deposits, the Bank had to contract its credit.[293] Biddle used this contraction to create an economic downturn in an attempt to get Jackson to compromise. Biddle wrote, "Nothing but the evidence of suffering abroad will produce any effect in Congress."[294] The attempt did not succeed, the economy recovered and Biddle was blamed for the recession.[295]

Jackson's actions led those who disagreed with him to form the Whig Party. They claimed to oppose Jackson's expansion of executive power, calling him "King Andrew the First", and naming their party after the English Whigs who opposed seventeenth century British monarchy.[296] In March 1832, the Senate censured Jackson for inappropriately taking authority for the Treasury Department when it was the responsibility of Congress and refused to confirm Taney's appointment as secretary of the treasury.[297] In April, however, the House declared that the bank should not be rechartered. By July 1836, the Bank no longer held any federal deposits.[298]

Jackson had Federal funds deposited into state banks friendly to the administration's policies, which critics called pet banks.[299] The number of these state banks more than doubled during Jackson's administration,[292] and investment patterns changed. The Bank, which had been the federal government's fiscal agent, invested heavily in trade and financed interregional and international trade. State banks were more responsive to state governments, and invested heavily in land development, land speculation, and state public works projects.[300] In spite of the efforts of Taney's successor, Levi Woodbury, to control them, the pet banks expanded their loans, helping to create a speculative boom in the final years of Jackson's administration.[301]

In January 1835, Jackson paid off the national debt, the only time in U. S. history that it had been accomplished.[302][303] It was paid down through tariff revenues,[286] carefully managing federal funding of internal improvements like roads and canals,[304] and the sale of public lands.[305] Between 1834 and 1836, the government had unprecedented spike in land sales:[306] At its peak in 1836, the profits from land sales were eight to twelve times higher than a typical year.[307] During Jackson's presidency, 63 million acres of public land—about the size of the state of Oklahoma—was sold.[308] After Jackson stepped down from the presidency in 1837, a Democrat-majority Senate expunged Jackson's censure.[309][310]

Lithograph cartoon of the Panic of 1837 published by H. R. Robinson (1837). Jackson is symbolized by "Glory" in the sky with top hat, spectacles, and pipe.

Despite the economic boom following Jackson's victory in the Bank War, land speculation in the west caused the Panic of 1837.[311] Jackson's transfer of federal monies to state banks in 1833 caused western banks to relax their lending standards;[312] the Indian Removal Act made large amounts of former Native American lands available for purchase and speculation.[313] Two of Jackson's acts in 1836 contributed to the Panic of 1837. One was the Specie Circular, which mandated western lands only be purchased by money backed by specie. The act was intended to stabilize the economy by reducing speculation on credit, but it caused a drain of gold and silver from the Eastern banks to the Western banks to address the needs of financing land transactions.[314] The other was the Deposit and Distribution Act, which transferred federal monies from eastern to western state banks. Together, they left Eastern banks unable to pay specie to the British when they recalled their loans to address their economic problems in international trade.[315] The panic drove the U.S. economy went into a depression that lasted until 1841.[311]

Lithograph of attempted assassination of Andrew Jackson published by Endicott & Co. (1835)

Jackson was the first president to be subjected to physical assault as well an assassination attempt.[316] On 6 May 1833, Robert B. Randolph struck Jackson in the face with his hand because Jackson had ordered Randolph's dismissal from the navy for embezzlement. Jackson declined to press charges.[317] While leaving the United States Capitol On 30 January 1835, Richard Lawrence, an unemployed house painter from England, aimed a pistol at Jackson, which misfired. Lawrence pulled out a second pistol, which also misfired. Jackson attacked Lawrence with his cane until others intervened to restrain Lawrence, who was later found not guilty by reason of insanity and institutionalized.[318][319]

During Jackson's presidency, slavery remained a minor political issue.[320] Though Federal troops were used to crush Nat Turner's slave rebellion in 1831,[321] Jackson ordered them withdrawn immediately afterwards despite the petition of local citizens them to remain for protection.[322] Jackson considered the issue too divisive to the nation and to the delicate alliances of the Democratic party,[323] while sympathetic newspapers argued for excluding slavery from federal politics and keeping it at the state level.[324]

Jackson's view was challenged when the American Anti-Slavery Society formally agitated for abolition[325] by sending anti-slavery tracts through the postal system into the South in 1835.[323] Jackson condemned these agitators as "monsters"[326] who should atone with their lives[327] because they were attempting to destroy the Union by encouraging sectionalism.[328] The act provoked riots in Charleston, and pro-slavery Southerners demanded that the postal service ban distribution of the materials. To address the issue, Jackson authorized that the tracts could be sent only to subscribers, whose names could be made publicly accountable.[329] That December, Jackson called on Congress to prohibit the circulation through the South of "incendiary publications intended to instigate the slaves to insurrection".[330]

There was a risk of slavery becoming a problem again after Van Buren's presidential nomination in 1835 when abolitionists stepped up their campaign to raise the question of slavery in Congress.[331] Jackson saw these as election-year attempts by Whigs to undermine the Democrats. During the 1836 election year,[332] the House addressed the issue by passing a gag rule, which kept abolition from becoming a topic of debate: Congress would receive documents regarding abolition, but immediately table them without discussion. The strategy worked; the Democratic party stayed united and Van Buren, Jackson's chosen successor, was successfully elected president in 1836.[333]

Engraved portrait of Jackson as president by the Bureau of Engraving and Printing (c. 1928). Portrait appears on the 1929 $20 bill.[334]

The Jackson administration successfully negotiated trade agreements with Great Britain, Spain, Russian Empire, The Ottoman Empire and Siam.[335] In his First Annual Message to Congress, Jackson addressed the issues of spoliation claims, demands of compensation for the capture of American ships and sailors by foreign nations during the Napoleonic Wars.[336] Using a combination of bluster and tact, he successfully settled these claims with Denmark, Portugal, and Spain,[335] but he had difficulty collecting spoliation claims from France, which was unwilling to pay an indemnity agreed to in an earlier treaty. Jackson asked Congress in 1834 to authorize reprisals against French property if the country failed to make payment, as well as to arm for defense.[336] In response, French put its Caribbean fleet on a wartime footing.[337] Both sides wanted to avoid a conflict, but the French wanted an apology for Jackson's belligerence. In his 1835 Annual Message to the Congress, Jackson asserted that he refused to apologize, but stated that he did not intend to "menace or insult the Government of France".[338] The French were assuaged and agreed to pay $5,000,000 to settle the claims.[339]

Since the early 1820s, large numbers of Americans had been immigrating into Texas, a territory of the newly independent nation of Mexico.[340] As early as 1824, Jackson had expressed a desire to acquire the region for the United States.[341] In 1829, he attempted to purchase it, but Mexico did not want to sell. By 1830 there were twice as many settlers from the United States as from Mexico, leading to tensions with the Mexican government that started the Texas Revolution. During the conflict, Jackson covertly allowed the settlers to obtain weapons and money from the United States.[342] They defeated the Mexican military in April 1836 and soon afterward declared the region an independent country, the Republic of Texas. The new Republic asked Jackson to recognize and annex it. Although Jackson wanted to do so, he was hesitant because he was unsure it could maintain independence from Mexico.[335] He also was concerned because Texas had legalized slavery, which was an issue that could divide the Democrats during the 1836 election. Jackson recognized the Republic of Texas on the last full day of his presidency, March 3, 1837.[343]

Jackson appointed six justices to the Supreme Court.[344] Most were undistinguished. Jackson nominated Roger B. Taney in January 1835 to the Court in reward for his services, but the nomination failed to win Senate approval.[345] When Chief Justice Marshall died in 1835, Jackson nominated Taney for Chief Justice; he was confirmed by the new Senate,[346] serving as chief justice until 1864.[347] He was regarded with respect during his career on the bench, but he is most remembered for his decision in Dred Scott v. Sandford.[348]

Two new states were admitted into the Union during Jackson's presidency: Arkansas (June 15, 1836)[349] and Michigan (January 26, 1837).[350] Both states increased Democratic power in Congress and helped Van Buren win the presidency in 1836, as new states tended to support the party that had done the most to admit them.[351]

Jackson and Rachel had no children together but adopted Andrew Jackson Jr., the son of Rachel's deceased brother Severn Donelson. The Jacksons acted as guardians for Donelson's other children: John Samuel, Daniel Smith, and Andrew Jackson. They were also guardians for Andrew Jackson Hutchings, Rachel's orphaned grand nephew, and the orphaned children of a friend, Edward Butler – Caroline, Eliza, Edward, and Anthony – who lived with the Jacksons after their father died.[368] Jackson also had three Creek children living with them: Lyncoya, a Creek orphan Jackson had adopted after the Battle of Tallushatchee,[369] and two boys they called Theodore[370] and Charley.[371]

Jackson as a Tennessee Gentleman by Ralph E. W. Earl ( c. 1831, the Hermitage, Tennessee)

For the only time in U.S. history, two women acted simultaneously as unofficial First Lady for the widower Jackson. Rachel's niece Emily Donelson was married to Andrew Jackson Donelson (who acted as Jackson's private secretary) and served as hostess at the White House. The president and Emily became estranged for over a year during the Petticoat affair, but they eventually reconciled and she resumed her duties as White House hostess. Sarah Yorke Jackson, the wife of Andrew Jackson Jr., became co-hostess of the White House in 1834, and took over all hostess duties after Emily died from tuberculosis in 1836.[372]

Jackson had a reputation for being short-tempered and violent,[373] which terrified his opponents.[374] He was able to use his temper strategically to accomplish what he wanted.[375][376][377] He could keep it in check when necessary: his behavior was friendly and urbane when he went to Washington as Senator during the campaign leading up to the 1824 election. According to Van Buren, he remained calm in times of difficulty and made his decisions deliberatively.[378]

He had the tendency to take things personally. If someone crossed him, he would often become obsessed with crushing them.[379] For example, on the last day of his presidency, Jackson declared he had only two regrets: that he had not hanged Henry Clay or shot John C. Calhoun.[380] He also had a strong sense of loyalty. He considered threats to his friends as threats to himself, but he demanded unquestioning loyalty in return.[381]

Jackson was self-confident,[382] without projecting a sense of self-importance.[383] This self-confidence gave him the ability to persevere in the face of adversity.[384] Once he decided on a plan of action, he would adhere to it.[385] His reputation for being both quick-tempered and confident worked to his advantage;[386] it misled opponents to see him as simple and direct, leading them to often understimate his political shrewdness.[387]

In 1838, Jackson became an official member of the First Presbyterian Church in Nashville.[388] Both his mother and his wife had been devout Presbyterians all their lives, but Jackson stated that he had postponed officially entering the church until after his retirement to avoid accusations that he had done so for political reasons.[389]

The Verdict of the People by George Caleb Bingham, (1854, Saint Louis Art Museum). An illustration of Jacksonian Democracy[394]

Jackson became president during a time of increasing white male suffrage.[395] His political victories led to the emergence of the Democratic Party,[396] which committed itself to abolishing all voting restrictions based on property or tax payments.[397] This change in political outlook became known as "Jacksonian Democracy".[398] Jackson believed that the country should be run by majority rule:[399] the government should be responsive to its constituents,[400] voters should be able to elect their representatives without mediating institutions like the Electoral College,[401] and the president directly represents the American people.[402] He argued that the sovereign power of the people lies in the constitution, not the state or the courts,[403] and that the president had a right to interpret laws independently of the judiciary.[404] Jackson asserted that because the government represents the majority, it has no right to grant favors such as corporate charters or subsidies to a privileged few.[405] The role of the government is to administer justice but otherwise to stay out of people's affairs.[406]

During Jackson's presidency, Alexis de Tocqueville described America as an experiment in self-government by a sovereign people but warned of its dangers, such as becoming a tyranny of the majority.[407] Jackson's Whig opponents expressed this concern, characterizing him as a king,[408] and Whig historians during the nineteenth century described Jacksonian Democracy as a program of exclusion in which capable people were replaced with mob rule.[409][410]

In the 1920s, the Jacksonian era became associated with the idea of the "common man";[411] a connection that remains strong today.[412] This idea defined the age as a populist rejection of social elites and a vindication of every person's value independent of class and status.[413] Jackson was seen as its personification,[414] an individual free of societal constraints who can achieve great things.[415] In 1945, Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr.'s influential Age of Jackson redefined Jacksonian Democracy through the lens of Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal,[416] describing the common man as a member of the working class struggling against exploitation by business concerns.[417] [418] Schlesinger quotes Roosevelt as saying that Jackson's heritage is "his unending contributions to the vitality of our democracy".[419]

In the twenty-first century, Jacksonian Democracy's value as a distinct concept has been brought into question, as many of its characteristics were already developing before Jackson's time.[420][421]

Critics of Jacksonian Democracy have argued that it was fundamentally racist, and that its egalitarianism is based on the assumption of white supremacy[422][423][424] in what has been called a "master race democracy".[425] During this era, condescending and hostile racist arguments were used to deny suffrage to free African Americans across most of the country.[426][427] Abolition was not considered a threat because of its moral significance, but because of its potential to disrupt national unity.[428][429][430] Abolitionists were seen as fanatics who amassed local power and flouted the democratic process to privilege African Americans over whites. The anti-slavery movement eventually replaced "money power" as the enemy of Jacksonian politics.[422]

Engraving of Jackson and William Weatherford (Red Eagle) after the Battle of Horseshoe Bend by J. W. Ridgeway after work by John R. Chapin (c. 1859)

Jackson participated in treaties before and during his presidency in which the major tribes of the Southeast ceded their land.[431]

The removal of Native Americans from lands claimed by the United States had been a long-term goal of the federal government.[432] Before he became president, Jackson had played a key role in negotiating treaties that required Native American tribes to cede their lands. In addition to the Creek territory he took at the Treaty of Fort Jackson after the Red Stick War in 1814,[433] he negotiated further cessions from the Creek, Choctaw, and Chickasaw in 1816. He helped negotiate the Treaty of Tuscaloosa with the Chickasaw that resulted in the Jackson Purchase in 1818 and obtained additional cessions from the Choctaw at the Treaty of Doak's Stand in 1820.[434] Jackson's victory in the First Seminole War was instrumental in convincing the Seminole to sign Treaty of Moultrie Creek in 1823, which surrendered much of their land in Florida.[435]

The Indian Removal Act made Native American displacement an official federal policy.[436] Jackson felt the act was the key to national development. Native Americans still occupied rich lands, and their existence as separate nations was seen to threaten American sovereignty.[437] Jackson presented the act as voluntary.[438] He argued that deportation was the most humane solution to address the ongoing problems between Native Americans and whites;[439] otherwise, Native Americans would eventually be conquered by war or subjugated by the states, which would lead to their annihilation.[440]

When the Indian Removal Act was passed, it was seen to have positive benefits. It increased Jackson's popularity in the states that were directly impacted by Native American removal, expanded the amount of land available for cotton cultivation,[441] and almost doubled the rate of land improvement.[246] Its implementation infused federal money into the Western states.[442] In his Farewell Address in 1837, Jackson described the act as one of his successes, arguing that it had increased the well-being of Americans while allowing the federal government to oversee and protect the well-being of Native Americans.[443] Some contemporary historians have agreed with Jackson, adding that his solution was the best available at the time[444] and it achieved its goal of allowing the Native American tribes to survive.[445]

More recently, Jackson's Indian Removal Act has been described as ethnic cleansing:[446] the use of force, terror and violence to make an area ethnically homogeneous.[447] To achieve the goal of separating Native Americans from the whites,[448] coercive force such as threats and bribes were used to effect removal [449] and unauthorized military force was used when there was resistance,[234] as in the case of the Second Seminole War.[450] The act has also been discussed in the context of genocide. On its own, it does not easily fit into a definition of genocide because its aim was separation, not annihilation;[451] but its role in the long-term destruction of Native American societies and their cultures continues to be a source of controversy.[452]

Jackson's complex personality made him a controversial figure. Writing just fifteen years after Jackson's death, James Parton summed him up as follows:

Andrew Jackson, I am given to understand, was a patriot and a traitor. He was one of the greatest generals, and wholly ignorant of the art of war. A brilliant writer, elegant, eloquent, without being able to compose a correct sentence or spell words of four syllables. The first of statesmen, he never devised, he never framed, a measure. He was the most candid of men, and was capable of the most profound dissimulation. A most law-defying law-obeying citizen. A stickler for discipline, he never hesitated to disobey his superior. A democratic autocrat. An urbane savage. An atrocious saint.[453]

Equestrian statue of Jackson by Charles Keck in front of the Jackson County Courthouse, Kansas City, Missouri (1934). Commissioned by Judge Harry S. Truman

These apparent contradictions still remain part of Jackson's legacy. Since the 1900s, he has been described as a frontiersman personifying the independence of the American West,[454] a slave-owning member of the Southern gentry,[455] a populist who promoted faith in the wisdom of the ordinary citizen and the will of the majority, [456] and an autocratic demogogue who incited violence for political ends.[457] He has been represented as a statesman who substantially advanced the spirit of democracy[458]and upheld the foundations of American constitutionalism, [459]as well as a dominating personality who knew how to wield power to crush opposition and trampled the law.[460]

His legacy has been variously interpreted by other presidents. Franklin Roosevelt used Jackson to redefine the Democratic party, describing him as a defender of the exploited and downtrodden and as a fighter for social justice and human rights.[461][462] Donald Trump used Jackson's legacy to present an image of himself as the president of the common man,[463] praising Jackson for saving the country from a rising aristocracy and protecting American workers with a tariff.[464] Abraham Lincoln used Jackson's ideas to negotiate the challenges to the Union that he faced during 1861, including Jackson's understanding of the constitution during the nullification crisis and the president's right to interpret the constitution as he understood it.[465]

Jackson's contradictory legacy is seen in opinion polls. In a 2014 survey asking political scientists to rate presidential greatness, Jackson was the ninth-highest rated president, but the second-most polarizing. He was also rated the second-most overrated president.[466] Jackson usually scores in the top half of presidents in public opinion polls looking at their performance, but his ratings have been dropping. In a C-SPAN poll, Jackson was ranked the 13th in 2009, 18th in 2017, and 22nd in 2021.[467][468]

In 2016, President Barack Obama's administration announced it was removing Jackson's portrait from the $20 bill and replacing it with one of Harriet Tubman.[469] Though the plan was put on hold during Trump's presidency, President Joseph Biden's administration resumed it in 2021.[470]

The continuing debate over Jackson's significance is part of what makes his legacy relevant today. The unresolved issues about the meaning of Jackson's actions reflect the ongoing questions that Americans face when judging the origins and meaning of their democracy.[471]