Il Canto degli Italiani

On the left, Goffredo Mameli (1827–1849), author of the lyrics, on the right, Michele Novaro (1818–1885), composer of the music

Holographic draft of 1847 by Goffredo Mameli of the first strophe and the refrain of "Il Canto degli Italiani"

The text of "Il Canto degli Italiani" was written by the Genoese Goffredo Mameli, then a young student and a fervent patriot, in a historical context characterized by that widespread patriotism that already heralded the revolutions of 1848 and the First Italian War of Independence (1848-1849).[3]

On the precise date of the drafting of the text, the sources differ: according to some scholars, the hymn was written by Mameli on 10 September 1847,[4] while according to others the date of birth of the composition was two days before, 8 September.[5]

After having discarded the idea of adapting it to existing music,[6] 10 November 1847[7] Goffredo Mameli sent the text of the hymn to Turin to set it to music by the Genoese composer Michele Novaro, who was in the house at that time of the patriot Lorenzo Valerio.[4][6][8]

Novaro was immediately conquered[9] and, on 24 November 1847, he decided to set it to music.[4] Thus Anton Giulio Barrili, patriot and poet, remembered in April 1875, during a commemoration of Mameli, the words of Novaro on the birth of the music of "Il Canto degli Italiani":[3]

1915: cover of an album of patriotic music: the personification of Italy, wearing the helmet of Scipio and waving the flag of Italy, driving the Bersaglieri gathered around it

I placed myself at the harpsichord, with the verses of Goffredo on the lectern, and I strummed, murdered the poor instrument with convulsive fingers, always with eyes at the hymn, putting down melodic phrases, one above the other, but a thousand miles from the idea that they could adapt to those words. I stood up disgruntled with myself; I stayed a little longer in the Valerio house, but always with those verses before the eyes of the mind. I saw that there was no remedy, I took leave and ran home. There, without even taking off my hat, I threw myself at the piano. The motif strummed in the Valerio house came back to me: I wrote it on a sheet of paper, the first that came to my hands: in my agitation I turned the lamp over the harpsichord and, consequently, also on the poor sheet; this was the origin of the Fratelli d'Italia

— Michele Novaro

Mameli, who was Republican, Jacobin[10][11] and supporter of the motto born from the French Revolution liberté, égalité, fraternité,[12] to write the text of "Il Canto degli Italiani" was inspired by the French national anthem, "La Marseillaise".[13] For example, "Stringiamci a coorte" recalls the verse of the "La Marseillaise", "Formez vos bataillons" ("Form your battalions").[11]

There was another verse in the first version of "Il Canto degli Italiani" that was dedicated to Italian women.[14] The verse, eliminated by Mameli himself before the official debut of the hymn, read:[14][15] "Tessete o fanciulle / bandiere e coccarde / fan l'alme gagliarde / l'invito d'amor. ([tesˈseːte o fanˈtʃulle], [banˈdjɛːr(e) e kkokˈkarde], [fan ˈlalme ɡaʎˈʎarde], [liɱˈviːto daˈmor]. English: Weave maidens / flags and cockades[N 1] / they make souls gallant / the invitation of love.)"

In the original version of the hymn, the first verse of the first verse read "Hurray Italy", Mameli then changed it to "Fratelli d'Italia" almost certainly at the suggestion of Michele Novaro himself.[16] The latter, when he received the manuscript, also added a rebellious "Yes!" at the end of the refrain sung after the last strophe.[17][18]

The first printed copy of the hymn was made on a flying sheet by the Delle Piane typography of Genoa. It was distributed on 10 December 1847 to those who took part in the procession of the Genoese district of Oregina. Mameli then added in pen the fifth strophe of the hymn, initially censored by the Savoy government because it was considered too anti-Austrian.

On 10 December 1847,[14] a demonstration, organized in front of the Santuario della Nostra Signora di Loreto of the Genoese district of Oregina, was officially dedicated to the 101st anniversary of the popular rebellion of the Genoese quarter of Portoria during the War of the Austrian Succession which led to the expulsion of the Austrians from the city. In fact, it was an excuse to protest against foreign occupations in Italy and induce Charles Albert of Sardinia to embrace the Italian cause of liberty and of unity.

On this occasion, the flag of Italy was shown and Mameli's hymn was publicly sung for the first time. It was played by the Filarmonica Sestrese, the then municipal band of Sestri Ponente, in front of a part of those 30 000 patriots - coming from all over Italy - who had come to Genoa for the event.[6] On 18 December 1847 the newspaper L'Italia of Pisa published this news from Turin:

The santuario della Nostra Signora di Loreto of the Genoese district of Oregina in front of which, on 10 December 1847, "Il Canto degli Italiani" made its public debut

... For many evenings numerous youths have come together in the Accademia filodrammatici to sing a hymn of Mameli, set to music by the maestro Novaro. Poetry ... is full of fire, music fully corresponds to it ...

— Newspaper L'Italia, 18 December 1847, [19]

There was perhaps a previous public rendition, of which the original documentation was lost, by the Filarmonica Voltrese founded by Nicola Mameli, brother of Goffredo,[20] on 9 November 1847 in Genoa.[21] In this first public performance the first version of "Il Canto degli Italiani" was sung, later modified in the definitive version.[21] Being its notoriously Mazzinian author, the piece was forbidden by the Piedmontese police until March 1848: its execution was also forbidden by the Austrian police, which also pursued its singing interpretation - considered a political crime - until the end of the First World War.[22]

There are two autograph manuscripts up to the 21st century; the first, the original one linked to the first draft, with hand annotations by Mameli himself, is located at the Mazzinian Institute of Genoa,[23] while the second, sent by Mameli on 10 November 1847 to Novaro, is kept at the Museo del Risorgimento in Turin.[7] The autograph manuscript that Novaro sent to the publisher Francesco Lucca is instead located in the Ricordi Historical Archive.[24] The sheet that is found at Istituto Mazziniano, subsequent to the two manuscripts, lacks the last strophe ("Son giunchi che piegano...") for fear of censorship. These leaflets were to be distributed at the 10 December demonstration, in Genoa.[25] The hymn was also printed on leaflets in Genoa, by the printing office Casamara.

Edition of 1860 printed by Tito I Ricordi

When "Il Canto degli Italiani" debuted, there were only a few months left to the revolutions of 1848. Shortly before the promulgation of the Statuto Albertino, the constitution that Charles Albert of Sardinia conceded to the Kingdom of Sardinia in Italy on 4 March 1848, a coercive law had been abrogated that prohibited gatherings of more than ten people.[6] From this moment on, "Il Canto degli Italiani" experienced a growing success thanks to its catchiness, which facilitated its diffusion among the population.[6] After 10 December the hymn spread all over the Italian peninsula, brought by the same patriots that participated in the Genoa demonstration.[6] In the 1848, Mameli's hymn was very popular among the Italian people and it was commonly sung during demonstrations, protests and revolts as a symbol of the Italian unification in most parts of Italy.[26]

When "Il Canto degli Italiani" became popular, the Savoy authorities censored the fifth strophe,[3] extremely harsh with the Austrians; however after the declaration of war to Austrian Empire and the beginning of the First Italian War of Independence (1848-1849),[27] the soldiers and the Savoy military bands performed it so frequently that King Charles Albert was forced to withdraw all censorship.[28] The anthem was in fact widespread, especially among the ranks of the Republican volunteers.[29]

In the Five Days of Milan, the rebels sang "Il Canto degli Italiani" during clashes against the Austrian Empire[30] and was sung frequently during the celebrations for the promulgation, by Charles Albert of Piedmont-Sardinia, of the Statuto Albertino (also in 1848).[31] Even the brief experience of the Roman Republic (1849) had, among the hymns most sung by the volunteers,[32] "Il Canto degli Italiani",[33] with Giuseppe Garibaldi who used to hum and whistle it during the defense of Rome and the flight to Venice.[4] In the 1860, the corps of volunteers led by Giuseppe Garibaldi used to sing the hymn in the battles against the Bourbons in Sicily and Southern Italy during the Expedition of the Thousand.[34] Giuseppe Verdi, in his Inno delle nazioni ("Hymn of the nations"), composed for the London International Exhibition of 1862, chose "Il Canto degli Italiani" to represent Italy, putting it beside "God Save the Queen" and "La Marseillaise".

Propagandist poster from the 1910s showing the score of "Il Canto degli Italiani"

After the proclamation of the Kingdom of Italy (1861) the "Marcia Reale" ("Royal March"),[35] composed in 1831, was chosen as the national anthem of unified Italy: the decision was taken because "Il Canto degli Italiani", which had too little conservative contents and was characterized by a strong republican imprint and Jacobin,[10][11] did not combine with the epilogue of the unification of Italy, of monarchical origin.[27] The references to the republican creed of Mameli - which was in fact Mazzinian - were, however, more historical than political;[11] on the other hand, the "Il Canto degli Italiani" was disliked also by the socialist and anarchist circles, which considered it instead the opposite, that is too little revolutionary.[36]

Front page of the Corriere della Sera of May 21, 1915: the deputies acclaimed the assumption of powers by the government, due to the imminent Italian entry into the First World War, singing the anthem of Mameli and Novaro.

The song was one of the most common songs during the Third Italian War of Independence (1866),[27] and even the Capture of Rome on 20 September 1870, the last part of the Italian unification, was accompanied by choirs that sang it together with Bella Gigogin and the "Marcia Reale";[35][37] on this occasion, "Il Canto degli Italiani" was often performed also by the fanfare of the Bersaglieri.[38]

Even after the end of the Italian unification, "Il Canto degli Italiani", which was taught in schools, remained very popular among Italians,[39] but it was joined by other musical pieces that were connected to the political and social situation of the time as, for example, the "Inno dei lavoratori" ("Hymn of the workers") or "Goodbye to Lugano",[40] which partly obscured the popularity of the hymns used during Italian unification (including "Il Canto degli Italiani"), since they had a meaning more related to everyday problems.[41]

"Fratelli d'Italia", thanks to references to patriotism and armed struggle,[41] returned to success during the Italo-Turkish War (1911–1912), where it joined "A Tripoli",[42] and in the trenches of the First World War (1915–1918):[41] the Italian irredentism that characterized it indeed found a symbol in "Il Canto degli Italiani", although in the years following the last war context cited he would have been preferred, in the patriotic ambit, musical pieces of greater military style such as "La Leggenda del Piave", the "Canzone del Grappa" or "La campana di San Giusto".[36] Shortly after Italy entered the First World War, on 25 July 1915, Arturo Toscanini performed "Il Canto degli Italiani" during an interventionist demonstration.[43][44]

"Il Canto degli Italiani" remembered together with the unification of Italy on a propaganda poster of the Italian Social Republic of Benito Mussolini

After the march on Rome (1922) the purely fascist chants such as "Giovinezza" (or "Inno Trionfale del Partito Nazionale Fascista") took on great importance,[45] and which were widely disseminated and publicized, as well as taught in schools, although they were not official anthems.[46] In this context the non-fascist melodies were discouraged, and "Il Canto degli Italiani" was not an exception.[41] In 1932 the secretary of the National Fascist Party Achille Starace decided to prohibit the musical pieces that did not sing to Benito Mussolini and, more generally, those not directly linked to fascism.[47]

Thus the tracks were judged to be subversive, i.e. those of anarchist or socialist type, such as the anthem of the workers or "The Internationale", and the official anthems of foreign nations not sympathizing with fascism, such as "La Marseillaise",[48] were banned. After the signing of the Lateran Treaty between the Kingdom of Italy and the Holy See (1929), anti-clerical passages were also banned.[48] The chants used during the Italian unification were however tolerated:[36][48] "Il Canto degli Italiani", which was forbidden in official ceremonies, was granted a certain condescension only on particular occasions.[48]

In the spirit of this directive, for example, songs such as the Nazi hymn "Horst-Wessel-Lied" and the Francoist song "Cara al Sol" were encouraged, as they were official musical pieces from regimes akin to that led by Benito Mussolini.[48] Otherwise, some songs were resized, such as "La leggenda del Piave", sung almost exclusively during the National Unity and Armed Forces Day every 4 November.[49]

During the Second World War, fascist pieces composed by regime musicians were released, also via radio: there were very few songs spontaneously born among the population.[50] In the years of the second war, songs like "A primavera viene il bello", "Battaglioni M", "Vincere!" and "Camerata Richard" were common, while, among the spontaneously born songs, the most famous was On the "Sul ponte di Perati".[51]

After the armistice of 8 September 1943, the Italian government provisionally adopted as a national anthem, replacing the "Marcia Reale", "La leggenda del Piave":[36][52][53] the Italian monarchy had in fact been questioned for having allowed the establishment of the fascist dictatorship;[36] recalling the Italian victory in the First World War, it could infuse courage and hope to the troops of the Royal Italian Army who fought the Italian Social Republic of Benito Mussolini and the Nazi Germany.[54]

In this context, "Fratelli d'Italia", along with other songs used during Italian unification and partisan songs, resounded in Southern Italy freed by the Allies and in the areas controlled by the partisans north of the war front.[55] "Il Canto degli Italiani", in particular, had a good success in anti-fascist circles,[49] where it joined the partisan songs "Fischia il vento" and "Bella ciao".[36][55] Some scholars believe that the success of the piece in anti-fascist circles was then decisive for its choice as a provisional anthem of the Italian Republic.[43]

Often, "Il Canto degli Italiani" is wrongly referred to as the national anthem of the Italian Social Republic of Benito Mussolini. However, the lack of an official national anthem of the Republic of Mussolini is documented: in fact, "Il Canto degli Italiani" or "Giovinezza"[56] was performed in the ceremonies. "Il Canto degli Italiani" and - more generally - the themes referring to the unification of Italy were used by the Republic of Mussolini, with a change of course compared to the past, for propaganda purposes only.[57]

So Mameli's hymn was, curiously, sung by both the Italian partisans and the people who supported the Italian Social Republic (fascists).[58]

Cipriano Facchinetti

In 1945, at the end of the war, Arturo Toscanini directed the performance of the Inno delle nazioni in London, composed by Giuseppe Verdi in 1862 and including "Il Canto degli Italiani";[3][59] however, as a provisional national anthem, even after the birth of the Italian Republic, "La leggenda del Piave"[60] was temporarily confirmed.

For the choice of the national anthem a debate was opened which identified, among the possible options: the "Va, pensiero" from Giuseppe Verdi's Nabucco, the drafting of a completely new musical piece, "Il Canto degli Italiani", the "Inno di Garibaldi" and the confirmation of "La Leggenda del Piave".[60][61] The political class of the time then approved the proposal of the War Minister Cipriano Facchinetti, who foresaw the adoption of "Il Canto degli Italiani" as a provisional anthem of the State.[61]

"La Leggenda del Piave" then had the function of the national anthem of the Italian Republic until the Council of Ministers of 12 October 1946, when Cipriano Facchinetti (of republican political belief), officially announced that during the celebrations of 4 November for National Unity and Armed Forces Day, in which the armed services of the republic will perform their oath of loyalty to the young republic, as a provisional anthem, "Il Canto degli Italiani" would have been adopted.[62][63] The press release stated that:[64]

... On the proposal of the Minister of War it was established that the oath of the Armed Forces to the Republic and to its Chief would be carried out on November 4th p.v. and that, temporarily, the anthem of Mameli is adopted as the national anthem ...

— Cipriano Facchinetti

Facchinetti also declared that a draft decree would be proposed which would confirm "Il Canto degli Italiani" as the provisional national anthem of the newly formed Republic, an intention which, however, was not followed up.[63][65]

Facchinetti proposed to formalize "Il Canto degli Italiani" in the Constitution of Italy, in preparation at that time, but without success.[61] The Constitution, which came into force in 1948, sanctioned, in article 12, the use of the flag of Italy as a national flag, but did not establish what the national anthem would be, nor even the national symbol of Italy, which was later adopted by legislative decree dated 5 May 1948.[66]

The President of the Italian Republic Sergio Mattarella, between the Corazzieri and the guard of honour, pays tribute to the Tomb of the Italian Unknown Soldier (November 4, 2016).

A draft constitutional law prepared in the immediate post-war period whose final objective was the insertion, in article 12, of the paragraph "The Anthem of the Republic is the "Il Canto degli Italiani"" was not followed, as well as the hypothesis of a decree presidential election that issued a specific regulation.[67]

"Il Canto degli Italiani" then had great success among Italian emigrants:[68] scores of "Fratelli d'Italia" can be found, together with the flag of Italy, in many shops of the various Little Italy scattered in the Anglosphere. "Il Canto degli Italiani" is often played on more or less official occasions in North and South America:[68] in particular, it was the "soundtrack" of the fundraisers destined to the Italian population left devastated by the conflict, which were organized in the second post-war period in the Americas.[69]

It was the President of the Republic Carlo Azeglio Ciampi, in charge from 1999 to 2006, to activate a work of valorisation and re-launch of "Il Canto degli Italiani" as one of the national symbol of Italy.[70][71] With reference to "Il Canto degli Italiani", Ciampi declared that:[71]

... It is a hymn that, when you listen to it, makes you vibrate inside; it is a song of freedom of a people that, united, rises again after centuries of divisions, of humiliations ...

— Carlo Azeglio Ciampi

In August 2016, a bill was submitted to the Constitutional Affairs Committee of the Chamber of Deputies to make "Il Canto degli Italiani" Italy's national anthem.[72] In July 2017, the committee approved this bill.[73] On 15 December 2017, on Gazzetta Ufficiale law nº 181 of 4 December 2017 was published after passing both houses of Parliament, and the law came into force on 30 December 2017.[74]

• Bassi, Adriano (2011). Fratelli d'Italia: I grandi personaggi del Risorgimento, la musica e l'unità (in Italian). Paoline. ISBN 978-88-315-3994-4.
• Caddeo, Rinaldo (1915). Inni di Guerra e Canti patriottici del Popolo Italiano (in Italian). Casa Editrice Risorgimento. ISBN 1-178-22330-2.
• Calabrese, Michele (2011). "Il Canto degli Italiani: genesi e peripezie di un inno". Quaderni del Bobbio (in Italian). 3.
• Jacoviello, Stefano (2012). Passioni collettive. Cultura, politica e società (in Italian). Nuova Cultura. ISBN 978-88-6134-862-2.
• Maiorino, Tarquinio; Marchetti Tricamo, Giuseppe; Zagami, Andrea (2002). Il tricolore degli italiani. Storia avventurosa della nostra bandiera (in Italian). Arnoldo Mondadori Editore. ISBN 978-88-04-50946-2.
• Ridolfi, Pierluigi (2002). Canti e poesie per un'Italia unita dal 1821 al 1861 (in Italian). Associazione Amici dell'Accademia dei Lincei.
• Ridolfi, Maurizio (2003). Almanacco della Repubblica: storia d'Italia attraverso le tradizioni, le istituzioni e le simbologie repubblicane (in Italian). Bruno Mondadori. ISBN 978-88-424-9499-7.
• Stramacci, Mauro (1991). Goffredo Mameli (in Italian). Edizioni Mediterranee. ISBN 88-272-0932-8.
• Vulpone, Pasquale (2002). Il Canto degli Italiani. Inno d'Italia (in Italian). Pellegrini. ISBN 88-8101-140-9.