How to Fix Cake Disasters

Co-authored by Maria Short

Last Updated: November 3, 2022 References

Baking has its ups and downs, and if you've ended up with a cake disaster in the kitchen, don't worry! It's likely you can do something to salvage the situation. Whether your cake didn't rise or you ended up with a broken or too-done cake, you can hopefully find a solution to help you either fix the cake or turn it into something else presentable.

Method 1

Method 1 of 4:

Fixing a Cake that Didn't Rise

1
Cook an unrisen cake that's still doughy a bit longer. If you check a cake and it still has batter in the middle, it may just not have had time to rise yet. Put it back in the oven for 5-10 minutes, keeping an eye on it to make sure you don't overdo it. You may still get your cake to rise.^{[1]
X
Research source}
2
Crumble the cake and mix it with frosting to make cake balls. Mix in store-bought or homemade frosting, adding just enough so the mixture comes together when squeezed. Roll the mixture into balls, and then toss in coconut, sprinkles, or cocoa powder.^{[2]
X
Research source}
- You can also coat the cake balls with melted chocolate and let them cool.
- This trick also works for a cake that's too dry.
Advertisement
3
Create a cake dome out of 2 thin sheets of cake if the cake didn't rise enough. Slice a 1-layer cake in half with a large bread knife to make 2 thin sheets. Lay plastic wrap in a large mixing bowl to use as a mold, and put one layer of the cake in the bottom of the bowl. Trim off any extra cake around the top until you have a mostly even circle. Add frosting or mousse to the middle of the cake bowl you've just made, then place the other layer of cake on top.^{[3]
X
Research source}
- Trim off any excess cake sticking over the edge so it all fits in the bowl.
- Place the cake in the refrigerator to set before turning it out on a plate. You can pour melted chocolate over the dome or smooth frosting on the round part of the dome for decoration.
4
Fill a sunken cake with candy for a festive effect. If just the center is sunk in, frost the cake as normal, then use it as a bowl for holding candies. Fill it with unwrapped candy, such as coated chocolate pieces, gummy bears, fruit candies, or any other candy you like.^{[4]
X
Research source}
- You can also fill the sunken cake with mousse or lemon curd and put frosting over the top instead. This makes a quick and easy pudding or dessert dish.
5
Turn a sunken cake into an ice cream cake to please the young at heart. Scoop softened ice cream into the sunken center of the sunken cake and smooth it out. Freeze the cake for about 30 minutes, then take it out. Add frosting across the top of the ice cream and around the edges, just as you'd normally frost a cake, to finish the ice cream cake.^{[5]
X
Research source}
- For a simpler topping, cover the cake in whipped cream and decorate with maraschino cherries.

Method 2

Method 2 of 4:

Working on a Cracked or Broken Cake

1
Make a trifle from broken cake pieces for a lovely layered dessert. Layer pieces of the cake in a large trifle dish or mixing bowl. Add a sprinkling of alcohol for flavor, if you wish, then add layers of things like pudding, frosting, fruit, mousse, or whipped cream in any combination. As you layer, add enough of each ingredient to spread it across the dish. Repeat layering until all the cake is used up.^{[6]
X
Research source}
- Make the top look extra special. Create a smooth layer on top with whipped cream or frosting, then top with chocolate curls or sprinkles for decoration.
2
Cover a cracked cake with frosting to hide its imperfection. Frosting will hide small cracks perfectly. If it's severely cracked, use a little frosting to try to "glue" the pieces back together; do this by spreading the frosting down into the crack and pressing it back together. Then cover the whole cake top with a thin layer of slightly softened frosting, creating a crumb layer.^{[7]
X
Research source}
- Let this set, then add a second, thicker layer of icing for decoration. If done well, it'll be hard to even notice it was cracked.^{[8]
  X
  Research source}
- Don't overdo the frosting crack infill though; too much frosting will make the whole experience sugary and unpleasant to eat.
3
Flip a cracked cake over to create a smooth top. If the cake just has cracks on top, you can always just use the bottom as the top. That way, you have a nice, smooth surface to work with.^{[9]
X
Research source} The base will be less firm though, so don't be surprised if it crumbles on the plate; this solution is best for home use.
- Another option is to level the cake by slicing off a thin layer at the top to make it smooth. Use a bread knife to cut an even layer across the top.
4
Create cake bark from the broken cake for a fun treat. Melt milk, dark, or white chocolate or candy melts and pour the melted chocolate onto a baking sheet lined with parchment paper. Use a spatula to spread the melted chocolate out thinly. Let it cool for 30 minutes, then crumble the cake over it in an even, thin layer. Press the cake into the melted layer. Spread another layer of chocolate on top and let it cool.^{[10]
X
Research source} The chocolate and cake will set together. To serve, break into individual pieces.

Method 3

Method 3 of 4:

Dealing with a Burnt or Overdone Cake

1
Trim off the burnt parts from the cake. Use a large bread knife to slice off the top or bottom if it's burned. Trim off any burnt parts around the edges by running the knife just under them. Take care to trim off only the burnt portion of the cake, as the rest of it is usually just fine.^{[11]
X
Research source}
- Think of this step as being like scraping off the burnt layer of a piece of toast, except the cake isn't quite as dry, so you'll need to use a knife to gently cut the burnt parts off.
2
Brush simple syrup on a dry, overcooked cake, to moisten it. Add 1 part sugar and 1 part water to a small pot and set it on the stove. Heat the mixture until the sugar melts, stirring constantly. Take the syrup off the heat and add a flavoring, such as an extract or rum. Let the syrup cool and brush a thin layer on the top of the cake before you add icing.^{[12]
X
Research source}
- It may help to poke holes in the cake with a fork to help it absorb the syrup.
- Know that this is not going to save everything. You might still end up with a gummy cake.
3
Layer a dry cake with moist ingredients to make it less dry. If you don't have time to make a simple syrup, apply a thick layer of buttercream frosting in the middle of the cake. Then use moist ingredients on top to decorate, such as fruit or chocolate.^{[13]
X
Research source}
- If your cake is only 1 layer, you'll need to cut it in half with a large bread knife to add frosting to the middle.

Method 4

Method 4 of 4:

Solving Removal and Cutting Problems

1
Release a cake from the pan with a knife. If your cake is stuck in the pan, slide a sharp knife between the pan and the edge of the cake all the way around. Use your hands to whack the sides and bottom of the pan a bit to help release the cake, then leave it to cool for 15 minutes.^{[14]
X
Research source}
- After 15 minutes, try to turn out the cake again. If it still comes out a mess, see the suggestions above for turning it into trifle, cake balls, or another broken-cake recipe.
- If you remove the cake too quickly from the pan, it may lose its shape or stick.
2
Level an uneven cake with a sharp knife. Sometimes, your cake may rise unevenly. If that's happened to you and you want an even top, just use a sharp bread knife to cut off the uneven part. You now have an even and smooth top for frosting.^{[15]
X
Research source}
3
Refrigerate cake layers if they tear when you try to cut them. Warm cake layers are more likely to crumble or tear. If you're trying to cut layers in half, leave them in the refrigerator for at least 30 minutes to cool down, then try again.^{[16]
X
Research source}
4
Finished.

Community Q&A
Did you know you can get answers researched by wikiHow Staff? Unlock staff-researched answers by supporting wikiHow

Question

Why did all the fruit in the cake fall to the bottom?

wikiHow Staff Editor
Staff Answer
This answer was written by one of our trained team of researchers who validated it for accuracy and comprehensiveness.

wikiHow Staff Editor

Staff Answer

Support wikiHow by unlocking this staff-researched answer.

This can be tricky to work out but some of the reasons might be: 1. The oven door was opened too soon during baking; 2. The cake batter was not thick enough and failed to hold the fruit in place; 3. The fruit was not covered in flour before adding it (where the recipe called for this); 4. If using glazed fruit, the syrup wasn't washed off. Check also that the right type of fruit was used as called for by the recipe (fresh, dried, glazed, etc.) and that the amounts were accurate.
Question

Why did my cake batter curdle?

wikiHow Staff Editor
Staff Answer
This answer was written by one of our trained team of researchers who validated it for accuracy and comprehensiveness.

wikiHow Staff Editor

Staff Answer

Support wikiHow by unlocking this staff-researched answer.

Curdling can occur when the ingredients are a mixture of room temperature ingredients with ingredients that are either too hot or too cold; next time ensure all ingredients are at room temperature. Or, you may have added the egg too quickly and failed to beat it sufficiently into the other ingredients; this can be avoided next time by adding a tablespoon of flour with the egg (take the tablespoon from the overall amount of flour for the recipe) and beating the egg in more slowly.
Question

My bundt cake is too moist. How can I fix it?

Community Answer

A cake that is too moist is often under baked, so you could try to continue the baking process until it is baked. Other reasons behind an overly moist cake include failing to completely cool it before storing or frosting the cake or storing it in too warm a place. Try putting the cake in a dry, cool place to let the moisture come out in a day. If it doesn't improve, add the cake to a dessert dish.