Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on tourism
The COVID-19 pandemic has impacted the tourism industry due to the resulting travel restrictions as well as slump in demand among travelers. The tourism industry has been massively affected by the spread of coronavirus, as many countries have introduced travel restrictions in an attempt to contain its spread.[1] The United Nations World Tourism Organization estimated that global international tourist arrivals might decrease by 58% to 78% in 2020, leading to a potential loss of US $0.9–1.2 trillion in international tourism receipts.[2]
Part of a series on the |
COVID-19 pandemic |
---|
|
COVID-19 portal |
In many of the world's cities, planned travel went down by 80–90%.[3] Conflicting and unilateral travel restrictions occurred regionally[4][5] and many tourist attractions around the world, such as museums, amusement parks, and sports venues closed down. UNWTO reported a 65% drop in international tourist arrivals in the first six months of 2020.[6] Air passenger travel showed a similar decline.[7] The United Nations Conference on Trade and Development released a report in June 2021 stating that the global economy could lose over US$4 trillion as a result of the pandemic.[8]
Tourism under the pandemic
Some have taken advantage of airlines drastically reducing their fares to travel for leisure despite multiple warnings to remain at home, along with two-week self-quarantine requirements upon arrival or return from travel.[9] A number of college students tested positive for COVID-19 after returning from traditional spring break destinations such as the Florida beaches, South Padre Island, and Cabo San Lucas.[10]
Dubai received global scrutiny for opening tourism too soon, despite a high rate of COVID-positive cases detected in the emirate. At least 300,000 people travelled to and from UAE and the U.K. in the months of November and December 2020. In the early months of the pandemic, the situation was reportedly handled well by the emirate. However, around New Year's Eve tourists and locals were reported to be attending parties without social distancing or face-masks. Accusations that Dubai was acting as a "super-spreader" of the virus forced the emirate to close all bars and pubs for a month on 1 February 2021.[11]
Tourism and vaccination
Many tourism venues such as museum, visitor centers, restaurants, hotel mandate COVID-19 vaccination for their staff and/or visitors, and such venues are known as "vaccinated venues".[12] Research has shown that tourists have varying levels of belief on COVID-19 vaccination in terms of its effectiveness and side effects, which have impact on the preferences of tourists to preference to visit or use "vaccinated venues".[12]
Travel restrictions
As a result of the pandemic, many countries and regions have imposed quarantines, entry bans, or other restrictions for citizens of or recent travellers to the most affected areas.[13] Other countries and regions have imposed global restrictions that apply to all foreign countries and territories, or prevent their own citizens from travelling overseas.[14]
Together with a decreased willingness to travel, the restrictions have had a negative economic impact on the travel sector in those regions. A possible long-term impact has been a decline of business travel and international conferencing, and the rise of their virtual, online equivalents.[15] Concerns have been raised over the effectiveness of travel restrictions to contain the spread of COVID-19.[16][17]
By country and continent
Cambodia
Foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 65% year-on-year.[18] Angkor Wat, usually crowded with thousands of tourists per day, was left almost deserted, with an average of 22 ticket sales per day for the whole Angkor National Park during April 2020.[19][20][21]
Cambodia has banned entry of foreign visitors from six countries – the United States, Italy, Germany, Spain, France, and Iran – since mid-March and has imposed entry restrictions for all foreigners since 30 March to curb COVID-19.[22]
Cambodia's tourism industry, which amounted to 4.92 billion US dollars, is currently being hit hardest by the ravaging pandemic. A tourism data showed that Cambodia received a total of 223,400 foreign tourists in March, a decrease of 65 percent over the same month last year.[23] More than 600 hotels nationwide had closed by June, and more than 10,000 tourism sector staff were made unemployed.[21]
China
Tourism in China has been hit hard by travel restrictions and fears of contagion, including a ban on both domestic and international tour groups.[24]
Hong Kong
Foreign arrivals in February 2020 fell by 96% year-on-year and by 99% year-on-year in March 2020.[25][26]
Cyprus
Foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 67% year-on-year.[27]
Singapore
Tourism has been hit hard by the COVID-19 pandemic, amid social distancing rules since 26 March 2020, including a ban of organised domestic tours and all tourist attractions closed.[28]
Indonesia
Foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 64.11% year-on-year.[30]
Israel
Israel closed its borders to international tourists early on in the COVID-19 pandemic. Overall, the number of international tourists who visited Israel in October 2020 stood at 738,000; compared to the same time period in 2019, when approximately 3.295 million tourists visited Israel. In October 2020, the Israeli tourism industry lost about 12.1₪ billion since January.[31]
Japan
Foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 94% year-on-year.[32] By mid-April, daily arrivals of foreigners had fallen by nearly 100% year-on-year.[33]
Malaysia
On 16 March 2020, the Ministry of Tourism, Arts and Culture announces that several tourist attraction around Malaysia will remain closed until 30 March 2020 which includes tourist information center, National Arts Gallery, craft centers, Lenggong Archaeological Museum, National Archives of Malaysia, memorial centers and National Library of Malaysia.[34]
South Korea
In South Korea, Korea Association of Travel Agents asked for government support to offset the industry's ballooning losses from a slew of travel cancellations since the COVID-19 pandemic. South Korea's largest travel agencies, Hana Tour and Mode Tour, either, reporting 10 billion won in damage from cancellations.[35]
Foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 95% year-on-year.[36]
Sri Lanka
Foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 70.8% year-on-year.[37]
Thailand
The current outbreak of a new coronavirus disease (COVID-19) in Thailand is a crisis for the tourism industry and economy.[38] Foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 76% year-on-year, and tourist spending fell 78% year-on-year.[39] With the Thai border closed and most international flights banned since 4 April, both tourist arrivals and spending in April 2020 have fell to zero.[40]
Turkey
Foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 68% year-on-year.[41]
Vietnam
Foreign arrivals in April 2020 fell by 98% year-on-year.[42]
United Arab Emirates
Due to coronavirus pandemic, Dubai's passenger traffic went down by 70% in 2020. Surging cases have led the UAE's government to prompt countries to halt flights to the country.[43]
Bahrain
In efforts to control the spread of Covid-19, various travel restrictions in Bahrain led the tourism sector to witness losses over BD 1 billion. As stated by Bahrain’s Industry, Commerce and Tourism Minister Zayed Alzayani, the country lost nearly BD 108 million per month following plunge of 29,000 visitors per day.[44]
Bosnia and Herzegovina
[45] The number of foreign tourists who visited Bosnia's Federation in March plummeted 79% on the year, to 9,660, the entity's statistical office said.
Foreign tourists spent 19,089 overnights in the Federation in March, down 77% year-on-year, the Federation's statistical office said on Wednesday.
The total number of tourists who visited the Federation in March fell by 75% on the year to 16,186. Total tourist overnights decreased by 73% to 31,881.
Foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 79% year-on-year.[45]
Bulgaria
Bulgaria banned the entry of foreigners in March due to the coronavirus epidemic.[22]
Foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 44% year-on-year.[46] Travelers from Greece and Serbia on business trips or with family ties, and diplomats, humanitarian and transport workers will be allowed to enter Bulgaria from 1 June without undergoing a 14-day quarantine, said Bulgarian Premier Boyko Borisov.
Croatia
Early data indicated that foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 75% year-on-year.[47]
Greece
Foreign arrivals fell by 47% year-on-year and tourism revenue fell by 71% year-on-year in March 2020.[48]
Hungary
Foreign arrivals fell by 99% year-on-year and domestic tourism fell by 95% year-on-year in April 2020.[49]
Serbia
Foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 66% year-on-year.[50]
Slovenia
Foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 78% year-on-year.[51]
Spain
Foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 64% year-on-year.[52] In May 2021, a report showed that tourism had fallen 76% during the month of March. The numbers showed a plummet of 90% considering the time previous to the pandemic of March 2019 but still higher than registered last February 2021. The government registered the visit of more than 109,000 French citizens but only 18,000 British citizens during March 2021.[53]
Australia
Tourism bodies have suggested that the total economic cost to the sector, as of 11 February 2020, would be A$4.5 billion. Casino earnings are expected to fall.[54] At least two localities in Australia, Cairns and the Gold Coast, have reported already lost earnings of more that $600 million.[55]
The Australian Tourism Industry Council (ATIC) called on the Government of Australia for financial support especially in light of the large number of small businesses affected.[56]
In March, national travel agency Flight Centre has indefinitely closed 100 stores throughout Australia, due to significantly lower demand for travel.[57] It also suffered a 75% decline in share price,[58] and announced that 6,000 staff would be made redundant or placed on unpaid leave globally.[59]
Fiji
Tourism in Fiji has been affected greatly by the global pandemic
Costa Rica
Foreign arrivals in March 2020 fell by 51% year-on-year.[60]
Mexico
The Consejo Nacional Empresarial Turístico (National Tourism Business Council, CNET) sent two letters in March to Alfonso Romo, Chief of Staff to the President of Mexico, asking for government support for the sector. Tourism in Mexico suffered the closure of 4,000 hotels (52,400 rooms) and 2,000 restaurants, while the airline industry lost MXN $30 billion (US$1.3 billion) through March.[61]
United States
Tourism in Hawaii went on hiatus. Tourist arrivals in Hawaii down nearly 100% in April 2020[62] and its 14-day mandatory quarantine kept tourism low.[62] A number of tourists who came to the state but did not follow the quarantine were arrested.[63] In June 2020, Hawaii had still not set a date for reopening to out-of-state tourism.[64] As of 16 June, the quarantine would be lifted for inter-island tourism.[65]
Florida tourism had a year-over-year 11% drop in the first quarter of 2020.[66]
During the pandemic in Door County, Wisconsin, hundreds of seasonal residents relocated to the county earlier in the spring than they typically do.[67]
In 2020, staycations became popular in the United States, where most people spent their vacation time at or close to home. Most vacation travel was done by car, as gas prices are low and many people prefer to wait to the last minute to plan trips due to uncertainties. There were sharp declines in travel by air, cruise ship, bus and rail.[68]
Brazil
As the 2nd largest hit country by the COVID-19 pandemic, after the US, Brazil's tourism industry suffered greatly. Tourism's net contribution to the Brazilian nominal GDP in 2020 saw a 53% decrease since last year (270.8B BRL and 143.8B BRL, respectively).[69]
By sector
Airlines
Casino industry
In Macau, the world's top gambling destination by revenue, all casinos were closed for 15 days in February 2020[70] and suffered a year-on-year revenue drop of 88%, the worst ever recorded in the territory.[71]
On 17 March, Nevada Governor Steve Sisolak ordered all casinos closed for 30 days.[72]
Cruise industry
Cruise lines had to cancel sailings after the outbreak of the pandemic. Bookings and cancellations grew as extensive media coverage of ill passengers on quarantined ships hurt the industry's image. In May 2020, Norwegian Cruise Line posted a quarterly loss of $1.88 billion[73] and warned it may go out of business.[74]
Hotel industry
On 11 April 2020, only 3 percent of hotels in Austin, Texas were occupied. On this date, 342 rooms were occupied, compared to the 10,777 rooms that had been occupied on the same date in 2019.[75]
Rental car industry
Hertz Global Holdings Inc. filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy on 22 May 2020. It had not been given access to the funds that the United States designated to bail out airlines.[76]
Restaurant industry
The pandemic has affected the global food-industry as authorities close down restaurants and bars to slow the spread of the virus. Across the world, restaurants' daily traffic dropped precipitously compared to the same period in 2019.[77] Closures of restaurants caused a ripple-effect among related industries such as food production, liquor-, wine-, and beer-production, food and beverage shipping, fishing, and farming.[78][79]
The impacts on the job market
The World Health Organization reported the coronavirus as a global health risk at the end of January 2020. Many businesses stopped their operations, and many of them were unable to survive during this crisis. There was a large number of bankruptcies, lay-offs, and requests for aid. As people needed to survive without income, many people applied for unemployment in the United States. Tourism is one of the industries that was impacted deeply, and some of the companies are still struggling with the labor shortage issue as employees prefer to stay at home. For instance, there are a couple of airlines that have cancelled a huge number of their flights in the United States in past couple of weeks due to this issue.[80] Budget hotels are hugely impacted due to their characteristics, and are vulnerable as they are mostly owned by individuals lacking finances, manpower, strategy, or a plan to overcome the crisis.[38]
See also
- Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the arts and cultural heritage
- Love is not tourism
- Sustainable tourism
- Vaccination requirements for international travel
References
- "BBC Business News". BBC News. Retrieved 25 May 2020.
- "International Tourist Numbers Could Fall 60–80% in 2020". unwto.org. Retrieved 16 September 2020.
- Team, The Visual and Data Journalism (28 March 2020). "Coronavirus: A visual guide to the pandemic". BBC News. Archived from the original on 27 March 2020.
- "EU's Politics-Oriented Approach To Border Reopening Is Risking Recovery". Schengen Visa Info. 13 July 2020. Archived from the original on 13 July 2020.
- "Airlines and Airports Warn European PMs on Inconsistent Approach to Travel Restrictions". Schengen Visa Info. 4 August 2020. Archived from the original on 16 August 2020.
- "International Tourist Numbers Down 65% in First Half of 2020". unwto.org. Retrieved 16 September 2020.
- "Airlines may need to retool routes with decline in business travel". Marketplace. 26 August 2020. Retrieved 6 November 2020.
- United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (30 June 2021). "COVID-19 and Tourism: An Update" (PDF). Retrieved 30 June 2021.
- Hoffower, Hillary (23 March 2020). "'It's Gen Z you want': Millennials are defending themselves from accusations that they're out partying and ignoring warnings amid the coronavirus pandemic". Business Insider. Retrieved 20 April 2020.
- Hoffower, Hillary (2 April 2020). "44 Texas spring breakers who partied in Cabo have tested positive for the coronavirus". Business Insider. Retrieved 20 April 2020.
- "Dubai Faces Festering Tourism Challenges Beyond Pandemic". Skift. 5 March 2021. Retrieved 5 March 2021.
- Zhang, S.X.; Chen, J.; Alvarez-Risco, A.; Del-Aguila-Arcentales, S.; Yanez, J.A. "Preference for vaccinated venues: the roles of belief in COVID-19 vaccine adoption rate and side effects". Current Issues in Tourism: 1–5.
- "Coronavirus Travel Restrictions, Across the Globe". The New York Times. 26 March 2020.
- "Coronavirus (COVID-19) – information for Australian travellers". Australian Government. 9 April 2020.
- "The long-term effects of the coronavirus". The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com. Retrieved 12 March 2020.
- Nsikan, Akpan (24 February 2020). "Coronavirus spikes outside China show travel bans aren't working". National Geographic. Retrieved 2 April 2020.
- Rowen, I. (2020). The transformational festival as a subversive toolbox for a transformed tourism: lessons from Burning Man for a Covid-19 world. Tourism Geographies, 22(3), 695-702.
- "Cambodia's international arrivals nosedive 65% in March | The Star". The Star. Malaysia. Retrieved 7 May 2020.
- Hunt, Luke. "Cambodians Reclaim Angkor Wat as Global Lockdowns Continue to Bite". thediplomat.com. Retrieved 11 November 2020.
- "Cambodians Revel in Now Tourist-Free Angkor Wat | Voice of America – English". Voice of America. Retrieved 11 November 2020.
- "Tourists amazed about seeing Angkor Wat without usual crowds". South China Morning Post. 6 June 2020. Retrieved 11 November 2020.
- "The Jakarta Post – Always Bold. Always Independent". The Jakarta Post. Retrieved 25 May 2020.
- "The Jakarta Post – Always Bold. Always Independent". The Jakarta Post. Retrieved 25 May 2020.{{failed verification
- Tan, Huileng (28 January 2020). "China's travel restrictions amid coronavirus pandemic will hit other Asian economies". CNBC. Archived from the original on 29 January 2020. Retrieved 31 January 2020.
- "UPDATE 1-Hong Kong February retail sales post record fall on coronavirus spread". Reuters. 31 March 2020. Retrieved 25 April 2020.
- "Hong Kong Tourism Board Says Visitor Arrivals to Hong Kong Drops 98.6% Y/Y In March". Yahoo! News. Retrieved 26 April 2020.
- Michael, Peter (21 April 2020). "Coronavirus: Tourist arrivals see steep drop in March". Cyprus Mail. Retrieved 25 April 2020.
- "Jail terms, fines for those who breach COVID-19 safe-distancing rules, stay-home notice". 27 March 2020. Retrieved 27 March 2020.
- "News for Airlines, Airports and the Aviation Industry | CAPA". centreforaviation.com. Retrieved 27 April 2020.
- "Indonesia's March foreign tourist arrivals plunge 64%". Reuters. 4 May 2020. Retrieved 7 May 2020.
- "Israel's tourism sector lost $3.6 billion so far in 2020, minister says". Reuters. 14 October 2020. Retrieved 31 March 2021.
- Submission, Internal (15 April 2020). "March visitors to Japan plunged 94% from year earlier due to virus curbs". The Japan Times. Retrieved 25 April 2020.
- "Foreign visitors to Japan fall 99.9% amid pandemic". Nikkei Asian Review. Retrieved 25 April 2020.
- Chin, Chester (16 March 2020). "National Art Gallery, Muzium Negara, among cultural institutions closed amid Covid-19 fear". The Star. Archived from the original on 21 March 2020. Retrieved 16 March 2020.
- "Korean tour industry seeks gov't help to prevent chain bankruptcies". pulsenews.co.kr. 11 February 2020.
- 김보람 (25 April 2020). "Number of foreign tourists nose-dives in March amid coronavirus pandemic". Yonhap News Agency. Retrieved 25 April 2020.
- "Sri Lanka marks a year since devastating Easter Sunday attacks". Al Jazeera. Retrieved 25 April 2020.
- Pandey, Janak Nandan. (2021). "Crisis management and COVID-19: the case of budget hotels in Muang Chiangmai District". International Journal of Society Systems Science. 13: 71–87. doi:10.1504/IJSSS.2021.115870. S2CID 242184568. Retrieved 18 October 2021.
- Limited, Bangkok Post Public Company. "March foreign tourist arrivals tumble 76.4% y/y". Bangkok Post. Retrieved 25 April 2020.
- "Thailand Had No Foreign Tourists in April After Closing Borders". Bloomberg. 29 May 2020.
- "Foreign tourist arrivals to Turkey plunge 68% y/y in March". SeeNews. Retrieved 30 April 2020.
- "International visitors to Vietnam in April decline 98.2 percent year-on-year". SGGP English Edition. 30 April 2020. Retrieved 30 April 2020.
- "Dubai airport sees passenger traffic drop 70% amid pandemic". Associated Press. Retrieved 15 February 2021.
- "Bahrain: Tourism Industry Loses $2.65 Billion Due to COVID19". Al Bawaba. Retrieved 14 January 2021.
- "Foreign tourist arrivals to Bosnia's Federation down 79% y/y in March". SeeNews. Retrieved 30 April 2020.
- "Foreign tourist arrivals to Bulgaria drop 43.7% y/y in March". SeeNews. Retrieved 30 April 2020.
- "Croatia reports rise in tourist arrivals in February in last burst of growth before coronavirus crisis". intellinews.com. 10 April 2020. Retrieved 25 April 2020.
- "Τουρισμός: Πικρή πρόγευση για τις επιδόσεις των επομένων μηνών τα στοιχεία α' τριμήνου". Naftemporiki (in Greek). 22 May 2020. Retrieved 5 July 2020.
- "Közel 100 százalékkal csökkent a turizmus forgalma áprilisban". Index.hu (in Hungarian). 5 June 2020. Retrieved 5 June 2020.
- "Foreign tourist arrivals to Serbia slump 65.8% y/y in March". SeeNews. Retrieved 30 April 2020.
- "Foreign tourist arrivals to Slovenia plunge 78% y/y in March". seenews.com. Retrieved 25 April 2020.
- "Spain foreign tourist arrivals slump 64% in March". Yahoo! News. Retrieved 7 May 2020.
- "Spain tourist arrivals slump 76% in March, recovery still far off". Reuters. 6 May 2021. Retrieved 6 May 2021.
- Butler, Ben (5 February 2020). "Coronavirus threatens Australian economy reeling from drought and fires". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Archived from the original on 6 February 2020. Retrieved 12 February 2020.
- Taylor, Josh (11 February 2020). "'Completely dropped off': Australia's tourism industry braces for coronavirus crisis". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Archived from the original on 11 February 2020. Retrieved 12 February 2020.
- "ATIC calls for government support to counter coronavirus impact on tourism industry – Australasian Leisure Management". ausleisure.com.au. Archived from the original on 15 February 2020. Retrieved 14 February 2020.
- "Flight Centre closes 100 stores across Australia due to business impact from coronavirus fears". Australian Broadcasting Corporation. 12 March 2020. Archived from the original on 13 March 2020. Retrieved 12 March 2020.
- "Flight Centre Travel Group Limited Share Price & Information – ASX". ASX. Retrieved 2 May 2020.
- "Flight Centre to stand down thousands of workers due to coronavirus". ABC News. 25 March 2020. Retrieved 1 May 2020.
- "Tourism in Danger by Covid-19: ICT Reports Historical Drop In Arrivals By Air In March". Q COSTA RICA. 16 April 2020. Retrieved 26 April 2020.
- The CNET asks for support while their companies save jobs (in English) by Carlos Velazquez, Dinero en Imagen, 26 March 2020
- Coleman, Justine (4 June 2020). "Top Hawaii tourism official retiring amid coronavirus fallout". The Hill. Retrieved 6 June 2020.
- Campbell, Josh (11 May 2020). "Tourists in Hawaii could face prison time for breaking quarantine". CNN Travel. Retrieved 6 June 2020.
- "Hawaii's Governor Declines to Set a Reopening Date for Tourism". MSN. 3 June 2020. Retrieved 6 June 2020.
- Schaefers, Allison (6 June 2020). "Lifting of interisland quarantine will move Hawaii tourism needle slightly". Honolulu Star-Advertiser. Retrieved 6 June 2020.
- Turner, Jim (1 May 2020). "COVID-19 arrival slashes Florida tourism numbers. Some attractions set to reopen in June". Miami Herald. Retrieved 6 June 2020.
- Door County Board Chair Reveals He Had COVID-19 by Myles Dannhausen Jr., 5 May 2020, doorcountypulse.com
- Hartman, Mitchell (3 July 2020). "Expect more staycations this summer". Marketplace. Retrieved 6 August 2020.
- "COVID-19 in Brazil: Impact on tourism GDP 2021". Statista. Retrieved 31 March 2021.
- "Gamblers hedge their bets as Macau casinos reopen to small crowds". South China Morning Post. 20 February 2020. Retrieved 21 February 2020.
- Sullivan, Lewis. "Macau's gaming revenue fell 88 percent in February". Casino Review. Retrieved 19 March 2020.
- Velotta, Richard N.; Schulz, Bailey (18 March 2020). "Nevada casinos closing for 30 days following state order". Las Vegas Review-Journal. Retrieved 19 March 2020.
- Reuters (14 May 2020). "Norwegian Cruise Line swings to $1.88 billion loss on charges". Yahoo! Finance. Retrieved 14 May 2020.
- Larkin, Michael (5 May 2020). "Embattled Carnival to Resume Some North American Cruises in August". Yahoo! Finance. Retrieved 5 May 2020.
- Edgemon, Erin (16 April 2020). "Austin hotels hit with devastating drops in occupancy, revenue". The Business Journals. Retrieved 23 April 2020.
- Chokshi, Niraj (22 May 2020). "Hertz, Car Rental Pioneer, Files for Bankruptcy Protection". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 23 May 2020.
- "See how much business U.S. restaurants are losing because of the coronavirus". CBS News. Retrieved 22 March 2020.
Globally, sit-down traffic at restaurants that use OpenTable have dropped a whopping 83% from a year ago [...].
- Somvichian-Clausen, Austa (20 March 2020). "How NYC's restaurant industry is surviving amid coronavirus closures". The Hill. Retrieved 22 March 2020.
- Bloom, Jonty (26 March 2020). "How are food supply networks coping with coronavirus?". BBC News. Retrieved 26 March 2020.
- Onyeaka, Helen (2021). "COVID-19 pandemic: A review of the global lockdown and its far-reaching effects". Science Progress. 104 (2): 1–18. doi:10.1177/00368504211019854. PMID 34061685. S2CID 235300232.